Rothbard and anarchism

All good responses. I’ll need a few days to respond.

NP man, there is no time limit

If we both agree that all government exists by the consent of the governed, then it’s difficult to see the force of this argument, since the criticisms apply equally to limited government, monarchy, dictatorship, tribal rule, and anything else. The bit about “hoping” is the same, since under limited government one would equally have to “hope” one’s Objectivist gang is more powerful (I’m assuming “more powerful” means “having more popular support”) than say, communists, or that in a monarchy, one would have to hope liberal forces had more support than, say, theocratic ones, etc. Since we agree that government rests on the consent of the governed, and since there is no such thing as a “self-enforcing rule,” then there is no system on God’s green earth that can get around the problem of “guaranteeing” everyone will follow the law. The best system is not one that eliminates such a problem, since no system can eliminate it, but one that does the best job of providing its constituent agents with an incentive to resolve their disputes 1) peacefully, and 2) in a manner consistent with individual rights, then differentiating between the best incentive structure, markets or governments. And again I think a perfectly reasonable case that markets would have a better constitutional structure for securing those two things, can be made.

I will try to redefine the parameters of my argument.

It is very important to clarify what someone means when he says “I support anarchy” or “I support minarchy.” As you have implied, this does not mean that I would rather live in a 1984 dictatorship instead of an anarchist society of Rothbardians, nor would you rather live in Somalia than a state based on the principles of the American Founding Fathers. But when we voice support for anarchy or minarchy, it must also be recognized that we should not be speaking in the some sort of “sim-city”-esque sense of divinely reordering society. Rather, all we can do is attempt to make institutional change within our own limits and except the consequences of said changes. (Bear with me, this is going somewhere.)

I support the establishment of a proper government by Objectivist definitions with a representative republic and voluntary funding. Implied in this support, is a belief in objective law and justice. There is a morally correct way to use force and a virtually infinite number of incorrect ways. As far as I am concerned, the enforcement of proper justice is the only concept for which it is proper to use violence agianst another individual to achieve an end. I do not recognize the validity of any government, gang, private security firm, etc, which does not abide by objective law. Of course it must be noted, that amongst such violators, there is a sliding scale of illegitimacy.

To say, “I support anarchy,” is the same as saying, “I support the rights of individuals to engage in acts of non-objective justice,” or at the very least, “I recognize the rights of such individuals to “compete” with objective lawmen on the open market.” You have tried to evade this issue by relying on “incentive” arguments which all rely on the previously mentioned “sim-city” view of society. But this argument must be brought into concrete form:

Let us say that you are the CEO of a private defense firm in an anarchist society who enforces objective law (or if you disagree with that term, then you enforce the non-aggression principle). Now another firm enters your local market place and attempts to introduce Sharia law (random example of a legal system we can all agree is immoral) onto the population. Does this new firm have a right to “compete” with your firm? Does it have a right to enforce Sharia law onto your firm’s customers or individuals without protection? If your answer to those two questions is “no,” then I fail to see the difference between your version of a “private security firm” and a “government” since your firm is coercively enforcing its legal domain over a territory. If your answer to the questions is “yes,” then I do not understand how you can advocate for the existence of such evil.

Of course just as I advocate for a proper government, yet am met with improper ones, you would surely advocate for the existence of good firms, and yet many bad ones would exist. If this is the case, then why would you prefer to leave the progression towards proper law up to intimidation and fighting on the market instead of civil society and the political process (however flawed that may be)?

And imo, most importantly, even if the stars alligned and we Objectivists achieved the dream of convincing more than half the population to agree with us, would you then support the dissitents rights to form enclaves based on around their beliefs so they could continue state-enforced religious fundamentalism, welfarism, warfarism, extortion, and theft? Or it would it be improperly coercive to force the dissidents to abide by objective laws?

You are arguing for the end of governments with the hope that whatever springs up afterwards will be better than the current state, even if that new thing is just a bunch of de facto smaller states. I am arguing for reforming our current states, or if absolutely need be, tearing them down to build new states. The more I think about this point, the more anarchy seems like a floating abstraction that is impossible to realize, even under optimal conditions. You say that the force within society will be distributed in a way so as to create competition and internalize legal costs. Why would this happen? How would this happen? Would an existing government sell off its weapon assets to the highest bidders? Would the government just stop enforcing laws? These are not just simple transition questions, they lay at the heart of what you are arguing for given the current context of the world.

I think that by leaving such questions blank, or better yet, by saying “the market” will sort them out, anarchists are able to get away without defining their terms and what they actually believe in. It is very easy to say: “in an imaginary world where a bunch of private companies had roughly equal levels of force and provided service to an assorted population sensibly, this is how anarchy would work with incentives and etc.” It is much harder to put into precise terms how or why such terms would be arrived at.

