Two incidents that happened today.
- In the morning, my son was all set to watch a particular program on TV. At his age, this is an important value to him. We checked the TV program on the online TV Guide and the web, to be sure about the time. Then, for some reason, the program did not air. (I guess the reported schedules/guides were just wrong.)
My son was in tears. He has about 60 other episodes of this series on various DVDs and cassettes. Yet, the schedule showed this was a new episode, and he was really looking forward to it.
I empathize with his feeling of disappointment. No, I cannot get into his mind, nor can I feel his pain. Despite that, I can empathize with him because I have felt disappointments too in situations where I had done everything right, and then something out of my control had gone wrong.
As an adult, I have to help him understand the context and understand how “in the scheme of his life”, this is a minor disappointment that he must “get over”. However, I must do so without belittling the value, nor the strength of his value for it. Also, I have to help him learn how to deal with it: for instance, by finding some other “fun-thing” to do.
The problem is, that if one starts by saying something like: “It’s just a single episode… it’ll come again… you can do something else that’s fun…”, it does not work. The child – in his own way – realizes that you have no clue how he is feeling (i.e. your lack of empathy is evident). He does not react well and your lesson is wasted. Also, this is often the starting point for an isidious lesson: teaching a child to repress their emotions.
What works best and is also the most justly-respectful of my child’s values and the automated response to a loss of such value? I have found that the most friendly and rational approach is to show that you understand why he is sad and disappointed (and I genuinely do). Acknowledging an emotion is acceptance: “it is okay to feel sad when you lose an important value”. After giving this some time (and the “duration of mourning” depends on what values have been lost), you’ll find that the child will rebound and probably suggest some other “fun-thing” he could be doing instead of “wasting his time” crying.
Now for the second incident:
- I was speaking to the mother of my child’s pal. She was talking about an exam she had to take. It was gruelling test for certification to be a doctor. It was split across two full days. “It’s going to be really tough because one of those days is the day I fast”, she said.
She explained that she had started a religious fast one day a week. (Ostensibly, her God sympathizes with the pain such a fast implies and ends up bestowing some value on her: like a better job, a better grade, or whatever.) I know religious people who would have reacted with a sentiment like: “Oh! you poor thing, how unfortunate that your exam is on the day of your fast.”
However, I neither empathized nor sympathized. (I simply bit my tongue, fighting back the urge to say “Serves you right”
)
Summary: Empathy is when you understand “where a person is coming from”, because you have “been there , done that”. Sympathy is when you think the place “they’re coming from” is a legitimate one. I think a just person can feel sympathy.