Should everyone wish to get married?

The alternative is to love someone until one doesn’t feel like it, which presumes enduring love cannot be maintained.  I believe a heroic (but fallible) being would aim higher.

Of course you love someone if and until you you no longer feel like it! Just like any emotion. That’s why it is senseless to contract feelings. Commitment is great, but not all commitments are contracts.

i think i have been more than reasonable. post #30 is a blatant misrepresentation of my position. i never said that i “know today that i will continue to be happily married 30 years from now”. the contract you have doesn’t give you knowledge of the future either. and it doesn’t have the power to magically prevent you from falling out of love.

The answer to the question “Should everyone wish to get married?” is obviously “no.”

But is it ever rational for anyone to get married? I believe so.

Here’s how I look at it:

The commitment one makes in marriage is based upon what one knows to be true about 1) himself, and 2) his partner. In marrying my wife, I said that I knew her to be of such a character that if love means what I think that it means – if love has the nature that I believe it to have – then I will have no choice but to love her not only today, but tomorrow, and the next day, and so on, because that is how I’m constituted. I respond to my wife with love, just as flowers follow the sunshine.

I believe that I will love her twenty, thirty years from now, and I’m not afraid to say so. By committing to my wife in any fashion at all, I’m speaking to this recognition that I have – this belief that I maintain, about the compatibility of our fundamental nature, that will continue to provide the basis for a loving and happy relationship. And while I recognize that “people change,” I do not expect for either me or my wife to be fundamentally different – even twenty years from now – again due to my beliefs about who we are and human nature more generally. I might develop a taste for different foods twenty years hence, or find myself getting into opera or soccer, but I am unlikely to become a communist or reject reason for faith.

It’s an important understanding, I think. It helps us to plot and plan our lives, knowing that we have certain relationships we can rely upon (which is why I believe that we also develop certain understandings like friends and “buddies,” who are maybe somewhat superficial friendships, and “besties,” and girlfriends/boyfriends and the like). Certain decisions, like whether or not to buy a home together, raise a family, and etc., require a high degree of confidence in the underlying stability of a relationship. A “commitment.”

Marriage is a formal recognition of that sort of commitment. Does the formal recognition itself add anything? Again, I think it can. Maybe this is due, in part, to the history of marriage in our society – that it is a “custom”? Or maybe it is largely symbolic? I believe that we often do things that are customary or symbolic, per our culture/society, and that there is nothing necessarily wrong with such participation. For instance, business men wear ties. Why? Does that strip of fabric dangling from one’s neck add to one’s business acumen? I doubt it. Yet the tie communicates something to others, and possibly has some effect upon the wearer (though I recognize that this is another possible conversation, and thus I may be begging the question here). So too does the wedding ring.

Excepting situations in which circumstances such old age make it unrealistic, if romantic love is one of the essential values in life, should everyone hold getting married as a long-term goal?

You haven’t participated in the thread after your initial post. When you posted, were you thinking specifically of marriage, or were you using marriage as a short-cut common-term for a long-term relationship that two people enter into, intending it to be life-long? In other words, are you asking about marriage as such, or are you asking if everyone should aim to be in a life-long relationship with a soul-mate?

…

 

BTW, a vow is not a contract.

 

Insofar as vows and contracts fall under the category of agreements, as used by Ayn Rand in her description of man as a contractual animal (see post #21), I think the differences are marginal in terms of this topic.  Whether verbal or written, ones integrity is used as collateral to back a pledge of performance, a loss of integrity being a serious impediment to negotiating future agreements.

 

My premise remains that marriage represents the same kind of contract contractual animals rely on to effect the happiness they pursue.

i think i have been more than reasonable. post #30 is a blatant misrepresentation of my position. i never said that i “know today that i will continue to be happily married 30 years from now”. the contract you have doesn’t give you knowledge of the future either. and it doesn’t have the power to magically prevent you from falling out of love.

 

Perhaps I misunderstood you,

 

 

happiness (and love) are the results and rewards of good choices. you don’t just choose to be happy or choose to be in love. that is why you can enter into a contract stating actions you will and will not take, but you don’t contract how you will feel in the future.

 

i’m currently engaged, i believe in marriage. but no part of my reason for getting married is to make the relationship more emotionally secure, to give assurance or to get assurance that the love is genuine or enduring. i already know that it is. if i didn’t already know that, i would not be getting married. that is a precondition for marriage, not a result of it.

 

 

When you state that you know the love you share with your fiancée is enduring, did you mean something other than you know you will continue to feel the same years from now?  You say this is a precondition for marriage, but it sounds more to me like a precognition of marriage.

 

I see the basic difference in our positions as you believe agreements aren’t necessary because one knows how relationships will turn out, and I believe agreements are necessary because one doesn’t know how relationships will turn out.  Is this correct?

Of course you love someone if and until you you no longer feel like it! Just like any emotion. That’s why it is senseless to contract feelings. Commitment is great, but not all commitments are contracts.

 

Let’s try this one step at a time.  Do you agree that making agreements about behavior, e.g., not committing adultery, would increase the likelihood of enjoying a long term romantic relationship?

enduring simply means lasting, or long-term (as opposed to fleeting or casual). the word does not specify precise duration. maybe you meant to say “eternal” or “life-long”, but you didn’t. my relationship would already be considered a long-term relationship, and neither of us have any reason to believe we will stop wanting to be together.

 

DonAthos above stated it perfectly, better than i would have been able to. his view of marriage is mine as well.

 

———

 

this conversation is specifically about the contract of marriage, not “agreements” in general. couples who are not married can, and usually do, make explicit agreements about their relationships.