First, insofar as the government is a coercive monopoly, it compels everyone to come to it for justice, and it is in this manner that the customer base is “captive,” since it faces no competition.

But secondly, I suggest that not even the “no taxation necessary” argument works out because a minarchic state would still have to engage in activities that are the moral and economic equivalent of taxation. The US. Postal Service likes to brag that it is not funded by taxes, and this is true, but it remains a coercive monopoly, since competition in the field of first-class mail delivery is illegal. Because of the knowledge and incentive problems notoriously associated with monopolies, the Postal Service inevitably costs its customers more both in actual fees and in quality-related opportunity costs than would a free market in mail delivery. This differential cost may not technically be a direct tax (a “seen,”) but the respects in which it differs from a tax seem neither morally nor economically significant. We may call it a de facto tax (an “unseen.”) A monopolistic legal system will necessarily be engaged in de facto taxation for precisely the same reasons. Hence the taxation-based objection to minarchy essentially stands.

I am sure you are equally aware that no proper government would enforce the exitence of a public post office or other frivilous organization which is not the state’s responsibility. But even at a more practical level, I would much rather except such miniscule levels of theft (the pre-Civil War US gov ran off of about 1% of GDP) over the chronic theft and fear likely to occur under anarchy (if such a thing even exists).

Why, there could just be no reason for anyone to be disatisfied with the government’s service and want to purchase from someone else. Anyone who wants that is clearly an evildoer with malign intentions!

I’m sorry, but this argument is rather unconvincing. Apart from being just a glaring non sequitur, there is the “seen” and “unseen” point about costs and opportunity costs made above. The production of security and law is not, as Gustave de Molinari pointed out in the 19th century, somehow magically exempt from the laws of economics. “Either this is logical and true, or else the principles on which economic science are based are invalid.” Security is not one “lump,” but can be produced in marginal units at varying efficiency. There are as many reasons to both compete with and purchase from someone other than the single monopolist government as there are for competing with and purchasing from anyone else in any other enterprise.

I addressed this issue in my first post of the thread. No, security is not like other goods (and in fact is not a good in any valid sense). The choice between legal systems is not like choosing a cell phone, but rather it must necesarily impact other individuals via the threat or use of force. Unlike other Objectivists, I actually do see room for competition of legal firms under the state’s umbrella. They could compete over speed, location, harshness/leniancy of judges, prices, etc, but then cannot properly compete over which laws are enforced and not enforced.

EDIT: The difference between force and other products is also amply historically demonstrated. Throughout history, virtually all communities organized into force monopolies (governments). This is due to force’s unique property of imposition.

I will try to redefine the parameters of my argument.

It is very important to clarify what someone means when he says “I support anarchy” or “I support minarchy.” As you have implied, this does not mean that I would rather live in a 1984 dictatorship instead of an anarchist society of Rothbardians, nor would you rather live in Somalia than a state based on the principles of the American Founding Fathers. But when we voice support for anarchy or minarchy, it must also be recognized that we should not be speaking in the some sort of “sim-city”-esque sense of divinely reordering society. Rather, all we can do is attempt to make institutional change within our own limits and except the consequences of said changes. (Bear with me, this is going somewhere.)

I support the establishment of a proper government by Objectivist definitions with a representative republic and voluntary funding. Implied in this support, is a belief in objective law and justice. There is a morally correct way to use force and a virtually infinite number of incorrect ways. As far as I am concerned, the enforcement of proper justice is the only concept for which it is proper to use violence agianst another individual to achieve an end. I do not recognize the validity of any government, gang, private security firm, etc, which does not abide by objective law. Of course it must be noted, that amongst such violators, there is a sliding scale of illegitimacy.

To say, “I support anarchy,” is the same as saying, “I support the rights of individuals to engage in acts of non-objective justice,” or at the very least, “I recognize the rights of such individuals to “compete” with objective lawmen on the open market.” You have tried to evade this issue by relying on “incentive” arguments which all rely on the previously mentioned “sim-city” view of society. But this argument must be brought into concrete form:

So far so good, up until the last paragraph. Surely there are “various and sundry anarchists” who advocate whim-worship and all kinds of nonsense, and surely these anarchists would be in opposition to Objectivism. But those types of anarchism do not reflect our position here.

We totally reject the position you describe to us, we do not support the rights of individuals to engage in non-objective justice. The main concern I am reading here is something like the following. The objection is that defense services on the market are incompatible with objective law. Critics envision that a patchwork of competing agencies each will have its own set of standards and procedures, some might reflect principles of “objective justice,” some might reflect principles of “non-objective justice.” Without one single coercive monopoly government to impose a uniform set of reliable and just procedures, then these critics foresee that there will be various criminal bands, gangs, warlords, outlaw agencies, etc. (you name it), that will go around performing non-objective justice.

