I’d agree with Burgess that the current purpose of OO.net, as defined in the rules, does not include attempts to convert non-Objectivists. Indeed, the ones who wander by are usually dispatched with alacrity. Still, a forum of that type could exist without duplicating ARI’s efforts.
What a forum can do is quite different from what the ARI can do. A forum is a more personalized and intense form of communicating. Of course it would be a waste trying to change a die-hard “irrationalist”. However, many people are at a point where they’d say: “I like certain things Ayn Rand says, but …”. There are so many possible objections: “it’s too impractical”, “it’s too extreme”, “it’s a belief like any other, and while I believe it, I won’t say it is objective”, “I think there is still a place for God in a little corner of my heart”, … etc.
Many such people are not irretrievable. I have personally convinced a few such people to see differently; I assume the same can be done via a forum. While the best way for such people to learn would be to read some of Ayn Rand’s books, there are reasons that they do not; these are similar to the reason I do not read Kant. They are not really “philosophical” and aren’t motivated to read a book about philosophy. They’ve accepted the idea that philosophy is not a science, but something “personal”. They’ve accepted the idea that philosophy is not really practical, and might even be a waste. However, they have not accepted these by much rigorous thought, mostly just because they’ve never examined the issues closely enough.
I think it is plausible that a certain number of such people can be at least brought to a stage where they are intrigued enough about certain ideas that they would get an Ayn Rand book and read it.
I also agree with Burgess’s objection about the use of trickery etc. That is not the way to change minds. Indeed I have rarely known a case where someone’s mind was changed without showing an understanding of their position. This does not mean that one shows agreement, but that one shows understanding of the structure of their knowledge. Without this, the person is simply left feeling misunderstood or tricked: “I can’t refute you, but I don’t think you’re right”. Even people who hold opinions because the majority does, do not think of it that way. One needs to explore the reasons they hold in their mind. Sometimes these reasons are ill-formed and one has to actually help the opponent enunciate them: “do you think one must do this so that the poor may… or because the …” etc.
Having said all that, I do not think the format of the forum – as it stands today – can achieve that end. Also, I do not know if there are enough people who want to play “Objectivist evangelist”.