Maybe this a question better left to science, but what precisely about a balloon is it that makes its actions entirely determined by the laws of physics?
No, no, that’s a question for philosophy, and I’m responding because I’m interested (I’m in the process of leafing through OPAR again, and this helps me figure things out), not because I’m feeling charitable, so thank you for asking.
It isn’t the laws of physics causing (or determining) the balloon to act in a certain way, it is its nature.
The balloon came first. People looked at it, and at many other entities. They studied them, they hypothesized, and finally they realized that the way all the objects they looked at are behaving can be described by a single statement about their nature. A law. Then they did the same and found another law. (there’s more to science than that, of course, but that’s irrelevant to this) So, in fact, the nature of the balloon necessitates the law to be what it is.
The reason for the law being what it is is the nature of the balloon. (and entities, in general) However, going up the ladder, and asking for the reason for the balloon and its nature, next, is meaningless. Existence and identity are axioms. What is, is, and what is has a nature. Why? It just does. The axioms are irreducible primaries, they cannot be deduced from something that precedes them. The reason why we know the axioms are true is because we cannot deny them without implicitly accepting them, as Peikoff explains in OPAR Ch1. He then goes into explaining what Causality, the link between the object’s nature and its actions, is, by first saying how a child would intuit the Law of Causality, then validating it through the Law of Identity, reaching the conclusion: the same entity under the same circumstance will perform the same action.
However, men are volitional entities, meaning that they can choose to have a focused mind, or an unfocused mind, at any point in time. (Chapter 2/ The Primary Choice as the Choice to Focus Or Not) Unlike inanimate objects, men can choose to change the content of their consciousness, whih in turn will cause them to act in a certain way. There are degrees to which a man can choose to focus (a continuous spectrum from nothing to fully focused), and each man has a given context of knowledge, of data which he must analize at a level of “focused” he chooses to be. Depending on the ‘level of focused’ a man is, his consciousness will cause him to act in a certain way. As I am sitting here, if I choose to and am able to fully focus (this counts as one aspect of the ‘circumstance’ I’m in), I will perform the same action. If I instead choose to give into the feeling of sleeplessness, and let my mind slide, my circumstances change, and I will perform a potentially different action. Also, if I am carrying out a course of action, with my mind focused on the task, and I come across a task that I dislike for some reason, I have a choice to unfocus my mind, allow my emotions to take over, which will result in abandoning the unpleasant task that I set out to do.
These are all things that can happen, potentialities observed through introspection by everyone, and also validated by this: volition is axiomatic, since every act of thinking (every item of conceptual knowledge) requires the validation that you indeed can direct your mind to focus. Even if you are making up a reason why this is impossible, you have to admit that you have the freedom to do that, to direct your consciousness to the task. If you find a statement in my posts that contradicts this, or in Peikoff’s books, or anywhere else, that is my error, or Peikoff’s error, or your error in interpreting it. The existence of free will is obvious, and even the act of denying it through argument is an act of proving its existence. In my view, they don’t contradict the statement I bolded, which Peikoff makes in OPAR: the same entity under the same circumstance will perform the same action.
So what precisely about the physical components which make up man is it that permits him to make actions which aren’t entirely determined by physical laws?
Man’s actions and the brain’s functioning are determined by physical laws, but we do not fully know how the brain works. That part is indeed up to science to figure out. Nevertheless, we do know that man is volitional ( A ), and we do know that a balloon acts in pre-determined way ( B ), and I don’t see the contradiction between the two. I cannot vouch for OPAR being error-free (meaning that there cannot be a sentence in it that contradicts another sentence), but I can vouch for those two facts, A and B, and also for fact C , that there are no contradictions in reality.
P.S. What you may be looking for is to validate volition, from causality. That is not a logical requirement (the logical requirement is simply that they do not contradict), since they are both axiomatic concepts. Science could possibly, one day, do that nonetheless, find a logical link between the two, by explaining exactly how the brain works in a neat model of causal interactions of various cells and particles.