But in fact, since we don’t take that position, we fully support there being one “morally correct way to use force and a virtually infinite number of incorrect ways,” we’re not against there being a uniform, objective law code. We certainly think that’s a good thing. What we challenge is two things: 1) Can the market produce such an objective law code, and 2) Is a free market necessary for such an objective law code, maybe objective law requires market anarchy.

Such thinking is not usually a failing of Objectivists. Take the standard leftists’ argument for government regulation:

  1. Standards of safety and quality are required for goods and services (an premise based on the desirability of the general health and welfare of people, totally compatible with Objectivist ethics.)

  2. The market cannot produce standards of safety and quality (an un-supported assertion.)

  3. Therefore government has to step in and regulate business.

How do Objectivists usually respond to this? We don’t proceed by denying premise (1), that people should just ingest un-safe food and products and just shut up and like it. No, we challenge premise (2), we point out that governmental regulations aren’t necessary to obtain standards of safety and quality, and that people are held responsible for damaging others’ property or person.

Likewise we see this argument:

  1. Individual rights require objective law (a premise supplied by Objectivist ethics and politics.)

  2. Markets can’t produce objective law (an un-supported assertion.)

  3. Therefore there must be a single monopolist government to protect individual rights.

We are not, as you ascribe in your response, denying premise (1), we are not saying that hey, sometimes rights will get violated, sometimes unjust procedures will be applied, but oh well, that’s how it goes. We rather fully agree with such uniform legal standards, we just assert that it is a non sequitur to go from there being a necessity for such standards to therefore a single coercive monopoly being necessary. If we agree that (using your words) there should be “one morally correct way,” whereas another (or possible infinite number of) incorrect ways, then then it does not matter who employs the procedures in question. If one single monopoly agency employs correct procedures, then it is morally right, but so is every other agency which employs correct procedures. If, on the other hand, the one monopoly agency employs incorrect procedures, then it is morally wrong, as is every agency which employs such procedures. Thus, if there is an independent verifiable standard by which to judge legal procedures (and certainly Objectivists of all people believe this is so, because we believe that the principles of justice are grounded in reality and discoverable by human reason), then this argument has no force whatsoever.

I once also opposed anarchy because I was convinced (largely from reading Ayn Rand) of the importance of objective law. Yet not one Objectivist that I am aware of has ever defined exactly what objective law is. If one wants to proceed then, one should begin not by strawmanning the free market position, but explaining exactly what objective law is and then provide reasons why the free market cannot produce it. No one, to my knowledge, has ever done this. There is much more to be said about it, but I’ll leave it here for now since that was the main point in your response.

You are arguing for the end of governments with the hope that whatever springs up afterwards will be better than the current state, even if that new thing is just a bunch of de facto smaller states. I am arguing for reforming our current states, or if absolutely need be, tearing them down to build new states. The more I think about this point, the more anarchy seems like a floating abstraction that is impossible to realize, even under optimal conditions. You say that the force within society will be distributed in a way so as to create competition and internalize legal costs. Why would this happen? How would this happen? Would an existing government sell off its weapon assets to the highest bidders? Would the government just stop enforcing laws? These are not just simple transition questions, they lay at the heart of what you are arguing for given the current context of the world.

I think that by leaving such questions blank, or better yet, by saying “the market” will sort them out, anarchists are able to get away without defining their terms and what they actually believe in. It is very easy to say: “in an imaginary world where a bunch of private companies had roughly equal levels of force and provided service to an assorted population sensibly, this is how anarchy would work with incentives and etc.” It is much harder to put into precise terms how or why such terms would be arrived at.

[…]anarchy (if such a thing even exists).

For this part, I think it’s a lot more interesting. No again, we don’t support just abolishing the state and hoping for the best. I think it is a bit of a misunderstanding. We are in agreement that philosophy, not politics determines the state of affairs of the world. But that does not get rid of the questions of politics. They still do have to be determined. I am not saying that, and there does seem to be a bit of a confusion sometimes with Objectivists, that if we institute the proper government, then the Objectivist movement is over and done and can disband overnight, or that society will turn into Objectivists overnight, and all will be happy. Objectivism and limited government are not immune to any of the “What if’s” and “How’s” you ask. Of course, philosophy will have to get us out of the mess. But once it does, the question still remains: what kind of political institutions do we set up, what kind of political structure does it take to implement our philosophy?

