btw this is not a real problem!!! I’m just studying Objectivism and trying to get a better grasp of concepts! Although some of these situations may be less likely, they are still very possible. Lets just assume negotiation does not work.
It is against the law to make sounds exceeding 140 Db except by special permit, as this will cause permanent damage to the inner ear.
Since this is the objectively defined limit, as to not cause physical injury, my neighbour is therefore allowed to play music at 139Db exactly?
( a ) No person shall disturb the peace and quiet of the City to the annoyance of citizens by any unnecessary outcry in the day or night season, upon the streets, alleys or public grounds in the City, or upon any private premises, or permit to be made any loud, unnecessary outcry or noise in conducting any kind of business in the streets, alleys, public or private grounds or premises.
( B ) Whoever violates this section is guilty of a minor misdemeanor.
( Ord. 22-93. Passed 4-5-93. )
What is considered an unnecessary outcry? by what standard?
Is disturbing the peace noises over 140Db? or is it a noise level set by measuring the standard Db of 1000 sample people’s voices?
Is a women reuniting with an old friend from school, screaming and dancing in delight, disturbing the peace and quite of the city?
People have the right to sufficient peace and quiet to get a good sleep
Yes, they do. On their own property. So I cant go claiming a right to peace and quite when I go over to a friends house. I can either leave or stay and suffer the noise.
A does not have the right to keep B awake by making a lot of unnecessary noise. There are laws on the books dealing with this kind of misdemeanor. If A makes too much noise and keeps B awake thereby, then B can make it A’s problem by summoning the law.
ok, makes sense again… I’m starting to get it here. A does not have the right to keep B awake if B is on his own property. Now…
A can only playing music up to 140Db. Since it is hard to judge by some sort of objective standard what exactly is disruptive… apart from the point where you cause bodily harm to your neighbor.
So the solutions would be:
Negotiation, which would work in most cases
if not then you could build sound proofing for your house
or you could move?