Re: #19 Tony, I gather that the talented young man who manages that site-sector of Olist (the sector’s name is offensive to some older folks like me) is very much one who thinks for himself, as seen here. The rule about excluding posting privileges to persons who “associate with” Dr. Kelley, Dr. Sciabarra, or the Brandens is a rule set by site owner Diana Hsieh. Dr. Hsieh had sharp personal and intellectual conflicts with those first two a few years ago. I did not follow the particulars. It was anyway their problem, and I had my own work to do, as ever. As I understand from a recent talk by Yaron Brook of the Ayn Rand Institute, Nathaniel Branden is held in contempt, as an institutional doctrine, because of his horrible deception of his lover Ayn Rand. David Kelley is singled out for public repudiation by ARI officials because of his alleged failure to understand some basic principle(s) of Objectivism, as expressed in an essayed exchange between him and Leonard Peikoff concerning “open” and “closed” Objectivism. I was glad when Dr. Peikoff declared he was not going to continue further in the essay debate of the issue; he too had more important work to do. As I recall, those seemed to be good essays on both sides. However, I have not studied them carefully, and anyway, like everyone else, I was familiar with the important heuristic at work in the conflict: don’t pull rank. Competitors will run down their competitors. I imagine some good has come of the rivalries. I recall a page in Marvin Minsky’s The Society of Mind, in which he spoke of how enormously powerful is the motivation Beat Professor X. I’m pretty sure humanity is greatly benefitted by that supplementary spur to thinkers and researchers at the frontiers of knowledge. Certainly the scholars associated with ARI have produced excellent work concerning the literature and philosophy of Ayn Rand. To be clear, that is mainly due to dedication of the individual scholars and to some extent due to financial support from generous rich people who support ARI in its support of Rand scholarship. I was a young man when the break between Miss Rand and Dr. Branden occurred. I was a little pissed off at them at first because they had blown up the organization NBI. That proved really not so important. Further writings and lectures streamed forth. They were important. Personal partisans, now in their 70’s and 80’s, who knew Ayn Rand, continue to throw punches at each other and will continue those punches so long as they breathe. The conflicts (personally rooted) between well-known Objectivist thinkers were not my problems, and I had my own work to do, as ever. I did grasp upon the split between Rand and Branden that she aimed to destroy him. What he had done was a serious moral failing (and one did not need to know a blessed thing about Objectivist morality to see that), but that was not all: I had learned about their affair of the heart shortly after the break and had some inkling of how extra full of hurt and rage Rand would have to be from such an experience. I was pleased to see Branden’s first book a couple years later. He had survived psychologically and continued a vigorous producer. Rand produced also, and for her days, I wished only she be “watched by every human love.” (At Peace)
Stephen, Heh, plenty to think about here. And those NBI days must have been a real roller-coaster ride!
Some of this has been on my mind already, but you offer a unique slant.
To be as condensed as I can - The thing is, I have no understanding of how it is possible for any Objectivist to lose objectivity about, or vilify, other Objectivists. Or, to suspend his independence of thought..
My take is that all our present intellectuals are, primarily, doing a magnificent job. Although I sometimes disagree with one or another.
Now, to Nathaniel Branden, who’s work I’m quite familiar with, he filled what I perceived as a ‘gap’ between philosophy and psychology that nobody else would or could. Although this is over-simplifying, his books were invaluable for me, personally.
I’ve read a few of Kelly’s essays which deserve to treated with deep consideration, too, I think. Whatever the past, these men are doubtlessly men of integrity. To sidetrack prolonged debate on them or their work, I want to stick to the point of how can such productive, self-proclaimed Objectivist academics (OK, NB calls himself, neo-), be called evil? immoral? or, Enemies of Objectivism, False Advocates, etc. I mean, if they are ‘evil’, where does Josef Stalin fit on the scale? For one of thousands. (To say nothing of a bunch of contemptibly immoral politicians existing in my country?)
This ‘us’ and ‘them’ grouping and disregard for fellow O’ists is not rational - in fact, it is tribalist, I think.
Also, for a person new to an Objectivist forum, to be met with such stringent conditions of entry, is unreasonable too. (Which was my criticism of the gay forum’s rules.) Mostly, he has read one of Rand’s books, and knows nothing of the internal politics. These forums represent to me islands of sanity (well, mostly) in a pretty insane world. Objectivists should greet newcomers with openness, and confidence - not with distrust. Others are also seeking reason, reality and good sense, more and more often today. Even those who leave will take something with them.
btw, not for the first time it occurs to me that I am closer, ideologically, to the average O’ist here - and to Drs Peikoff , Branden, Kelly, Hsieh, Brook - all academics and other ‘end-users’ (like myself) who I’m never going to meet - than I am to most of my own friends. (Bitter differences, or “rivalries” as you put it, aside.) I’m sure I am not the only one. .
Thanks for your considered and considerate reply.
Tony
[Edit: I only now read the link you provided of Trey Peden’s article, and yes I was unfair; he does seem a thoughtful and independent guy. Which makes the rules of the forum he is managing all the more contradictory…]