Rooting For Particular Athletes/teams

There is a thread discussing sports in general already.

http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.p…c=930&hl=sports

I started this thread to address a slightly different question. Taking the good of sports as a given, how does one decide what specific athlete or team to root for? I’ve had some difficulty trying to determine what, if any, objective criteria guide one’s decision.

Based on my own attitudes, and my discussions with others about theirs, this seems largely influenced by one’s upbringing or a place that otherwise acquires significance in his life. I’ll provide some info about myself to illustrate.

My favorite teams are the Boston Red Sox, N.E. Patriots, Boston Celtics, and Nebraska Cornhuskers (football). I also like the Baltimore Orioles and Washington Redskins.

I grew up near Boston. I go to school in Nebraska. My parents grew up in Maryland, and my dad grew up an Orioles and Redskins fan.

Also, I find myself rooting for Danica Patrick, the woman Indy driver competing in the Indy 500 as I type this. I’d like to see history made. I like to see things happen that might inspire people with irrational beliefs to challenge those beliefs. Is this rational?

So, the question is, what objective criteria cover this?

I’ve got more questions, but I’ve got the end of a race to watch.

I don’t root for teams; in general I’m not particularly interested in team sports and I certainly don’t “follow” them. However, when I watch the Olympics I definitely find myself rooting for specific individual atheletes.

If I were to articulate my method of approaching this idea, it would sound something like this:

I start out rooting, in general, for the Americans, because I have more connection with them than I do with any of the other atheletes.

I try to watch how the individual atheletes perform in the initial trials. It’s easy to single out who is REALLY pushing their will to the absolute maximum, who is refusing to give in to injuries or accidents or up-and-coming challengers.

Then, if they perform some particularly impressive stunt, I’m hooked, and I root for them to win at the end. This is why I wound up dancing around the room when Paul Hamm won the gold for Men’s gymnastics last year.

I was definitely rooting for Danica Patrick today at the 500! A near-win…but I’m very happy with how she placed.

Based on my own attitudes, and my discussions with others about theirs, this seems largely influenced by one’s upbringing or a place that otherwise acquires significance in his life. 

Rooting for a team because they’re local implies some kind of collectivism. I’ve heard many a “fan” say that they root for the local team even though the local team consistently loses. They believe that loyalty to a losing team holds a value. They believe that they have a duty to root for a team from their locale. This is incorrect. The error comes from determinism, where people mistakenly believe that they are “determined” to be a certain way because of their physical location. This is false; we have free will.

I’ve also heard many people say, “we won!” when the person speaking has absolutely nothing to do with the winning. The athlete won. The coach could say they won in that they coached a winning team. The owner of the team could say they won because they own the team. But the fat guy on the couch watching TV with a beer in his hand didn’t do anything to make the team win. In this case, they are taking credit for another person’s achievements. It would be correct to say, “my favorite team won,” but not to say, “we won.”

Also, I find myself rooting for Danica Patrick, the woman Indy driver competing in the Indy 500 as I type this.  I’d like to see history made.  I like to see things happen that might inspire people with irrational beliefs to challenge those beliefs.  Is this rational?

Enjoying watching achievement is rational. I myself enjoy the Olympics. I particularly enjoy watching the equestrian sports, since I ride dressage. I watch other riders in order to learn from those who perform best in my sport. My husband plays tennis, and enjoys watching the tennis matches. In those sports, we are enjoying seeing the best athletes in the world achieving their goals and learning from watching them.

Rooting for someone because you personally know them and care for them is also rational. You want those for whom you care to achieve their goals.

Playing sports vicariously through others and pretending that their achievement is your acheivement is not rational. Rooting for someone because you appreciate their achievement or because you personally know them is rational.

Rooting for a team because they’re local implies some kind of collectivism. 

Do you think this is necessarily so? I understand what people often do, but I’m trying to see what we should do, i.e. what objective criteria are out there. Locality is actually an area in which I think there is a rational reason to root for a specific team. If the local team does well, this often has a good economic impact on your area. Wanting to see successful businesses in the area in which you live sounds pretty rational to me. Do you disagree?

Rooting for someone because you appreciate their achievement or because you personally know them is rational.

I agree, but apart from personal knowledge, how should one choose for whom to root? There are plenty of great achievers in a specific sport.

Oh good grief. Rooting for a team does not, in any way, imply collectivism. My favorite baseball team has always been the Cubs and I went to Texas A&M, so I always root for the Aggies. Neither one have been particularly good in recent years, except for the Cubs 2 years ago. I am not being “collectivist” by rooting for them. Yes, I root for my own university. I can recognize the acheivement of another team (like when Oklahoma beat us 77-0) without being happy about it and while wishing that my own team could perform at that level.

:nuke: No rooting for a team does not imply collectivism. There are some people who do have such low self image that they supplant the accomplishments etc of the team for their own. There isn’t any difference wearing a shirt at the gym like I do that says aynrandbookstore.com than there is when I wear the one that say All Black. Though nobody other than the 1 Aussie gets the All Black shirt.

Where people confuse the whole fans become collectivists thing is when people replace their own self image/life/personality/identity etc with that of the team. It’s the same line where people loose their own identity and replace it with that of the group identitiy.

If you want to expand on the notion, given what today is in the United States, how about the notion of a Memorial Day or a July 4th or any “National” holiday for that matter where “we” celebrate anything. It does go a bit far.

