Should everyone wish to get married?

…

The judge can look at whatever contract was agreed to, can decide who is in breach, and can figure out what damages are owed. he can’t force people to remain married. That’s totally irrational and downright evil.

 

And totally outside the scope of my argument.

The point is whatever obligations were established as a result of intending to live together ought to remain in effect until both parties agreed to separate, i.e., agree to get in, agree to get out.

What if they don’t agree to separate?

Devil’s Advocate, you’ve mentioned actions which can be enforced, like distribution of property and such. This is all well and fine. That sort of thing can be contracted for. The problem is the emotional aspect. You can take actions to try to increase the likelihood of maintaining emotions in oneself and others, but you cannot actually force the emotion to be maintained if those actions don’t end up being enough to do the trick. Those actions you can take can be taken regardless of any contract though too. Another party involved could promise to do or not do certain other actions too which likely could impact feelings, but that still doesn’t require a contract to have them make and try to follow such promises. All that a contract could really do is forcibly handle certain elements of the aftermath in the event of a dissolution of a relationship. I don’t think, legally, you could even call the cops to force somebody at gunpoint not to move out or go have sex with somebody else even if you did make any promises not to do such things and had a marriage contract.

What if they don’t agree to separate?

 

It is hard for me to imagine that two individuals who fell in love for the best of reasons and later grew apart through no fault of their partner, would intentionally make the process of separation more hurtful than necessary.  In this respect I think Khalil Gibran sums it up best with, “If you love somebody, let them go, for if they return, they were always yours. If they don’t, they never were.”

 

In any case, the law intervenes when individuals cannot resolve their own conflicts.

bluecherry,

 

It’s likely that a police officer would rather respond to an armed robbery than a domestic disturbance.  Nevertheless, I maintain that objective law would attempt to enforce (short of sanctioning criminal activity) whatever legal agreements two parties agreed to regardless how inane those agreements might appear to third parties.  Indeed it must in order to secure the right of individuals to freely enter into agreements and rely on having those agreements fulfilled.

So, you think then something like moving out should have police prevent it? If the goal of such agreements as not moving out is to try to foster somebody liking you, I’m pretty sure forcing them to stay would just be counterproductive and breed resentment rather than making things better.

It is hard for me to imagine that two individuals who fell in love for the best of reasons and later grew apart through no fault of their partner, would intentionally make the process of separation more hurtful than necessary. 

Sorry, but I must use the R-word. This is an example of rationalism in thinking, because everyone is familiar with the concept of a “messy divorce”. It is not at all uncommon that a couple who once thought they’d spend their lives together want to do all sorts of things to hurt the other during a divorce.

 

 

… … objective law would attempt to enforce (short of sanctioning criminal activity) whatever legal agreements two parties agreed to regardless how inane those agreements might appear to third parties.  

No, the law must  not  always enforce the original terms. More often it must compute guilt and damages. This is rational because it is reality-based: it takes cognizance of the nature of human beings and of relationships.

In any case, the law intervenes when individuals cannot resolve their own conflicts.

 

Right, and part of the security a contract provides is that it helps to resolve disagreements. That brings me back to my question earlier. The question is important because it can show the degree you think marriage contracts ought to provide security for relationships.

 

Jill: “You promised you’d love me!”

Jack: “I do love you!”

Jill: “Then why did you go hiking without me?!”

Jack: “Because I wanted alone time.”

Jill: “Liar. You don’t love me, you broke our contract; see you in court!”

How would a judge determine if in fact Jack broke the contract, assuming that promising to remain in love is part of the contract’s terms? Assume also that Jack doesn’t want a divorce. Do you watch Breaking Bad? If you do, there is an analagous situation later in the series with Skyler and Walter where one of them refuses to sign divorce papers, but the other one REALLY wants a divorce. In effect, they’re forced to be together, and the “relationship security” really is promised, at the cost of another person’s happiness.

Right, and part of the security a contract provides is that it helps to resolve disagreements. That brings me back to my question earlier. The question is important because it can show the degree you think marriage contracts ought to provide security for relationships.

 

Jill: “You promised you’d love me!”

Jack: “I do love you!”

Jill: “Then why did you go hiking without me?!”

Jack: “Because I wanted alone time.”

Jill: “Liar. You don’t love me, you broke our contract; see you in court!”

