The Golden Mean, or All Things in Moderation

39 minutes ago, AlexL said:

There is no free speech on a private forum. 

There’s a balance to be had what to permit and not permit. My absolute hard limit would be Q-believers and anyone being on the level of an actual admitted fascist, or straight up racists. Those are the people that I think poison the well and you need no further proof that they will be acting in bad faith every time they open their mouth. Then there is throwing out the ban hammer just because someone said something that you thought was a really bad take. Not very productive to do that.

It makes sense to have some toleration for those people with bad takes, but you can still inject influence into the discussion and actively encourage better and more rational thinking. Or more benevolent thinking. 

 

1 hour ago, AlexL said:

There is no free speech on a private forum.

There is, if and to the extent that the forum’s owners and moderators allow it.

1 Like

@AlexL

Another one of Objectivism Online’s less often enforced rules. <—for a full list, click the underlined.

Reporting violations of the rules

Do not post complaints about the behavior of any member on the forum - report them to the moderators. Public complaints about other members will be treated as a personal attack and may be deleted!

If you think someone deserves a warning, please use the “Report!” link found on every post. The offender will not know who reported him.

 

Rules or guidelines ?

https://www.differencebetween.com/what-is-the-difference-between-guidelines-and-rules/

(as far as know this source hasn’t made any claims pertaining to the FBI or Covid , so golden)

3 hours ago, AlexL said:

Are you sure about your wording? Instead of “invalidity” did you mean validity?

Well obviously free speech also requires that we allow people to post valid arguments. But yes, I meant invalidity.

3 hours ago, AlexL said:

Besides, I was speaking about arbitrary claims, those which were presented without proof/justification even after such justification was demanded.

Sometimes people have decided that they can deem facts they don’t like to be “arbitrary” just so that they can then demand that those facts be removed from consideration and debate.

I think each person should be able to make their own assessment about what is “arbitrary” because that’s just another form of making their own assessment about what is “invalid.”

9 hours ago, Eiuol said:

9 hours ago, AlexL said:

There is no free speech on a private forum. 

There’s a balance to be had what to permit and not permit.

Sure, but it is misleading to couch it in terms of freedom of speech, that is as a right. Freedom of speech is a guarantee for non-limitation by government etc., while on a forum the owner does legitimately define the limits – at his discretion, in the form of forum rules.

Quote

Then there is throwing out the ban hammer just because someone said something that you thought was a really bad take.

Nu, someone’s refusal to justify his own claims is an easy to establish fact , not an opinion  (if I correctly understand what the idiom “bad/good take” means).

Quote

It makes sense to have some toleration… [to] encourage better and more rational thinking.

Allowing arbitrary claims dis courages rational thinking. Baseless claims are irrational thinking.

10 hours ago, necrovore said:

12 hours ago, AlexL said:

There is no free speech on a private forum.

There is, if and to the extent that the forum’s owners and moderators allow it.

Therefore freedom means doing/saying what you are allowed to !

9 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

Reporting violations of the rules

Do not post complaints about the behavior of any member on the forum - report them to the moderators. Public complaints about other members will be treated as a personal attack and may be deleted!

  1. Does this mean, for example, that, if someone makes a claim and refuses to justify it, I cannot tell him directly about that and I should instead complain to the moderators?

  2. And if I do, what will the moderators do? I suppose they will first check the rules and see if there was a violation. In this example, is there a violation of the rules? It doesn’t seem to be… at least not explicitly.

  3. Therefore the moderators will do nothing. The result will be: I am not allowed to tell him that justifying ones own claims is part of a rational debate, and the moderators will not caution him either.

Is this OK?

9 minutes ago, AlexL said:

Is this OK?

Good questions. Obviously without moderator intervention, and such a rule being adhered to, #3 would stand.

#2 would depend on the quality of volunteers to a moderator pool.

#1. Would insistence for providing justification have more weight coming from the general rank and file, or the voluntary maintainers of the site?

 

9 hours ago, necrovore said:

But yes, I meant invalidity.

Then the following

14 hours ago, necrovore said:

Free speech […] requires that we allow people to make invalid arguments, on the basis that the invalidity, if it is not already apparent, will become so eventually.

doesn’t make sense to me (I am not sure anymore that I am allowed to tell this to you directly​:worried:).

 

9 hours ago, necrovore said:

13 hours ago, AlexL said:

Besides, I was speaking about arbitrary claims, those which were presented without proof/justification even after such justification was demanded.

Sometimes people have decided that they can deem facts they don’t like to be “arbitrary” just so that they can then demand that those facts be removed from consideration and debate.

I think each person should be able to make their own assessment about what is “arbitrary” because that’s just another form of making their own assessment about what is “invalid.”

No, the above definition of “arbitrary” is very clear and the check is straightforward: was a justification given or not? Maybe you believe that only a justification that the other person finds convincing is a valid justification in this context, but no, the definition does not demand that, and I am conscious of this fact. Any justification removes the arbitrariness. Then follows the examination of the validity of the justification itself, which is a different stage.