The question of political structure does not mean lack of emphasis on philosophy, nor imply that once the right structure is set up that all is well and the right philosophy will appear out of nowhere. Both questions are complimentary and indispensable in any system. The question of political structure and articulated philosophical principles is a joint undertaking in any political philosophy, articulated principles and incentive structures jointly supplement each other. It is the same in any system. Take the US government for example. There is a constitution, and there is a Bill of Rights. There is a political structure and there is the corresponding philosophic principles. In any political system, it is true that articulated principles come first and ground the system, but once you have that grounding, it doesn’t simply solve all the problems and stop there. It is not enough to simply decree that a government shall do this and shall not do that, and shall be based on this or that philosophy. One must specify a political structure (e.g., separation of powers, checks and balances, etc.) that corresponds to the articulated philosophical principles (pursuit of happiness, liberty, individual rights), and in fact a successful political structure is one that gives individual participants an incentive to act as the articulated principles specify. So the question here is not “what political system will make people into perfect Objectivists or libertarians without philosophy,” that would be a complete misunderstanding. The question is, as I have been suggesting, what political structure does the best job of providing its constituent agents with the appropriate incentives to govern themselves in a manner consistent with rationality, egoism, and individual rights.

Lastly, you ask, in passing, “if such a thing exists.” I think it far more appropriate to ask “Do we ever really get out of anarchy?” Earlier you stated “I support the establishment of a proper government by Objectivist definitions with a representative republic and voluntary funding,” you did not state “I support the establishment of a proper government by Objectivist definitions with a one-man dictator and voluntary funding.” Why is that? After all, it’s not impossible that a one-man dictator could enforce nothing but totally objective law and justice, and people could voluntarily fund him. Even the old French laissez faireists’ strategy for liberty consisted of trying to convert the king to laissez-faire. But you wouldn’t want to do such a thing because you recognize that, even though it might by hypothetically possible, it would be highly undesirable because of the incentive structure such a system would face. You wanted a “representative republic” because you wanted power to be more decentralized, you wanted there to be “separation of powers” and “checks and balances,” in short, you wanted a more polycentric legal system.

Polycentricity is not an “all or nothing” affair, but rather a continuum. Limited government attempts to mimic the functions of the market in providing competition amongst a variety of competing branches, legal interpreters, enforcement mechanisms, and agents. Thus our problem can be one that limited government just doesn’t take constitutionalism and checks and balances far enough, and thus it is an inferior incentive structure. When we speak of constitutional restraints we are presumably not talking merely of words written on a piece of paper. Such paper prohibitions are neither necessary (look at Britain) nor sufficient (look at Soviet Russia) for actually operative constitutional restraints. What matters is a nation’s ‘constitution’ in the original sense of the actual institutions, practices, and incentive structures that are in place. So a constitution in that sense has no existence independent of the actual behavior and interactions of actual human beings. Thus, we can consider a free market society a species of, rather than as an alternative to, constitutionalism.

. Unlike other Objectivists, I actually do see room for competition of legal firms under the state’s umbrella. They could compete over speed, location, harshness/leniancy of judges, prices, etc, but then cannot properly compete over which laws are enforced and not enforced.

And just to key in on this point, because I do have an argument for this, I think this falls prey to the same kind of objections as noted earlier. In this theory, the state can act as a sort of “licensing agency,” granting licenses to act within a certain set of legal rules. First of all, what exactly this means can have varying interpretations (I’ll skip listing all of them for now), but suppose that means something like the state confines itself to imposing only those general principles that are required by objective justice. If one believes, as we both do, in such a single, uniform standard, then what possible objection could you have to this?

Well let’s think what this would look like for a second. We’re supposed to have a variety of competing agencies on the free market, and one organization takes upon itself the job of forcing all the other agencies to conform to the single, uniform standard of objective justice. But it’s the only organization doing this, so then suppose another organization enters that field and competes in the job of being the “licensing agency” certifying in accordance with the same exact principles of justice. Does it then prohibit competition in that field? If so, then it is an unjust aggressor for the same reasons above, for if the coercive imposition of these objective principles of justice is permissible, then it is permissible for anybody. Secondly, it is also undesirable on incentive grounds, since all coercive monopolies (and licensing laws) lack the very checks and balances that make us want competition in the first place, and so this type of argument completely fails on its own grounds.

Before I give a full response, can you give me your definition of anarchy?

The notion that a government can in any manner be objective in the salient sense is historically falsified by the American empire. That there is a centralized force to administer justice only means justice is even more corruptible, if you’re to by the arguments for capitalism offered by many Objectivists.

Beyond the moral issue, there is also the fact that there is no way for economic calculation of a monopoly to take place. Government is monopoly on force, so how do we determine how costly justice is? We submit it to a market place, but statists demand that justice not be a matter of market determination.

Also, for the record, market anarchism does not start with Rothbard. The first in spirit market anarchist was Gustave de Molinari. Rothbard and other respected market anarchists usually admit to his being the first and most robust theory of private justice.

Before I give a full response, can you give me your definition of anarchy?

Sure. I don’t think has any real set meaning, which is why I avoid the term. But in the widest sense, I define it as any social system which does not have a state. (It’s analogous to the term “atheist,” it doesn’t give any positive content, and people of all sorts of different beliefs can be held under the same term.) I define a state as a territorial monopolist on the use of force.

