The answer to the question “Should everyone wish to get married?” is obviously “no.”
But is it ever rational for anyone to get married? I believe so.
Here’s how I look at it:
The commitment one makes in marriage is based upon what one knows to be true about 1) himself, and 2) his partner. In marrying my wife, I said that I knew her to be of such a character that if love means what I think that it means – if love has the nature that I believe it to have – then I will have no choice but to love her not only today, but tomorrow, and the next day, and so on, because that is how I’m constituted. I respond to my wife with love, just as flowers follow the sunshine.
I believe that I will love her twenty, thirty years from now, and I’m not afraid to say so. By committing to my wife in any fashion at all, I’m speaking to this recognition that I have – this belief that I maintain, about the compatibility of our fundamental nature, that will continue to provide the basis for a loving and happy relationship. And while I recognize that “people change,” I do not expect for either me or my wife to be fundamentally different – even twenty years from now – again due to my beliefs about who we are and human nature more generally. I might develop a taste for different foods twenty years hence, or find myself getting into opera or soccer, but I am unlikely to become a communist or reject reason for faith.
It’s an important understanding, I think. It helps us to plot and plan our lives, knowing that we have certain relationships we can rely upon (which is why I believe that we also develop certain understandings like friends and “buddies,” who are maybe somewhat superficial friendships, and “besties,” and girlfriends/boyfriends and the like). Certain decisions, like whether or not to buy a home together, raise a family, and etc., require a high degree of confidence in the underlying stability of a relationship. A “commitment.”
Marriage is a formal recognition of that sort of commitment. Does the formal recognition itself add anything? Again, I think it can. Maybe this is due, in part, to the history of marriage in our society – that it is a “custom”? Or maybe it is largely symbolic? I believe that we often do things that are customary or symbolic, per our culture/society, and that there is nothing necessarily wrong with such participation. For instance, business men wear ties. Why? Does that strip of fabric dangling from one’s neck add to one’s business acumen? I doubt it. Yet the tie communicates something to others, and possibly has some effect upon the wearer (though I recognize that this is another possible conversation, and thus I may be begging the question here). So too does the wedding ring.