Should everyone wish to get married?

…

 

That’s your description. It’d only be fair to say Rand described man as rational, and a trader of values. Your point seems to be that contracts are fundamental to any trade, even emotional trades. The problem with that is simply emotional trades, like love, can’t be contracted. If you attempt to contract it, you will not be able to measure properly when that contract is broken. The only possible standard to the terms then is as long as one partner literally feels like it. So, you’re back where you started, the risk of them someday falling out of love didn’t go away. What could you possibly contract about emotions on measurable grounds?

…

 

Here’s the source of “my description”:

 

“Man gains enormous values from dealing with other men; living in a human society is his proper way of life—but only on certain conditions. Man is not a lone wolf and he is not a social animal. He is a contractual animal. He has to plan his life long-range, make his own choices, and deal with other men by voluntary agreement ( and he has to be able to rely on their observance of the agreements they entered ).” ~ ARL, Man

 

Yes, my point is that “contracts are fundamental to any trade”, and that traders are not unemotional beings.  Do we pursue happiness, or just material assets?  Every relationship between individuals requires time and effort, i.e. an investment being made with the expectation of some agreed upon return on that investment.  Emotional relationships are no exception such that contractual animals become something else when pursuing love interests.

 

…

That’s why I brought in the word “control”. Yeah, contracts are about control, except attempting to control emotions is not proper. You know, like a “controlling relationship” where one partner makes unreasonable demands without taking into account what the other can reasonably control.

 

…

 

Contracts record terms of agreement, i.e., who is responsible for what.  When individuals freely promise to love one another forever, then yeah they ought to be held accountable for having a change of heart later on.  If you can’t do the time, don’t sign the line.  In any case, imagine the value of contracts if every one had an emotional escape clause such that one becomes exempt from contractual obligations because one no longer feels like providing them.

 

…

 

Actions like what? Don’t be so abstract, concretize!

 

This seems to be the major source of your objection, so I’ll attempt to clarify here what is meant by sheltering oneself by contract from emotionally driven actions.  Let’s say two couples fall in love and want to spend the rest of their lives together.  They can:

a) live together freely without obligation

B) marry and formally hold each other accountable to specific kinds of behavior, e.g., no lying, cheating, theft, etc.

 

Couple ‘a’ and couple ‘b’ both have children and at some point later on, one partner from each relationship initiates an extra marital affair.  Both partners are discovered and sent packing.  Neither of the remaining partners were primary wage earners, so both are left raising children with insufficient funds.  The remaining partner from couple ‘b’ recieves alimony, while the remaining partner from couple ‘a’ goes on welfare.  Which couple made the more rational decision regarding their future?

 

Wait a minute… what about that emotional sheltering bit??  It’s more commonly referred to as peace of mind knowing that one has taken steps to limit hardships resulting from trading partners who later neglect their previously agreed to obligations.  That’s the best concrete I can pour at this point in time (going to be out of touch for a few weeks), and in any case, my argument has nothing to do with contracting for love and everything to do with contracting for security, which is what all contracts, including marital ones, are intended for.

Here’s the source of “my description”

I stand corrected. I think you take the description too far, though. Agreements are made over choices. Agreements can’t be made over the state of your emotions which are not choices. You can’t be held accountable in a contractual sense for having a change of heart. Indeed, why you want to make an agreement goes with an emotional motivation underlying your goal, but you wouldn’t make a contract where the terms include a change of emotion. What would you say about this dialogue I made up?

Jill: “You promised you’d love me!”

Jack: “I do love you!”

Jill: “Then why did you go hiking without me?!”

Jack: “Because I wanted alone time.”

Jill: “Liar. You don’t love me, you broke our contract; see you in court!”

How would a judge determine if in fact Jack broke the contract, assuming that promising to remain in love is part of the contract’s terms?

 

When individuals freely promise to love one another forever, then yeah they ought to be held accountable for having a change of heart later on.  If you can’t do the time, don’t sign the line.  In any case, imagine the value of contracts if every one had an emotional escape clause such that one becomes exempt from contractural obligations because one no longer feels like providing them.

But it is not possible to make that into a contract because emotions aren’t something you decide. That’s why trades of emotion can’t be contracted.

Your example is an example of contracting for purposes of property or money and is not about emotional connections.

Look, you said “[marriage] allows individuals to experience their romantic relationship further removed from fears of rejection, abandonment, or unwanted interference by others.” I am not disputing the value of agreeing how to deal with money and property. I’m disputing that marriage can possibly improve a relationship compared to before marriage. That is, unless there are baseless fears and jealousy in the relationship, which is hardly a rational reason to marry.

Jill: “You promised you’d love me!”

Jack: “I do love you!”

Jill: “Then why did you go hiking without me?!”

Jack: “Because I wanted alone time.”

Jill: “Liar. You don’t love me, you broke our contract; see you in court!”

How would a judge determine if in fact Jack broke the contract, assuming that promising to remain in love is part of the contract’s terms?

