As far as motion in place, Aristotle should not be thought of as offering a strange and totally off base theory compared to modern physics. Rather, much of what he writes could work as fluid dynamics. Even assuming Newtonian physics, we can’t disregard when objects move through mediums. If anything, Newton and Galileo underappreciated the notion of objects going through mediums. The way bodies according to Aristotle move to their natural place is similar to how objects of different density move differently in fluids. Aristotle was not wrong about physics in the sense that an astrologist is wrong about the stars influencing your life directly. He was wrong like Newton, in the sense that his theory didn’t predict as much as he had hoped, in the same way Newton could not predict how subatomic particles move. In the world we live in, moving through air and water, Aristotle’s observations and analysis are the right approach.
Rovelli, C. (2015). Aristotle’s Physics: A Physicist’s Look. https://doi.org/10.1017/apa.2014.11
Book IV
1 – Bodies are carried to their own place if not obstructed.
2 – Place is compared to a jar. So, to the extent that place is separate, it is not form; to the extent place contains, it is not material.
3 – A thing can not be within itself in the primary sense.
4 – The question of place only comes up because of the question of motion. We don’t need to bother asking about places outside the context of motion, certainly not if the concept place is inductively dependent on motion.
The heavens have no place because nothing surrounds it; if it did have a place, something would be around it. All things are within the heavens.
Place is the limit of the limited.
6 – It might seem like that void is real because things contract or compress. By compressing, it might seem as if void is within the thing because void might seem like the reason it can go into itself.
7 – Things do not need to move by void, alteration is enough. A thing does not need to move into nothingness.
8 – Within the void, nothing is differentiated. Every direction is equally the same, every movement is to the same extent. In this sense void is not treated as simply a vacuum, but the complete absence of anything whatsoever of any particular nature. A true nothingness. At least a vacuum implies some nature of how things move through it.
Aristotle sees movement in place as always through a medium.
9 – Some people think that things can compress because they contain void.
Being smaller or larger, in the sense of being compressed or expanded, really has to do with material, not so much a movement in place. The material would have to do with the potential of something to be smaller or larger.
10 – Find the impasses deliberately. Aristotle likes to find ways to get stuck in reasoning, I would say as a way to question common sense assumptions that might otherwise be hard to notice.
Time is not composed of nows. Each successive now is destroyed. Time is like part of a circuit, but not a circuit itself. In these ways, now is not exactly a time.
11- Time is only perceived when there is motion so in this sense time must have something to do with motion.
Time is a number of motion fitting along before and after. It is a number of motion as what has been counted, in the same way that 5 might be a number of particular horses in front of you.
Time is motion only insofar as motion has number.
The now is not time, in the same way that a point is not a line or part of a line. Instead, now is an attribute of time.
12 – Time is a measure of motion. Time is a number of change as being counted.
Things are in time just as things are in number. They are not within a literal time as a physical space, but within time because they belong to the concept time. Spacetime treats time as a space, but I suspect that the technical definition that Einstein used of time is different than what Aristotle used, not as an improved definition, but referring to something else.
14 – If there can’t be a counter, there can’t be anything counted. This might sound like primacy of consciousness, but Aristotle treats time as only a measurement. Time is not something primary, entities are primary, so its existence already depends on concrete things. Furthermore, motions must be measured - the resulting measurement, time, only exists after someone does the measuring. This whole chapter has a lot about measurement.
Time is like a circle because change of place can be uniform, circular motion is the most uniform, and all motions are measured by time.
Book V
1 – The form is not moved. It is motionless, as it is a state of being that things move towards, and does not itself exist independently.
Change from:
one subject to another = motion to contraries
subject to what is not that subject = destruction
from what is not a subject to the subject = coming into being.
2 – Motionless things are considered at the rest if they have the capacity to move.
There is no change of a change.
3 – The continuous has limits that touch, are the same, and hold together. This would be like a relay race.
4 – When something is continuous, and its ends are one, the motion is one.
5 – Things that do not have contraries, change from them is contrary to change to them. Coming into being has no contrary since that which doesn’t exist can’t itself change into a state of existence. But if change from existing into nonexisting is destruction, then doesn’t coming into being have a contrary? Perhaps the question is about if there is a contrary that can become the thing that changed, in the way you can go from sick to healthy to sick again.
6 – Is rest a coming to a standstill? Does movement by force or by nature affect this?
Book VI
1 – The continuous is always divisible so what touches whole to whole is not continuous.
2 – Disproving Zeno. If the parts are finite, then passing through them is finite in time, if the part can measure the whole.