I think Objectivists, through the use of Ayn Rand’s phrase “competing governments” (a phrase rarely used by anarchists themselves) to describe the anarchist system tend to commit packaged-deal fallacies to embody law and order itself into the concept of the state, so that anarchy is not just the absence of a state, but the absence of law and order itself. Obviously by “competing governments” we cannot mean competing states. My guess, then, is that by “government” Rand sometimes means (despite her official definition in any other context besides when talking about anarchy) something like: an institution or set of institutions governing human activity through the application of rules, i.e. something like “law.” Obivously we are not opposed to law and would like to see more law and order.

This may be a very simple question that shows my limited knowledge of anarcho-capitalism, but how can laws, even laws developed by private justice firms on a free market, have any force in an anarcho-capitalist society? In other words, let’s say I accidentally run over my neighbor’s cat. He demands I pay or spend 10 days in prison, or something, and his security firm that he subscribes to backs his claim. And I simply say, “Uhhh … no thanks.” How could the security firm use “law” against me if law is really a form of archy?

I realize I might be missing huge parts of the puzzle here, so enlighten me?

This may be a very simple question that shows my limited knowledge of anarcho-capitalism, but how can laws, even laws developed by private justice firms on a free market, have any force in an anarcho-capitalist society? In other words, let’s say I accidentally run over my neighbor’s cat. He demands I pay or spend 10 days in prison, or something, and his security firm that he subscribes to backs his claim. And I simply say, “Uhhh … no thanks.” How could the security firm use “law” against me if law is really a form of archy?

I realize I might be missing huge parts of the puzzle here, so enlighten me?

I don’t think the answer is any different from what “gives the law force” under government. The question seems to be asking, in effect, what makes the judgments of the legal system “stick,” so to speak. Well so then what happens under government? Surely it is not the fact that some law is written on some piece of paper that “makes it stick,” for as I pointed out, such written guarantees are neither necessary nor sufficient to ensure people act in certain ways. As long as people have free will, nothing external to those people and the institutions they arrange themselves in will “make it stick” or “give it force.” Making a given judgment stick, or giving it force, is the function of the entire system of interlocking agencies, agreements societal norms, and incentive structures that comprise the free market. The idea that there must be one coercive super-agency to make something stick is precisely the idea market anarchism challenges. Even under the supposedly preferred regime of limited government, there is no one branch, let alone one individual officer, who makes such judgments stick. Securing cooperation among the branches of government is the function of checks and balances, separation of powers, etc., not the function of some unchecked superordinate branch. The free market as a constitutional political structure is simply a generalisation of the principle of checks and balances, not the elimination of law and order. Again, as previously stated, the “archy” we oppose illegitimate authority (such as embodied in a coercive monopoly), not law and order itself.

Thanks. But can you do your best to address my particular example? Is the example itself badly misunderstanding the issues? What if, in the case of a minor dispute (where I would be largely free from social ostracism if I declines to abide by some private law demand), if I refused to comply with a demand of justice (repaying for a window that I broke while playing baseball, for another example), what would make the private security firm’s private law demand for justice “stick” if I refused to comply?

It seems to me that force is the only final arbiter, or final means to make a law “stick.” But how is a private market force justifiable in anarchism if I simply refuse to comply?

Sure. I don’t think has any real set meaning, which is why I avoid the term. But in the widest sense, I define it as any social system which does not have a state. (It’s analogous to the term “atheist,” it doesn’t give any positive content, and people of all sorts of different beliefs can be held under the same term.) I define a state as a territorial monopolist on the use of force.

I need something a little more than that. I still don’t really get what you are advocating. Ok, you want a market for law, but what does that mean in concrete terms? Do you want to set up your own private security firm (or someone else to set it up for you) and not be stopped by the state from doing so? And if so, how would you treat competitors and what rights do they have in yourn mind? And furthermore, what are rights?

Maybe I’m not seeing it, but to me you keep falling back on the “sim-city” arguments where you envision anarchy just springing out of nowhere and providing just law (for the most part). Perhaps there isn’t even that much of a difference between what you and I are saying. I see no problem with secession as long as the new government is equally or better suited to protecting individual rights.

Edit: Upon further thought, I think the entire definitions of anarchy and government should revolve around the question of rights. Do non-objective force wielders have the right conduct their own form of justice? If your answer is no, then surely you would support a just force user’s right to destroy the unjust force users. In which case, there is no anarchy, because the legal system is united. Even if their are multiple organizations providing the justice, their cooperation and common idelogy put them on the same level as friendly countries. The only difference would be the existence of some form of profit motive since presumably these organizations would be private enterprises and not charities.

My only concern there is that the profit motive is not necesarily (and in fact almost never) aligned with objective justice. Under such circumstances, we would return to the same issue with legal systems clashing. My question to you is what proof do you have that this would lead to objective law? You have mentioned incentives, but can you clarify?

