There have been scattered comments on this board to the effect that rooting for a sports team, particularly a national sports team, is on the collectivist side. Let’s talk about it.
I like Football better than any other sport. I like the Pittsburgh Steelers better than any other NFL team. Given the choice of watching a good game bewteen any two teams (say Packers vs Cowboys) and a not so good game between Pittsburgh and any other team, I’ll watch the Steelers. Why? Why is ti preferable to watch “my” team beat the snot out of the Texans rather than the Dolphins struggle agaisnt the Jets, or the Pats’ new and untested QB try to make a career for himself and win the game?
Because I have an emotional investment in the Steelers that is lacking as regards other teams. They’re “my” team and I rather see them than any other team. I derive more pleasure from their games than anyone else’s. I can enjoy a game I’ve no stake on, say New Orleans vs Phoenix, if the game is good, but there’s no ecstasy of victory. I simply don’t care who wins. I may “adopt” a team for the duration of a game, and I may want to see teams I dislike loose, but the joy there is tepid and insipid.
This seems like sufficent reason for me.
Of course, it’s also no unusual to see teams loose, even the Steelers. And it isn’t unusual for a team to hit a rough patch lasting several years. Then there is little joy and much frustartion I just endure until good times return (which makes me wonder how the fans fo the Cardinals, Saints, Vikings and Falcons, among others, mannage to endure for so long).
When it comes to individual sports, I am more choosy about it. I think it’s ok to attach one’s self emotionally to a nation int he Olympics if that nation deserves admiration on its own terms. therefore I’ll commonly root for the US, UK, Australia, Denmark, most of the countries formerly in the Soviet block and Israel, among a few others. But I’ll also follow an individual athlete regardless of nationality if I admire his or her skills. For example, I liked and rooted for Katarina Witt when she skated for East Germany. She was that good, and good-looking as well, and I figured one cannot blame an athlete for the country the rules say she must compete for (setting aside the fact that she chooses to comepete for that country at all, of course).
About my own country, Mexico, I mostly expect it won’t do too well. That’s based on long experience. But also the spectacle after a bad performance by any Mexican team is so ridiculous and hilarious I’m amazed it’s taken seriously. Every time the national team gets knocked off the World Cup, or the Mexican delegation does badly at the Olympics, there is this tearing of vestments and demands that the government fix sports once and for all. Ah, but if a Mexican athlete has the temerity to enroll in a US college atheltics team, which ahve standards far above Mexico’s, he’s denounced as a traitor and Yankee-lover even if he then competes for Mexico and does better than his teamates (this doesn’t happen often, though). Curiously there is none of that when a mexican player signs up with a pro sports team in America or Europe. Mexican kickers were once all the rage in the NFL adn several of them were very good. Baseball teams in america have hired Mexican players for decades. Anyway, I don’t root for Mexico because it’s irrational to invest in a system so firmly locked into mediocrity.