In college I took a course called “The Aesthetics of Art”. It was a discussion class and everyone came into it with unique perspectives on what exactly art is. Whether they were the strict classicists, dismissing anything that did not necessarily require classical training to create, or the flimsy types that thought “everything and anything could be art as long as it is beautiful”. At the end of the course everyone left with a more centrist agenda. I know I began to appreciate things I had at one time dismissed as craft or decoration instead of art.
I’m interested in what your limits of art are, forget any hierarchy of man’s design and create your own. For instance, say, my taste for Miming over that of Caricature Portraits. I will list a few interesting cases and you all respond accordingly. Is it art? Why?
Case One:
In 1964, the Parisian performance artist Ben Vautier sat down in the middle of a street in Nice with a placard on his lap. The placard read, “Regardez moi cela suffit je suis art.” [“Look at me. That’s all it takes; I’m art.”] He then had himself photographed in this position.
Was he right? Is this self proclamation enough to constitute art? Or is it the result of some mis-guided narcissism? Is he critiquing the method that popularly accepted art is produced?
Case Two:
In Liverpool, England, late in 1983, a wine merchant named Maureen Gledhill bought an abstract painting from Ernest Cleverley, a sculptor who also runs a pet shop. When Ms. Gledhill walked into the shop, the sculptor had been discussing the picture with Brian Burgess, an artist, and she believed it was one of Burgess’ works. She paid $105 for the painting, thinking it a bargain, and displayed it prominently in her home.
But it turned out that the painting was the work of a duck named Pablo, who had escaped from his cage while Cleverley, the sculptor, was doing some painting, and had got his feet in the paint. “The duck,” said Cleverley, “is a natural.”
Should Gledhill have been disappointed to find out this was the work of a frantic duck, without intent of cause or pattern? Does art necessarily require a human element at all? Would you have kept the painting, or asked for your money back?
Case Three:
Okay, here’s a hypothetical one. Suppose a well-known artist happens to be vacationing in the small community where you are curator of the local museum. One day you see him walking along the beach, and you tell him that your museum - although it is almost without funds to purchase new works - would be greatly honored to be given a work by him. The artist pauses, smiles in an indecipherable way, and bends over to pick up a piece of driftwood that is lying on the beach. “Here,” he says with a glint in his eye, “take this. Call it Driftwood.”
As curator, do you exhibit the driftwood or not? [Your gallery would be greatly enhanced by acquiring a genuine work by this famous artist.]
If this topic sparks any interest, perhaps I will post more cases later. For now, tell me what you think.