Thanks. But can you do your best to address my particular example? Is the example itself badly misunderstanding the issues? What if, in the case of a minor dispute (where I would be largely free from social ostracism if I declines to abide by some private law demand), if I refused to comply with a demand of justice (repaying for a window that I broke while playing baseball, for another example), what would make the private security firm’s private law demand for justice “stick” if I refused to comply?

It seems to me that force is the only final arbiter, or final means to make a law “stick.” But how is a private market force justifiable in anarchism if I simply refuse to comply?

The issue would be brought before your security firm and your neighbor’s. Some sort of arbitration would occur and a decision about your fate would be made. However, what decision is made is largely predicated upon the power of each firm in terms of military might. My concern is that essentially the stronger of the two firms could enforce their own decision regardless of the what actually should occur according to objective standards.

If you simply refuse to comply, then presumably yourn neighbor’s security firm will want to arrest you. Whether or not the firm can will depend upon its evaluation of how your firm will react. A gun fight in the street is possible, though expensive and not an attractive option. Rather, one firm would probably just stare down the other.

But what if you didn’t have a firm – decided not to pay the dues or whatnot? then presumably any other person’s “security firm” could simply arrest you without arbitration, and enact their own punishment and rule over your life. I know you aren’t defending the position, just explaining it to me. But it seems like these are real problems with the anarcho-capitalism viewpoint.

The problem I see with it from my limited perspective so far, is that it treats justice as subjective in theory, if not also in practice (even if Rothbard didn’t believe natural rights were subjective). In other words, one security firm could enact its own laws that are contrary to the non-aggression principle, and they would have to be deemed in theory as just, and another security firm would possibly argue against those violations of the non-aggression principle, and then some arbitration would be relaized that may or may not ultimately honor the non-aggression principle.

But justice with regard to man’s rights IS a monopoly. And there should be a consistent defense of those rights across the board.

To put it another way, I can envision two concepts: Man’s rights as one concept, and the entity of justice that enforces the means of protecting man’s rights on the other hand. If man’s rights is a monopoly (in other words, there is an objective understanding of what man’s rights are), then wouldn’t there need to be a monopoly on the entity that protects man’s rights? If it were left up to a set of multiple entities, each with various views toward justice, then there seems to be an interjection of subjectivity in enforcement into the concept of objectivity in justice theory, thus destroying the goal of objective social justice in practical living.

Here’s an example of what I’m thinking of. One “security agency” has clients that agree that prostitution is criminal. Further, the agency agrees to work toward removing prostitution from the society where its clients reside. So, the agency finds a female prostitute, and arrests her, knowing that her security agency will come and arbitrate for her release. Well, even before the arbitration, her rights have already been violated. This is because by having multiple different security agencies with different aims and subjective justice values, the claim to an objective natural right of man is nullified, or at least thrown to the mercy of arbitration.

Another problem I see with it is that certain security agencies will become prevalent along geographical lines, and eventually you will be right back to small nation states, where within those nation states people are back at square one in terms of fighting for their natural rights in presence of an oppressive security agency government.

It seems then that, justice is not a commodity like goods and services are on the free market. Justice (in reference to the right to one’s own life) is an objective fact, and therefore a monopoly. Allowing any government, whether a security agency among many others, or a single “monopolistic” government to violate man’s rights is evil and should be opposed. So it does not really matter with whether you are dealing with a multiplicity of competing governments, or a single government. The fight is still the same, and in fact may be an easier fight when you are dealing with a monopoly of a government.

Making a given judgment stick, or giving it force, is the function of the entire system of interlocking agencies, agreements societal norms, and incentive structures that comprise the free market.

But in a free market there are no societal norms or judgments that are given force or that can be enforced. In the term “free market” the word “free” means: free from force. In the quoted sentence “free market” is a stolen concept – what you are saying is: “we need a market free from force in order to trade in force”.

This is the contradiction commonly accepted and ignored by all “market anarchists”.

Again, as previously stated, the “archy” we oppose illegitimate authority (such as embodied in a coercive monopoly), not law and order itself.

This is the fundamental confusion employed and promulgated by anarchists in general: the ignoring of the difference between initiatory and retaliatory force by grouping them together under the term “coercion”. For the government to say to its citizens “individuals have the right to life so you may not murder each other and if you do, we will put you in jail” is not coercion since rational people refrain from murder willingly. And it is not initiatory force. It is only the publishing of an objective law along with the consequences of what will happen if you initiate force – it is retaliatory in nature.

Initiation of force is always immoral and should be illegal. Retaliatory force is a moral imperative. Government, properly, holds a monopoly on the use of retaliatory force. By using the term “coercive monopoly” anarchists want you to believe that not only is force always bad but so is a monopoly. In fact they are wrong on both counts.