I view the contract issue as strictly about property, and probably about property concerning children, also. In my very limited understanding of the matter, I believe prenups already mitigate marital property disputes between couples, but the court does a lousy job with children. On the one hand, I could see a contract specifying that a spouse cannot move before a child is grown – but on the other hand, I can’t see a spouse contracting the possibility of living with someone in misery.

if all you mean to say is that, knowing you have legal recourse to secure material compensation in the event of something like infidelity, provides some peace of mind, then i could agree. but you keep trying to smuggle in the idea that the contract is also, “individuals freely promis[ing] to love one another forever”. that’s the “emotional” part we’re trying to isolate. if your argument has “nothing to do with contracting for love”, then what is that?

Eiuol & splitprimary,

 

You remain concerned that contracts (like money) can’t buy you love; that love is somehow beyond the realm of choice.  If this were the case, then pursuing happiness (an emotional state) would remain an exercise in futility.  The fact remains that happiness is not only achievable by choice, but that the odds of achieving happiness are increased by making agreements with others, and holding oneself and others accountable to those agreements.  Another way of stating this is to say that contracts minimize the risk of becoming unhappy as a result of interactions with others.

 

To assert that one cannot make someone love you jumps over a critical element;  love you for what?  There are any number of reasons one might love another.  When individuals fall in love, those reasons form the foundation of their relationship.  Marriage is the means by which individuals attempt to assure each other that each is committed to defining and maintaining their relationship according to those reasons.  In this respect, marriage is like any other contract entered into willingly for the purpose of achieving a mutually beneficial goal.  And like any other contract, should either or both parties become unhappy with their relationship, there remains a legitimate means of escape, e.g., divorce. 

 

So again, one does not contract to create love because presumably one is already in love.  One contracts for security (peace of mind) that the love being acted on is genuine and enduring and can be maintained long term, even in the face of hardships and uncertainty.  Finding and contracting with a reliable parts supplier is essentially the same.  And to respond to how this makes a married couples’ love better than shacking up, one only has to consider interacting with others without any expectation of reliable performance, e.g., a vow to behave consistently.

 

That being said, marriage or any other contractual obligation is serious business and not for everyone, and particularly not for those who don’t care to be held accountable for their actions or promises to behave consistently.  In summing up, I will say that it is not in the nature of fallible beings to have perfect marriages.  But that fallible beings even choose to attempt to enter into and maintain long term mutually beneficial relationships is an attempt to live as a heroic beings ought to live.

happiness (and love) are the results and rewards of good choices. you don’t just choose to be happy or choose to be in love. that is why you can enter into a contract stating actions you will and will not take, but you don’t contract how you will feel in the future.

 

i’m currently engaged, i believe in marriage. but no part of my reason for getting married is to make the relationship more emotionally secure, to give assurance or to get assurance that the love is genuine or enduring. i already know that it is. if i didn’t already know that, i would not be getting married. that is a precondition for marriage, not a result of it.

 

happiness (and love) are the results and rewards of good choices. you don’t just choose to be happy or choose to be in love. that is why you can enter into a contract stating actions you will and will not take, but you don’t contract how you will feel in the future.

 

i’m currently engaged, i believe in marriage. but no part of my reason for getting married is to make the relationship more emotionally secure, to give assurance or to get assurance that the love is genuine or enduring. i already know that it is. if i didn’t already know that, i would not be getting married. that is a precondition for marriage, not a result of it.

 

 

We can agree that emotional states are the result of choice, what Ayn Rand referred to as an emotional barometer of the effacy of ones actions.  Yes, one doesn’t just choose to be happy, one chooses to pursue happiness and contracts to effect that goal.

 

Congratulations on your engagement.  As one who has lasted 30 some seasons of marriage, I wish you well but warn you that what you “know” is subject to revision by practice.  In any case, I wish you well in your pursuit of happiness.

I view the contract issue as strictly about property, and probably about property concerning children, also. In my very limited understanding of the matter, I believe prenups already mitigate marital property disputes between couples, but the court does a lousy job with children. On the one hand, I could see a contract specifying that a spouse cannot move before a child is grown – but on the other hand, I can’t see a spouse contracting the possibility of living with someone in misery.

 

Delimiting contracts to property certainly fits the historical context of marriage, and accepting Locke’s view of ones person being their primary property fits the more contemporary view.  Two individuals freely vowing long term ethical behavior towards each other meets the standard of Galt’s vow and agrees with the Trader Principle, therefore is consistent with Objectivism.

i didn’t mean to derail the conversation by personalizing. congratulation and condescension aside, you have not addressed the charge that you are mistaking cause for effect.

 

i didn’t mean to derail the conversation by personalizing. congratulation and condescension aside, you have not addressed the charge that you are mistaking cause for effect.

 

 

Fair enough.  Please elaborate on my mistake that one chooses to pursue happiness and contracts to that effect.  And please explain exactly how you know today that you will continue to be happily married, say 30 years from now.

