…
That’s your description. It’d only be fair to say Rand described man as rational, and a trader of values. Your point seems to be that contracts are fundamental to any trade, even emotional trades. The problem with that is simply emotional trades, like love, can’t be contracted. If you attempt to contract it, you will not be able to measure properly when that contract is broken. The only possible standard to the terms then is as long as one partner literally feels like it. So, you’re back where you started, the risk of them someday falling out of love didn’t go away. What could you possibly contract about emotions on measurable grounds?
…
Here’s the source of “my description”:
“Man gains enormous values from dealing with other men; living in a human society is his proper way of life—but only on certain conditions. Man is not a lone wolf and he is not a social animal. He is a contractual animal. He has to plan his life long-range, make his own choices, and deal with other men by voluntary agreement ( and he has to be able to rely on their observance of the agreements they entered ).” ~ ARL, Man
Yes, my point is that “contracts are fundamental to any trade”, and that traders are not unemotional beings. Do we pursue happiness, or just material assets? Every relationship between individuals requires time and effort, i.e. an investment being made with the expectation of some agreed upon return on that investment. Emotional relationships are no exception such that contractual animals become something else when pursuing love interests.
…
That’s why I brought in the word “control”. Yeah, contracts are about control, except attempting to control emotions is not proper. You know, like a “controlling relationship” where one partner makes unreasonable demands without taking into account what the other can reasonably control.
…
Contracts record terms of agreement, i.e., who is responsible for what. When individuals freely promise to love one another forever, then yeah they ought to be held accountable for having a change of heart later on. If you can’t do the time, don’t sign the line. In any case, imagine the value of contracts if every one had an emotional escape clause such that one becomes exempt from contractual obligations because one no longer feels like providing them.
…
Actions like what? Don’t be so abstract, concretize!
This seems to be the major source of your objection, so I’ll attempt to clarify here what is meant by sheltering oneself by contract from emotionally driven actions. Let’s say two couples fall in love and want to spend the rest of their lives together. They can:
a) live together freely without obligation
B) marry and formally hold each other accountable to specific kinds of behavior, e.g., no lying, cheating, theft, etc.
Couple ‘a’ and couple ‘b’ both have children and at some point later on, one partner from each relationship initiates an extra marital affair. Both partners are discovered and sent packing. Neither of the remaining partners were primary wage earners, so both are left raising children with insufficient funds. The remaining partner from couple ‘b’ recieves alimony, while the remaining partner from couple ‘a’ goes on welfare. Which couple made the more rational decision regarding their future?
Wait a minute… what about that emotional sheltering bit?? It’s more commonly referred to as peace of mind knowing that one has taken steps to limit hardships resulting from trading partners who later neglect their previously agreed to obligations. That’s the best concrete I can pour at this point in time (going to be out of touch for a few weeks), and in any case, my argument has nothing to do with contracting for love and everything to do with contracting for security, which is what all contracts, including marital ones, are intended for.