I was recently arguing with some co-workers about mind-body separation, specifically why emotion should not be considered separate from rational thought or somehow immune to explanation. I guess I didn’t do a very good job, because they weren’t convinced. In summation, their argument seemed to draw it’s strength from numbers and volume, as well as appeal to sanctity and ultimate incomprehensibility of emotion. Not to mention condescension bordering on rudeness when I told them I understood why I have loved and do love the people in my life. But I digress.
This conversation set me to wondering about the statement, “I know how you feel.”
Can this statement ever be objectively true? I have lost a pet, and person A may have also, but does he really understand the depth of feeling for my poor departed gerbil?
What if I were to say it to a cancer patient, if I myself had never had cancer? I believe I know a great deal about the suffering they may be enduring, at least academically, but does that make what I say the truth? What if I did have cancer, but no longer was suffering from it? What if the cancer was the same, but he or she was leaving behind a family, while I was single? Do I truley understand how he or she feels if the circumstances are totally different but the affliction is the same?
When is it appropriate to say, “I know how you feel?”
The term “I know how you feel” can be taken in its literal sense, that you are aware of the feeling the person is experiencing on a mental level (e.g. Saying, “I know how you make a cake” does not mean that you have ever made one). I think the meaning has corrupted though, and most people assume you mean that you have experienced scenarios similar to theirs, in which you had similar feelings. This connotation is dangerous, and does lead to misunderstandings “You can’t possibly know how I feel!!”
When my father died, I would have preferred it if people had spoken about their emotion, and then held their peace, not venturing to explore my emotions. This may just be me though. I know when my uncle was dying of cancer he would ask people to leave if they couldn’t carry on a conversation. He would say “Look at my mind, not at my cancer.” Again, my uncle may be unusual, but I have heard similar things from friends who are handicapped, protesting that a quick “I know how you feel,” is both shallow and untrue, and carrying on a conversation with them about topics other than their ailment actually gives more comfort. As for a quick response, I have none. I often envy the religious, who can say “I’m praying for you,” which to them means something similar to “I care that you are suffering,” which is of course, rather awkward to say.
I often envy the religious, who can say “I’m praying for you,” which to them means something similar to “I care that you are suffering,” which is of course, rather awkward to say.
How about, “Please let me know if there’s anything I can do for you”?
I’m praying for you is saying both that they care, and that they’re powerless. You can express that sentiment without the mysticism.
I have heard similar things from friends who are handicapped, protesting that a quick “I know how you feel,” is both shallow and untrue, and carrying on a conversation with them about topics other than their ailment actually gives more comfort.
That and endlessly talking about their handicap is extremely tedious. It’s like having an unusual name that lends itself to a particular pun . . . you’ve heard it thirteen million times and you want to get on with things without having to endure the discussion AGAIN.
I’ve always made it a policy to avoid discussing handicaps/illnesses/deaths in the family etc. with people unless they indicate to me, first, that they want to talk about it. I file it under the politeness heading of “intrusive behavior”. It’s still awkward because some people seem to consider this “rude”, which I find incredibly annoying. Excuse me, I’m not being rude, I’m acknowledging the fact that we never had anything to say to each other *before* your mother died, so why should I presume to be your intimate confidant *now*?! This, in turn, leads to the “I know how you feel” statement, because we feel like they have to say *something* to indicate that we are abstractly sympathetic without being intrusive.
I think the strategy of sharing your own experiences without asking for or expecting reciprocal sharing from the suffering party is probably the best one.
I was recently arguing with some co-workers about mind-body separation, specifically why emotion should not be considered separate from rational thought or somehow immune to explanation. I guess I didn’t do a very good job, because they weren’t convinced. In summation, their argument seemed to draw it’s strength from numbers and volume, as well as appeal to sanctity and ultimate incomprehensibility of emotion. Not to mention condescension bordering on rudeness when I told them I understood why I have loved and do love the people in my life. But I digress. (boldface added for emphasis)
You could have made the most logically integrated argument possible, had used eloquent language, identified all of their errors and still not have convinced them. Whether through evasion, or being unable to think in terms of principles, or simply need more time to fully understand an idea’s full implications (a conversation is a good starting point, but it is not enough) you must not make the mistake of thinking that simply because you are correct that you can convince people to accept your ideas as being true. Most importantly, don’t take such a failure as proof that you are wrong. Reality will give you proof either way. As a rule, if I am engaging somebody that does not share my viewpoint I don’t try to argue with them or convince them of anything. To the extent that the other is curious of my views, I’ll make an effort to inform him of what they are and my reasons behind them. If I know I that I am not able to answer his questions adequately (due to lack of time, interest, or sufficient knowledge) I will try to point him to a source that can. Those who are basically rational and honest, even though they may have accepted false ideas, will be able to put two and two together.
Now as to the content of your argument, you have raised a subject which will bother a majority of people that you encounter. You state correctly that emotions are not inexplicable. One can know and identify their causes. In actuality, this goes one step further with an ethical implication that in order for one to build and maintain his own happiness, he has the responsibility to introspect and identify the premises behind his emotions. Thus to a person who does not introspect (or does so superficially) an argument in favor of the objective accountability of emotions through reason is a reproach to their manner of living. Consequently, such a person will only be able to subconsciously understand this as a reproach and will react with emotional negativity. If the co-workers you were attempting to reach are important enough to you on a personal level, a better approach to this issue would be to repurpose the discussion around how using the principles of Objectivism combined with introspection has led you to much greater happiness and achievement as well as a better understanding of who you are; plus let them know that it is of personal importance to you that they can find the same for themselves. If they don’t matter to you on a personal level, I’d just cut my losses and move on.
And it’s alright man, I know how you feel. 