One contracts for security (peace of mind) that the love being acted on is genuine and enduring and can be maintained long term, even in the face of hardships and uncertainty.

 

How can a contract provide security of emotion? You say it does, but I’m saying it is impossible to make promises of emotion that would hold up in a court of law. What is possible, though, is to interact with people you judge to be honest. But what you cannot explicitly choose cannot be contracted. Further, you didn’t address my example of one party claiming a marriage contract is broken. You say marriage itself is peace of mind, so how does marriage secure you emotionally from impulsive breakups as in my example?

How can a contract provide security of emotion?

 

Consider the contract a citizen has with government to provide security.  When a citizen feels safe (an emotional state), is that not the result of having a contract that provides security?  Obviously the government cannot make one feel safe by acting without any commitment to provide security.

first of all, having been married for 30 years does not add weight to your position. that is a form of argument from authority. first-hand experience is not necessary to be able to understand these concepts. and longevity, by itself, says nothing about the value of a relationship or the participants anyway. one couple might stay together because they have remained each other’s highest value through consistent self-improvement and shared philosophy, another might be miserable but stay together by default, because they’re afraid of being independent, or out of a sense of duty to a mystical entity. there are all kinds of reasons a marriage might have lasted.

 

but what we’re getting down to is what marriage actually does. either “marriage is the objective evidence” and public declaration of a relationship that already existed and could exist without the external symbols, or making it official somehow fundamentally changes the nature of the relationship itself. maybe you can explain how signing a legal contract in any way increases the likelihood of your staying satisfied with a romantic relationship in the future. the way i see it, the legal part only deals with what happens in the case of dissolution, it doesn’t help the relationship along otherwise.

 

i have another question for you too. are you in favor of no-fault divorce? is it valid to divorce for no other reason than that you no longer want to be in the relationship?

 

you said earlier, “should either or both parties become unhappy with their relationship, there remains a legitimate means of escape, e.g., divorce.” but seem to view negatively the “shift… to agreements to trade as long as one partner feels like it”, and say that the marriage contract is a case where, “individuals freely promise to love one another forever” and “ought to be held accountable for having a change of heart later on.” plus, " imagine the value of contracts if every one had an emotional escape clause such that one becomes exempt from contractual obligations because one no longer feels like providing them." isn’t being unhappy with a relationship a case of “no longer feeling like” fulfilling your “promise to love one another forever”? does marriage impose a duty that you wouldn’t otherwise have in a committed, long-term relationship? what is the extent of that obligation? what should you do when it conflicts with your self-interest?

Consider the contract a citizen has with government to provide security.  When a citizen feels safe (an emotional state), is that not the result of having a contract that provides security?  Obviously the government cannot make one feel safe by acting without any commitment to provide security.

You’re right. But you couldn’t add a clause that says “feeling secure will be guaranteed”. It is also possible to promise continuing protection. That possibility adds for peace of mind by contract. It is impossible to promise continuing love, so marriage wouldn’t provide peace of mind.

I’m yet to hear a good argument for marriage. If you love someone, you stay with them. No contract required.

You’re right. But you couldn’t add a clause that says “feeling secure will be guaranteed”. It is also possible to promise continuing protection. That possibility adds for peace of mind by contract. It is impossible to promise continuing love, so marriage wouldn’t provide peace of mind.

 

There’s no guarantee that the pursuit of happiness will achieve happiness, so it follows that being married cannot guarantee enduring love any more than government security guarantees enduring safety.  A vow is only a statement of intention, e.g., I intend to love thee until death do us part.  Marriage provides peace of mind because ones declaration of love becomes as firm a commitment as is possible for one emotional trader to make with another emotional trader given that both remain fallible beings.

 

The alternative is to love someone until one doesn’t feel like it, which presumes enduring love cannot be maintained.  I believe a heroic (but fallible) being would aim higher.

splitprimary,

 

I will attempt to respond to post #33 once you have made some effort to respond to post #30.

marry late, marry wealthy

I’m yet to hear a good argument for marriage. If you love someone, you stay with them. No contract required.

 

And I have yet to hear a good argument for how a contractual animal (Ayn Rand’s definition of man) requires the observance of all agreements they enter except marital ones.  Couldn’t you as easily state that, “If you want to work with someone, you work with them. No contract required.”

And I have yet to hear a good argument for how a contractual animal (Ayn Rand’s definition of man) requires the observance of all agreements they enter except marital ones.  Couldn’t you as easily state that, “If you want to work with someone, you work with them. No contract required.”

For most people, the contract with their employer is pretty month-to-month. Th long term clauses tend to be of to types: first, you have multi-year contracts for senior employees [these are declarations of intent, but when things sour, they are effectively promises to pay a certain amount to buy out the remainder of the contract]; second, you have non-compete clauses, which employees tend to resent when things sours, and seldom keep them in the job… mostly have them scheming of ways to work around the clause.

 

BTW, a vow is not a contract.