From another thread here is my standard argument against a “market in force”:

There is a fundamental contradiction involved in having a “market in force” and it is impossible to get around.

Markets like minds do not and can not operate by force. “Freedom” means: free from force. When we speak of a free market we mean a market free of force. A “market in force” is not only a contradiction in terms but I believe it makes use of a stolen concept.

The only way to decide the issue is on principle:

  • The only thing that can violate your Rights is force.

  • Therefore, the only civilized interactions among men occur when no force is involved.

  • The only proper function of government is to protect your Rights.

  • It follows then that what government must do is outlaw the use of physical force.

  • You don’t outlaw the use of physical force by making it lawful for men to practice it.

You cannot uphold a principle by violating it.

I need something a little more than that. I still don’t really get what you are advocating. Ok, you want a market for law, but what does that mean in concrete terms? Do you want to set up your own private security firm (or someone else to set it up for you) and not be stopped by the state from doing so? And if so, how would you treat competitors and what rights do they have in yourn mind? And furthermore, what are rights?

Maybe I’m not seeing it, but to me you keep falling back on the “sim-city” arguments where you envision anarchy just springing out of nowhere and providing just law (for the most part). Perhaps there isn’t even that much of a difference between what you and I are saying.

No, I don’t think anything will “spring out of nowhere,” I don’t know why you resort to such wording which is obviously designed to misrepresent. Government is one pattern of social activity supported by individual human agents. The free market is another. When people stop acting is such a way that supports governmental monopoly, and start acting in other ways based on articulated philosophical principles, then that’s where a new form of social organization comes from. It’s the same as we say we want people to change and stop supporting interventionism and, based on articulated philosophical principles, form a limited government. You don’t ask, but I’m baffled, where exactly does this “limited government” come from (as if there is some location occupying some Archimedean point outside of the society that constitutes it)? Does it spring from nowhere?

I see no problem with secession as long as the new government is equally or better suited to protecting individual rights.

If one agency is equally or better suited to protecting individual rights, and the person may withdraw support from one previous organization to a later equal or better agency, then logically you support market anarchism.

Edit: Upon further thought, I think the entire definitions of anarchy and government should revolve around the question of rights. Do non-objective force wielders have the right conduct their own form of justice? If your answer is no, then surely you would support a just force user’s right to destroy the unjust force users. In which case, there is no anarchy, because the legal system is united.

Certainly, I agree that the legal system should protect individual rights, and that this protection should be universal and uniform as needed, but I don’t think it follows that “there is no anarchy.”

If competing courts converge on a shared set of norms, that does not mean they become part of a single monopoly institution. Burger King and McDonald’s products bear more than a passing resemblance to each other, but they are not regarded as the same firm.

My question to you is what proof do you have that this would lead to objective law? You have mentioned incentives, but can you clarify?

Yes, I can clarify. I’m not saying all anarchies would inevitably lead to objective law, I’m pretty sure I said the exact opposite of that earlier. Again, you are not saying that forming a government would automatically lead to objective law. There is emphasis on articulated philosophical principles on the one hand, and emphasis on the best constitutional structure on the other hand. Both a limited government and the free market are forms of constitutional structures, and I think limited government is (largely unbeknownst to its advocates) designed to imitiate the mechanisms of the free market, which are more consistent generalizations of the principle of checks and balances.

Therefore, what I am saying is that the free market does not lack some form of objectivity available to states, and that competition is superior to monopoly for familiar feedback and incentival reasons. It’s the same standard argument against having a monopoly in shoe production, t shirts, ballpoint pens, restaurants, sunglasses, lawn care, stock brokers, etc. that Objectivists would use in every other context.

The problem I see with it from my limited perspective so far, is that it treats justice as subjective in theory, if not also in practice (even if Rothbard didn’t believe natural rights were subjective). In other words, one security firm could enact its own laws that are contrary to the non-aggression principle, and they would have to be deemed in theory as just, and another security firm would possibly argue against those violations of the non-aggression principle, and then some arbitration would be relaized that may or may not ultimately honor the non-aggression principle.

Certainly that is a problem, but not one specific to anarchy. How is it any different with a government? Last time I checked, President Obama had a different interpretation of justice from, say, Ron Paul, and both desired to enact laws which may or may not be in line with the non-aggression principle. So what happens under government? Well, under our system, we have a series of constitutional restraints, you have various checks and balances and so forth, and we have some form of arbitration or deliberation, and the result may or may not honor the non-aggression principle.

That people have differing interpretions of justice is not unique to the free market, it is an all-pervasive fact of human nature, as Locke pointed out in his argument for constitutional government. As he points out, there would be no point in having various competing jurisdictions, separation of powers, and checks and balances, if we all had the same interpretation of justice. So on the free market there are constitutional restraints, and various checks and balances too, that is, there are various institutions and incentives for people to do things. The point of constitutional design is that the government is supposed to be structured in such a way that people have an incentive to work together and reach some reasonable solution rather than fighting it out when they have differing interpretations of justice. So there are also incentives in a market-based legal order for people to work together peacefully rather than fighting it out. In fact, you could argue that they have more incentive, because with defense services being provided on the free market, it’s harder for anyone to externalize their costs, thus people are less likely to choose violent conflict instead of coming to a consensus.