I have friends that root for particular teams because they, for example, went to school with the star pitcher or something like that. Affiliating yourself (by choice) with a particular organization doesn’t NECESSARILY indicate collectivism.

There can be all sorts of reasons to like a particular team. They don’t have to be huge, wrenching, soul-shattering reasons, just A reason is good enough. I like the Dayton Dragons (our local minor-league baseball team) because they have a cool mascot. :slight_smile:

I doubt that many sports fans are fans for truly irrational reasons. I suspect that a very common reason for being a fan of a particular team is that the players on that team were heroes to the fan when he was a kid.

That is certainly true in my case. I grew up in the Detroit suburban area, and players of the Detroit Red Wings, especially Gordie Howe, were my heroes. I moved to California after college, but never stopped being a Red Wing fan, even though the team was terrible for many, many years. I can’t even imagine switching my loyalty to another team.

Sports are the last widely visible bastion of heroism in our culture. As such, it’s perfectly rational to be a fan - indeed, it’s life affirming and a source of emotional fuel in a way that is similar to great art.

Mark Peters

Rooting for a team because they’re local implies some kind of collectivism. 

Are you sure you aren’t painting a kind of broad stroke here? I would support a local team that strives for excellence because it benefits me to live in a city that benefits from a financially successful sports franchise. That is a good selfish reason to support local teams and athletes that has nothing whatsoever to do with collectivism. I would suspect that many fans recognize the need for their local teams to do well as they contribute greatly to the financial wealth of the city in which they live. That has a direct impact on them. This also provides financial opportunities for local vendors.

It can create financial opportunities for individuals as well, even if on a limited basis. For example, as we drove into the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, we noticed that EVERY residence along the main strip (and several other streets as well) for blocks and blocks had rented out their yards for parking spaces. I suspect at 20 dollars a head (which seems a reasonable fee based on the Speedway parking prices and limited availability), some folks made as much as a couple hundred bucks that day. Many had set up grills and were selling hamburgers and drinks. I also suspect that when NASCAR is in town, they do the same though likely on a smaller scale. I would not be surprised if other cities with other major teams and/or sporting events do the same thing.

Are you sure you aren’t painting a kind of broad stroke here?  I would support a local team that strives for excellence because it benefits me to live in a city that benefits from a financially successful sports franchise.  That is a good selfish reason to support local teams and athletes that has nothing whatsoever to do with collectivism.  I would suspect that many fans recognize the need for their local teams to do well as they contribute greatly to the financial wealth of the city in which they live.  That has a direct impact on them.  This also provides financial opportunities for local vendors.

No offence, but this sounds like rationalization. I find it very difficult to believe that anyone cheers on their local sports team because the economic benefits the team’s success brings to the city could potentially increase their wages several years down the line. I agree that sports teams can have beneficial effects on cities, but I dont think this is why most people (or indeed, anyone) actually cheer them on.

I agree that sports teams can have beneficial effects on cities, but I dont think this is why most people (or indeed, anyone) actually cheer them on.

It’s one more thing for me to root for. While I’m in Nebraska, I hope the Huskers do well because the economic impact directly benefits me. It’s not limited to jobs. I benefit from the increased goods and services available. One example is that I have more restaurants and bars to choose from.

Whether or not other people have rational reasons for their decisions, I’m trying to see if there are rational reasons for mine.

Regarding those beneficial effects, they are pretty important, particularly in the smaller cities.

“The Buffalo Sabres hockey team adds $65 million to the local economy in an average year, according to a study issued today by New York State Comptroller Alan G. Hevesi. When the team reaches the playoffs, each home game adds another $2 million.” http://www.osc.state.ny.us/press/releases/feb03/22503.htm

And now that the lockout’s going on, how’s Detroit handling it?

http://www.freep.com/news/metro/areahockey5e_20050205.htm

No offence, but this sounds like rationalization. I find it very difficult to believe that anyone cheers on their local sports team because the economic benefits the team’s success brings to the city could potentially increase their wages several years down the line. I agree that sports teams can have beneficial effects on cities, but I dont think this is why most people (or indeed, anyone) actually cheer them on.

Actually, I’m not sure you can accuse someone (or at least me) of rationalizing without being offensive, but I’m not really worried about it, as I disagree that it’s rationalization, and I know that you are otherwise a reasonable and courteous person on the forum.

That said, I said “many” fans, not “most” fans, and I note your lack agreement on that point as well.

Could it just be your roots as well? I’m a die-hard Green Bay Packer fan (a team owned by the city) and there are several reasons why I root for them. Number 1, I grew up in wisconsin (I live elsewhere now) and many of my best childhood memories come from there (especially watching football with friends) so, it seems natural to remain a fan, as it ties me, and more importantly, my memories to it. Also, it’s just plain entertaining. Green Bay has Brett Favre, who is one of the most entertaining QB’s to ever play. There are several other character players on the team (not hold-out Javon Walker) that make it a fun team to watch. Yes, because the city owns the team, business is boosted in that area. Over half the businesses in that area have some affiliation with the team and it’s really quite a culture up there, that’s different from the rest of the world.

That said, there are other teams that I like (i.e. Redskins, Pittsburgh), usually because of individual players that I enjoy watching (Ben Roesethburg, Joe Gibbs re-surged coaching job, and others). So, by being a Green Bay fan, that doesn’t stop me from liking other teams and/or other players.

A question for football fans here, what do you think of all the recent holdouts?