How would a judge determine if in fact Jack broke the contract, assuming that promising to remain in love is part of the contract’s terms? Assume also that Jack doesn’t want a divorce. Do you watch Breaking Bad? If you do, there is an analagous situation later in the series with Skyler and Walter where one of them refuses to sign divorce papers, but the other one REALLY wants a divorce. In effect, they’re forced to be together, and the “relationship security” really is promised, at the cost of another person’s happiness.

 

Haven’t watched Breaking Bad, but if Jill could prove her case in court I suppose Jack would be forced to divorce Jill.  I’m not aware of anyone/situation where a breach of contract wouldn’t lead to some form of restitution.  As to how a judge would determine who the guilty party was, whatever agreements were in place should be sufficient to reach a decision.  Your example as is, isn’t sufficient for me to know what that decision might be.

 

I believe a promise to love essentially means a promise to care for, so while it’s true the emotion love cannot be forced, the action care certainly can, as in cases of court awarded custody, alimony, etc.

Sorry, but I must use the R-word. This is an example of rationalism in thinking, because everyone is familiar with the concept of a “messy divorce”. It is not at all uncommon that a couple who once thought they’d spend their lives together want to do all sorts of things to hurt the other during a divorce.

…

 

Yes that’s true, but generally the cause is betrayal, where the guilty partner specifically misrepresents the love professed in order to get away with something undeserved.  There are enough clean separations to know that “messy divorces” aren’t unavoidable.  Do you believe Objectivists would commonly have “messy divorces”?

 

…

 

No, the law must  not  always enforce the original terms. More often it must compute guilt and damages. This is rational because it is reality-based: it takes cognizance of the nature of human beings and of relationships.

 

Wouldn’t that be more commonly recognized prior to sanctioning a problematic agreement.  Just as one cannot agree to commit a crime, one cannot agree to force the impossible.

So, you think then something like moving out should have police prevent it? If the goal of such agreements as not moving out is to try to foster somebody liking you, I’m pretty sure forcing them to stay would just be counterproductive and breed resentment rather than making things better.

 

The police regularly look for and require reluctant child supporters to fulfill their obligations.  But I agree that imprisoning someone to foster affection isn’t likely to succeed. 

Do you believe Objectivists would commonly have “messy divorces”?

Just take a look at how Objectivists (at least much of the current crop) treat each other today…

But I agree that imprisoning someone to foster affection isn’t likely to succeed. 

“Likely to succeed”! I hope that’s not the importance consideration.

If your spouse had no affection for you any more, would you want someone to coerce her in some way? (Sounds like a contradiction to try.) Would you want some, even minor, penalty applied to her? 

 

Personally, I cannot imagine agreeing to a marriage contract that says that my wife has to pay some type of penalty if she no longer loves me, or loves someone else more and wants to move on. Of course it makes sense to understand how our joint property will be split, and how the custody of the kids will be decided, but apart from that, it would be pretty insecure, impractical and evil for me to penalize her for any lack of love.

Haven’t watched Breaking Bad, but if Jill could prove her case in court I suppose Jack would be forced to divorce Jill. 

 

I thought, according to you, a marriage contract would make Jack feel more secure about his romantic relationship and love?  How can he truly feel more secure if Jill can force Jack to divorce, by simply stating she doesn’t think Jack loves her at all anymore, even if Jack is telling the truth that he still loves her?

 

Perhaps you mean marriage increases security of love between rational people, except that doesn’t seem possible if you can’t develop a contract which can resolve disagreements over if the contract has been broken.

I thought, according to you, a marriage contract would make Jack feel more secure about his romantic relationship and love?

…

 

I tried to respond to this in post #47, but you didn’t answer…

 

Let’s try this one step at a time.  Do you agree that making agreements about behavior, e.g., not committing adultery, would increase the likelihood of enjoying a long term romantic relationship?

 

That is the kind of emotional security I’ve been referring to.  Not to force someone to continue loving you, but to agree to certain kinds of behavior that increase the likelihood of maintaining ones love long term.  Ones emotional mechanism acts like a barometer of the efficacy of ones actions, remember??  By agreeing to promote some actions and avoid others, one stands a fair chance at maintaining ones love long term.