But justice with regard to man’s rights IS a monopoly. And there should be a consistent defense of those rights across the board.

Certainly we agree that there should be a consistent defense of natural rights acress the board. But this does not mean a consistent defense of those rights across the board requires a monopoly, or in your words is a monopoly, because this would make the same mistake as Dormin111 above in regards Burger King and McDonald’s. There is no reason to conflate competition among agencies with competition among ways of doing things. Or are we to assume Burger King and McDonald’s are same firm? DC Comics and Marvel?

But in a free market there are no societal norms or judgments that are given force or that can be enforced. In the term “free market” the word “free” means: free from force. In the quoted sentence “free market” is a stolen concept – what you are saying is: “we need a market free from force in order to trade in force”.

This is the contradiction commonly accepted and ignored by all “market anarchists”.

The phrase “market free from force” is a redundancy, and the proposition “we need a market which sells defense services” is not contradictory, as long as such services themselves are retaliatory in nature, as you yourself are capable of distinguishing below.

This is the fundamental confusion employed and promulgated by anarchists in general: the ignoring of the difference between initiatory and retaliatory force by grouping them together under the term “coercion”. For the government to say to its citizens “individuals have the right to life so you may not murder each other and if you do, we will put you in jail” is not coercion since rational people refrain from murder willingly. And it is not initiatory force. It is only the publishing of an objective law along with the consequences of what will happen if you initiate force – it is retaliatory in nature.

Initiation of force is always immoral and should be illegal. Retaliatory force is a moral imperative. Government, properly, holds a monopoly on the use of retaliatory force. By using the term “coercive monopoly” anarchists want you to believe that not only is force always bad but so is a monopoly. In fact they are wrong on both counts.

What? Please cite where I said force is always bad. This is the typical zealous re-hashing of canned talking points which is completely unconnected to anything I wrote.

From another thread here is my standard argument against a “market in force”:

There is a fundamental contradiction involved in having a “market in force” and it is impossible to get around.

Markets like minds do not and can not operate by force. “Freedom” means: free from force. When we speak of a free market we mean a market free of force. A “market in force” is not only a contradiction in terms but I believe it makes use of a stolen concept.

The only way to decide the issue is on principle:

  • The only thing that can violate your Rights is force.

  • Therefore, the only civilized interactions among men occur when no force is involved.

  • The only proper function of government is to protect your Rights.

  • It follows then that what government must do is outlaw the use of physical force.

  • You don’t outlaw the use of physical force by making it lawful for men to practice it.

You cannot uphold a principle by violating it.

Okay. Cool. I’m not proposing making it lawful for men to initiate force. It is a non sequitur to go from hey, aggression should be outlawed, to ergo we must have a coercive monopoly government.

A MISSING PIECE IN THE DISCUSSION: HOW TO DEFINE “TERRITORY”

2046 is making, in my opinion, a brilliant defense of anarchism.

I have no way to argue. I declare myself defeated: I have exhausted my ideas on how to defend the possibility of a proper monopoly of force within a given territory, IF territory is defined by the currently existing borders between nation-States…

This in no way undermines the metaphysics, epistemology, ethics and esthetic premises of Objectivism. It does not undermine its view of politics as far as the definition of rights is concerned. It would only challenge a particular view of Ayn Rand on how to protect rights.

In addition of all what has been said in this thread, there is a further problem that has not been addressed: is there an objective, ethical foundation for the definition of the boundaries of the territory in which a government has the monopoly of force?

If we cannot define “territory” ethically, then we cannot have a State at all.

To me, the only objective, ethical foundation is the free will of land owners.

I live in Mexico. If I owned a piece of land in the Sourthern margin of the Grande River, and I was insatisfied with the corrupt, inefficient Mexican government and would like to be protected by the USA more efficient government OVER my privately owned territory, then I could ethically have the choice to re-define the borders of Mexico, so that the new border would put my piece of land under USA jurisdiction.

What would be the rational / moral basis of a government to claim jurisdiction over my privately owned land?

Let’s remember that boundaries of States were generally established by violent means, that did not include the opinion of the smaller owners of the land involved. Indeed, during the definition of boundaries it has been common to see forced migration of people and unspeakable violation of rights. Keeping the borders as they are also involves initiation of force. If I were to declare my land under the jurisdiction of another government, even a better government (a one that performs better in protecting rights) I would see soldiers or policemen trespassing my fences, taking me to jail, accusing me of traison or shooting me.