Insofar as vows and contracts fall under the category of agreements, …, I think the differences are marginal in terms of this topic.  

A contract is an agreement with the force of law. That’s no marginal difference. There’s good reason a marriage is a contract. Ending of the relationship often leaves at least one of the parties with financial damage or with financial obligations. So, there has to be a way to resolve the financial issues. The marriage contract is all about what happens when it it breaks up, plus reasons that allow one party to break it up on better financial terms. 

 

Meanwhile, the vows to love and to cherish etc. are not contracts, but a friendly agreements to try one’s best to stick together long term, and not to let short-term problems or temptations undermine one’s longer-term happiness. However, it often happens that – after some time – one reaches the conclusion that one’s long-term happiness does not lie in the marriage. In that case, there is no breach of the friendly agreement, because at its base was an assumption that is no longer true.

softwareNerd & splitprimary,

 

Verbal agreements such as promises to love can become legally binding when certain conditions are met.  Typically a promise to love leads to sharing of material assets, and in those cases one would likely not find oneself exempt from ones obligations just because one no longer feels love for their partner.  That is consistent with Ayn Rand’s description of man as a contractual animal, and supported by legal concepts historically, and more recently as in common law interpretations.

Typically a promise to love leads to sharing of material assets, and in those cases one would likely not find oneself exempt from ones obligations just because one no longer feels love for their partner. 

 

What obligation? You seem to be saying the obligation is to “remain in love”.

What obligation? You seem to be saying the obligation is to “remain in love”.

 

More like honor ones obligation to act consistently with regard to the love once professed.  One concrete example would be not to commit adultery while pretending to remain in love with ones spouse; or to have ones cake and eat it too.  If one no longer loves the person one has made a commitment to, one is ethically bound to at least not pretend to love them in order to retain the benefits of the relationship dishonestly.

softwareNerd & splitprimary,

 

Verbal agreements such as promises to love can become legally binding when certain conditions are met.  Typically a promise to love leads to sharing of material assets, and in those cases one would likely not find oneself exempt from ones obligations just because one no longer feels love for their partner.  That is consistent with Ayn Rand’s description of man as a contractual animal, and supported by legal concepts historically, and more recently as in common law interpretations.

Yes, of course verbal contracts should be just as binding as written ones. That’s besides the point here. Even if you write out an agreement to love and cherish, and have it notarized, it is not a contract that can be upheld in any rational court of law. 

More like honor ones obligation to act consistently with regard to the love once professed.  One concrete example would be not to commit adultery while pretending to remain in love with ones spouse; or to have ones cake and eat it too. 

Any others? Does the extent of obligation extend past a promise of no adultery?

Any others? Does the extent of obligation extend past a promise of no adultery?

 

That would depend on the individuals involved, and in some cases adultery might not be so much of an issue.  The point is whatever obligations were established as a result of intending to live together ought to remain in effect until both parties agreed to separate, i.e., agree to get in, agree to get out.  Primarily it’s an issue of maintaining respect for someone who was considered worthy of that respect, as opposed to behaving unethically towards someone whose only fault is to no longer be the object of ones desire.

That would depend on the individuals involved, and in some cases adultery might not be so much of an issue.  The point is whatever obligations were established as a result of intending to live together ought to remain in effect until both parties agreed to separate, i.e., agree to get in, agree to get out.  Primarily it’s an issue of maintaining respect for someone who was considered worthy of that respect, as opposed to behaving unethically towards someone whose only fault is to no longer be the object of ones desire.

This is arbitrary. You can respect someone, but still want to move on. Respect is not a chain.

Yes, of course verbal contracts should be just as binding as written ones. That’s besides the point here. Even if you write out an agreement to love and cherish, and have it notarized, it is not a contract that can be upheld in any rational court of law. 

 

That and Eiuol’s earlier example would be cases where a rational judge wound encourage both parties to attempt to reconcile their differences prior to divorcing and/or suing for a breach of contract, if one exists.  I am under the impression that objective law would in fact allow two individuals to create any form of contract they choose to except agreements to commit a crime.

Yes, of course verbal contracts should be just as binding as written ones. That’s besides the point here. Even if you write out an agreement to love and cherish, and have it notarized, it is not a contract that can be upheld in any rational court of law. 

 

That and Eiuol’s earlier example would be cases where a rational judge wound encourage both parties to attempt to reconcile their differences prior to divorcing and/or suing for a breach of contract, if one exists.  I am under the impression that objective law would in fact allow two individuals to create any form of contract they choose to except agreements to commit a crime.

That and Eiuol’s earlier example would be cases where a rational judge wound encourage both parties to attempt to reconcile their differences prior to divorcing and/or suing for a breach of contract, if one exists.  I am under the impression that objective law would in fact allow two individuals to create any form of contract they choose to except agreements to commit a crime.

Well, a judge might well “encourage” two parties to try to work something out; but, that’s simply judge playing uncle. If either says they’ve thought it through, there’s nothing a judge can do to force them to reconcile.

The judge can look at whatever contract was agreed to, can decide who is in breach, and can figure out what damages are owed. he can’t force people to remain married. That’s totally irrational and downright evil.

This is arbitrary. You can respect someone, but still want to move on. Respect is not a chain.

 

Ethical behavior is the binding force here.  Love and respect are earned values, are they not?  Without knowing the particulars of what led two individuals to choose to spend the rest of their lives together, and why one of them no longer wishes to, it wound be hard to say whether the choice to separate is arbitrary or not.