Should everyone wish to get married?

Excepting situations in which circumstances such old age make it unrealistic, if romantic love is one of the essential values in life, should everyone hold getting married as a long-term goal?

How does marriage necessarily enhance or improve romantic relationships?

Short answer to the title topic: No.

 

Excepting situations in which circumstances such old age make it unrealistic, if romantic love is one of the essential values in life, should everyone hold getting married as a long-term goal?

The qualifying phase in this question is, “if romantic love is one of essential values.” Romantic love, in the truest sense, is quite rare. There are far too many loveless marriages; people carry on their lives together out of habit, or fear of what it would be like to be independent of their spouse.

 

How does marriage necessarily enhance or improve romantic relationships?

I concur with Eiuol. Two people in love can have all of the joys of each others commitment without the legal contract. However, I would add that the contract binds property rights and grants a couple tax benefits. Where children are involved, the situation may be different. In any event, a life is not complete without having had at least one great love affair, if not many.

if “romantic love is one of the essential values in life”, then romantic love should be held as a long-term goal. whether â€œmarriage” is the proper or ultimate end of romantic love, if and when that is found, is a separate argument.

1 Like

How does marriage necessarily enhance or improve romantic relationships?

 

The same way contracts do as an explicit statement of commitment witnessed by others.

Excepting situations in which circumstances such old age make it unrealistic, if romantic love is one of the essential values in life, should everyone hold getting married as a long-term goal?

 

Age is no exception to romantic love, but marriage isn’t for everyone.  Marriage, like any other contractural agreement, provides a form of security by explicitly declaring a committment to sharing long term goals.  Not everyone benefits from that kind of committment, but for those who do, a golden wedding anniversary shared with family members is a truly golden moment and a source of pride and achievement.

…

 

I concur with Eiuol. Two people in love can have all of the joys of each others commitment without the legal contract. However, I would add that the contract binds property rights and grants a couple tax benefits. Where children are involved, the situation may be different. In any event, a life is not complete without having had at least one great love affair, if not many.

 

Two people can built a car together without a legal contract too, but only one will retain ownership should they later decide to go their separate ways.  Marriage, as a contract, provides security but not love.  A good marriage is a working relationship in which the partners love their job.

All good points so far. It occurred to me that if it wasn’t so taboo, a practical approach to marriage as a regular old contract would yield loveless marriages as a non-embarrassing norm. “Oh, they were married years ago. They’ve lived there for over ten years I think, but at the end of next year I believe she’s selling her portion and moving away with her lover. Him? Apparently he’s converting part of it into a bigger work room for his model planes. I don’t know, it’s just what he likes!”

LOL Jaskn,

 

Today’s practical alternatives to contractual marriage include leasing and catch and release.

The same way contracts do as an explicit statement of commitment witnessed by others.

Too vague. You didn’t describe what improves the nature of the relationship. Why does a statement of commitment improve a romantic relationship? The legal relationship certainly changes, but how does the romantic relationship change in a way unique to marriage? I don’t think I need to draw out further how legal aspects of a relationship don’t necessarily change the romantic aspects, so I’m only asking what about one changes the other.

Too vague. You didn’t describe what improves the nature of the relationship. Why does a statement of commitment improve a romantic relationship? The legal relationship certainly changes, but how does the romantic relationship change in a way unique to marriage? I don’t think I need to draw out further how legal aspects of a relationship don’t necessarily change the romantic aspects, so I’m only asking what about one changes the other.

 

In a word, security.  That is what “contractual animals” benefit from; knowing in advance that ones future partner is explicitly and publicly committed to working together for mutual benefit towards shared goals.  In terms of marital security, it allows individuals to experience their romantic relationship further removed from fears of rejection, abandonment, or unwanted interference by others.

 

In simple terms, marriage is the objective evidence of two individuals choosing to share a long term monogamous relationship with each other because that improves the nature of their romantic relationship.  As I half jokingly suggested to Jaskn, other individuals prefer the practice of catch and release.

seeing marriage as a contract doesn’t need to trivialize it. people will never give up religion if they think it’s the only way to have meaning and to take life seriously.

In a word, security.  That is what “contractual animals” benefit from; knowing in advance that ones future partner is explicitly and publicly committed to working together for mutual benefit towards shared goals.  In terms of marital security, it allows individuals to experience their romantic relationship further removed from fears of rejection, abandonment, or unwanted interference by others.

Yeah, that’s what I’m getting at and questioning. Contractual promises are good. But we’re not talking about  the legal or monetary consolidation that marriage typically is about. We’re talking here about emotional security, and you’ve explicitly mentioned fears or other things that indicate uncertainty of trust. Sure, it is fine to take contracts to assure you what happens with the distribution of property or money in the event anything bad happens. It is not fine to use marriage as a promise that you’ll be with no one else as a way to assure them you won’t suddenly vanish. Talk about controlling! If marriage is a means to improve relationships because they’re further from rejection, that sounds horrible - are the people otherwise jealous more often before marriage? If they are, something is wrong.

 

You seemed to assume right away that “promising” relationships will last is a good thing. I see it as delusional at worst, or naive at best to expect that relationships based on emotions can be promised. Contracts based on emotion is a terrible thing, and even if you only mean a symbolic promise, that’s bad for the reasons I stated above. It’s only a modern development that marriage as an agreement became connected to love.

None of the purported emotional benefits of marriage require a legal contract to be obtained.

… It is not fine to use marriage as a promise that you’ll be with no one else as a way to assure them you won’t suddenly vanish. Talk about controlling! If marriage is a means to improve relationships because they’re further from rejection, that sounds horrible…

 

But “controlling” is exactly what contracts are about, and why individuals choose to freely enter into them.  To have the ability to exercise some control over the uncertainty of having a significant other (trading partner) back away from whatever committments are being depended on to pursue ones happiness.