 

This lies at the core of pursuing happiness and is entirely consistent with the practice of Objectivism… to make rational choices that promote ones well being.  How is it then, that the emotion love remains so mysterious to Objectivists that one apparently falls in and out of it for no reason at all?

Agreements help, yes. It doesn’t then follow contractual agreements are enhancements of all non-contractual agreements. The problem is saying contracts can secure you from things they cannot secure you from when there is no way for the law to determine if a contract is broken.

My post was to say you’ve contradicted yourself, where you say marriage provides security of love, but then say Jill’s mere accusation is sufficient to end the marriage and force a divorce. Jack wants the marriage, Jill doesn’t.
 

How is it then, that the emotion love remains so mysterious to Objectivists that one apparently falls in and out of it for no reason at all?

No one said “no reason at all”. If you think Jill has no reason at all, modify it to say that her reason is the values of the two have changed.

Jill: “Sorry, Jack, but ever since I changed my job to be a chef, my values have been changing, even in little ways. I don’t think I love you anymore.”
Jack: “But you said you’d love me, and we made vows even when we got married!”
Jill: “I know, but my life has changed in ways I didn’t expect. I still like you, I just don’t want to keep our romantic relationship.”
Jack: “I love you though, how can you not love me too?”
Jill: “I don’t know really, but it happened.”
Jack: “Let’s try to fix this, I don’t want a divorce, the marriage still applies.”
Jill: “No, Jack, I don’t feel love. You didn’t wrong me. I changed.”

Jill fell out of love while still taking all the actions to maintain love. She didn’t choose to fall out of love or even neglect Jack. But Jack is still in love. Marriage according to you secures Jack from the worry that this would happen. If Jill can force a divorce, she has suffered no consequence of betraying her love. Unless you want to say Jack can hold Jill legally responsible for the emotional pain the breakup caused? This should be a good example of 2 rational people disagreeing, where if a marriage secured love, it would be in Jack’s favor. This is when love ends while still taking actions to support love.

…

My post was to say you’ve contradicted yourself, where you say marriage provides security of love, but then say Jill’s mere accusation is sufficient to end the marriage and force a divorce. Jack wants the marriage, Jill doesn’t.

…

 

In you 1st example I said, if Jill could prove her case in court Jack would have to divorce Jill, not that her “mere accusation” would be sufficient.  There’s a difference and you know it.

 

Your 2nd example still requires Jill to establish cause, i.e., some fault on Jack’s part.  If for example Jill were contractually bound to supply Jack with parts, telling a judge she no longer felt like supplying them wouldn’t be sufficient to release her from her obligation.  Jack would be entitled to restitution, and that would be in his favor.  Also the “consequence of betraying her love” would be a loss of integrity making any future agreements all the more difficult to secure.

 

Look, my argument is primarily supported by 3 premises:

  1. Ayn Rand correctly identifies man as a contractual animal that relies on making agreements with others and holding them accountable,

  2. Ayn Rand correctly identifies man’s emotional mechanism as a barometer of the efficacy or impotence of his actions,

  3. that the pursuit of happiness, e.g., spending the rest of ones life with a loving partner is more likely to be achieved by agreeing to hold each other accountable to actions that are mutually beneficial.

 

Any effort to force someone to continue loving you by contract or imprisonment is outside the scope of my argument, period.

“obligation to act consistently with regard to the love once professed”

 

-that’s a great way to put it. i do agree with that.

In you 1st example I said, if Jill could prove her case in court Jack would have to divorce Jill, not that her “mere accusation” would be sufficient.  There’s a difference and you know it.

 

I didn’t say “if she could” really, but of course if she could if she proved her case based upon her accusation. But what evidence would possibly be sufficient in a court?

If your argument is just those 3 points, then it looks like you retract this statement: “When individuals freely promise to love one another forever, then yeah they ought to be held accountable for having a change of heart later on.” Yes, the consequence on Jill is possibly Jack’s view of Jill, but that is not due to the legal agreement, since it isn’t a consequence of the law. That’s an agreement separate from marriage.

I didn’t say “if she could” really, but of course if she could if she proved her case based upon her accusation. But what evidence would possibly be sufficient in a court?

…

 

How about proving that Jack’s sudden desire for “alone time” involved spending it with another Jill?

 

I’m a bit pressed for time now, but later on I’d like to take another shot at answering your initial question.