 

…

 

You seemed to assume right away that “promising” relationships will last is a good thing. I see it as delusional at worst, or naive at best to expect that relationships based on emotions can be promised. Contracts based on emotion is a terrible thing, and even if you only mean a symbolic promise, that’s bad for the reasons I stated above…

 

I assume that promising to deliver on ones committments is a good thing, which is primarily why we are contractual animals and not lone wolves.  As I stated in post #7, “Marriage, as a contract, provides security but not love”, meaning sheltering oneself from emotionally driven actions produced by love/hate/indifference is as valid a form of security as sheltering oneself from emotionally driven actions like theft/dishonesty/malfeasance.

 

… It’s only a modern development that marriage as an agreement became connected to love.

 

That is an interesting perspective and I think accounts to some degree for the more recent decline in marriage as a viable form of contract.  As contractual expectations shift from agreements of trade based on principle, to agreements to trade as long as one partner feels like it, the absence of necessity for such emotional contracting becomes apparent.

 

Happiness may be pursued, but not guarenteed.

any long-term romantic relationship usually involves the promise of exclusivity, even if only implicitly. i think Eioul’s point is that getting married as a way to have extra assurance that your partner won’t leave you or cheat on you is unhealthy.

 

the problem is not so much that it’s controlling to obtain an official promise of fidelity, it’s that you should already be so confident that you don’t have any anxiety about that in the first place. getting it in writing, backed by the state, does not improve the situation anyway. marriage does not shield you from “emotionally driven actions produced by love/hate/indifference”, since divorce is always an option. your security against that is the value of the relationship and the character of the person you’re with.

 

…

 

the problem is not so much that it’s controlling to obtain an official promise of fidelity, it’s that you should already be so confident that you don’t have any anxiety about that in the first place. getting it in writing, backed by the state, does not improve the situation anyway. marriage does not shield you from “emotionally driven actions produced by love/hate/indifference”, since divorce is always an option. your security against that is the value of the relationship and the character of the person you’re with.

 

 

Contract law doesn’t prevent breach of contract, it only enables one to pursue compensation for breach of contract.  In this matter, marital contract provides as much security as any other form of contract.  As an Objectivist, to argue against such forms of security calls to question ones agreement with Ayn Rand’s description of man as a contractual animal.  If one claims that marriage, as a contract, is of no value then one assumes the position that contracts in general are of no value.

 

Is this your position?

Marriage as a contract absolutely provides *material security*. i am not arguing against that and neither is anyone else here. Eioul said: “Contractual promises are good… it is fine to take contracts to assure you what happens with the distribution of property or money in the event anything bad happens.” —“But we’re not talking about the legal or monetary consolidation… we’re talking here about emotional security… fears … uncertainty of trust.”

 

what marriage should not have the function of providing in a relationship is emotional stability. having that contract in your hand does not increase love or trust, it does not make the romance itself more intense or more enduring. marriage should not be used as â€œa means to improve relationships” by putting you “further from rejection”, as a way to calm your fear and mistrust. that would be similar to trying to get pregnant in order to make a failing relationship last.

the point is put very well by an Objectivist psychologist here: http://drhurd.com/if-you-dont-feel-loved-maybe-this-is-why/
 

“There’s an old saying about marital relationships being a ‘ball and chain.’ Today we use the terminology of prisons and involuntary psychiatric hospital stays to describe relationships: ‘commitment.’ Yikes! By what horrific turn of events or concepts does something as beautiful, spontaneous and nonobligatory as romantic love turn into imprisonment or enslavement? What does it say about the way many people approach romantic love—and human association more generally—that it so often comes to this?”

“From a rational perspective, you don’t want someone to love you unless they freely and willingly choose and allow themselves to do so. What else can reside beneath a connection of love or friendship other than willingness, spontaneity and authenticity? If your spouse or friend doesn’t love you because of sincere, personally held motivation—then what is to be the motive? Duty? Obligation? ‘You loved me five years ago, so you’ve got to love me now. You must love me now.’ … What’s even in it for you—selfishly—to have someone love you merely out of habit, obligation or duty? Don’t you want it to be real, most of all?

 

If John Galt’s oath is true—and I maintain that it is—then it’s likewise true that nobody is obliged to love you or care about you, just because you want it or need it. You must earn that love—not only in your own conclusions and practice, but also in the other person’s eyes. This is true not only on the first date, or in the first year, but for all the years of your romantic association (or any other kind of association) together."

Splitprimary, your paraphrase of what I was saying is right, and I agree with what you said. Or also like Bluecherry said, the supposed emotional benefits of marriage aren’t even unique to marriage.

 

Ayn Rand’s description of man as a contractual animal.

That’s your description. It’d only be fair to say Rand described man as rational, and a trader of values. Your point seems to be that contracts are fundamental to any trade, even emotional trades. The problem with that is simply emotional trades, like love, can’t be contracted. If you attempt to contract it, you will not be able to measure properly when that contract is broken. The only possible standard to the terms then is as long as one partner literally feels like it. So, you’re back where you started, the risk of them someday falling out of love didn’t go away. What could you possibly contract about emotions on measurable grounds?

That’s why I brought in the word “control”. Yeah, contracts are about control, except attempting to control emotions is not proper. You know, like a “controlling relationship” where one partner makes unreasonable demands without taking into account what the other can reasonably control.
 

meaning sheltering oneself from emotionally driven actions produced by love/hate/indifference

 

Actions like what? Don’t be so abstract, concretize!