9 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

Good questions. Obviously without moderator intervention, and such a rule being adhered to, #3 would stand.

#2 would depend on the quality of volunteers to a moderator pool.

#1. Would insistence for providing justification have more weight coming from the general rank and file, or the voluntary maintainers of the site?

The moderators enforce the Guidelines. The Guidelines do not specify that a user should justify his claims if asked to. 

Do you consider that he should?

And if you consider that he should, do you intend to do something about it? Because yes, insistence for providing justification has more weight coming from the moderator - because the moderator seems, according to the Guidelines, to have leverage.

PS. You reminded me of the correct procedure for “Reporting violations of the rules” described in the Guidelines. Can I assume that you don’t think that I acted improperly by directly communicating my specific displeasure to whyNOT?

@AlexL on that topic in particular, it would help to have someone with an interest in what is being hashed over.

In part, I created this thread to pull together some references to moderation, discovering that there are classes folk pay money to help develop the skill.

From the members that are relatively active on the forum, I would ask if there is any interest in volunteering for operating in that capacity here.

 

12 hours ago, AlexL said:

Allowing arbitrary claims dis courages rational thinking. Baseless claims are irrational thinking.

I’m saying that they aren’t offenses that need to be acted upon through post deletion or anything like that, that’s the sense tolerance of tolerance I’m talking about. But you can be intolerant in the sense of calling it out, and saying those kinds of claims are bad, or demonstrate how the claims in question aren’t valid. 

9 minutes ago, dream_weaver said:

it would help to have someone with an interest in what is being hashed over.

I think the moderator for Ukraine-related thread(s) should have NO special interest in the topic, should have no opinion, should be neutral.

Quote

In part, I created this thread to pull together some references to moderation, discovering that there are classes folk pay money to help develop the skill.

The skill you mentioned there has little to do with what is required here. Moderating a structured debate or debate competitions (as in high school) is essentially different, in my view. I think that the moderator should understand what is fair and just and should have some knowledge of informal logical fallacies.

Quote

From the members that are relatively active on the forum, I would ask if there is any interest in volunteering for operating in that capacity here.

The participants in the Ukraine thread should not be involved in the  moderation of this thread - conflict of interests. I, in particular, cannot moderate this thread, because I will be judge and party.

There is no need for a special moderator for Ukraine threads - unless you don’t feel like doing it, but then the problem is a different one.

57 minutes ago, AlexL said:

I think the moderator for Ukraine-related thread(s) should have NO special interest in the topic, should have no opinion, should be neutral.

My special interest in any topic I have interest in is to remain as objective as my knowledge and mental capacity allow me to. The notion of having no opinion and dispassionate neutrality flies in the face of what drew me to this philosophy.

57 minutes ago, AlexL said:

The skill you mentioned there has little to do with what is required here. Moderating a structured debate or debate competitions (as in high school) is essentially different, in my view. I think that the moderator should understand what is fair and just and should have some knowledge of informal logical fallacies.

I think I mentioned earlier, some of this was conference style debating particular.

In my previous paragraph addressing the first paragraph of your quote, I couldn’t tell you what informal logical fallacy the ideas of having “no special interest in the topic, should have no opinion, should be neutral” fall under.

57 minutes ago, AlexL said:

The participants in the Ukraine thread should not be involved in the  moderation of this thread - conflict of interests. I, in particular, cannot moderate this thread, because I will be judge and party.

There is no need for a special moderator for Ukraine threads - unless you don’t feel like doing it, but then the problem is a different one.

I can understand why a judge ought recuse himself from a case where a relative, spouse, close friend, or owns a financial holding in a company, for example.

Last I checked, that isn’t what OO is about. I understand that there can be personality conflicts. people can harbor grudges, talking past one another or even be egregious evasions or attempts to mislead. 

On as small a scale as is being operated on here, little short of calling in an outside arbitrator would seem to fit the criteria.

If you think whYNOT’s being evasive, why engage with him? If you think someone is a troll, why feed a troll?

—

Another way of tying this to my first point.

You have an interest in resolving something you don’t get in what is going on in the Russian/Ukrainian. Do you seek the answer from someone that isn’t going to provide it, or spend your days bemoaning how they are not acting how you think they should act? Wouldn’t that time be more objectively spent pursuing the answer your seeking in other places it might reside?

If you know an answer for certain and someone issues a falsehood, does that alter what you know? State the right answer, then it is there to point to and use for reference.

If you think this forum ought be run differently, that’s one thing. If it’s only about that thread then perhaps the problem is a different one.

16 hours ago, AlexL said:

Therefore freedom means doing/saying what you are allowed to !

If you’re allowed to do it, then you’re free to do it. Sounds synonymous to me. On the other hand, this syllogism seems wrong:

  • In a capitalist society, all forums are privately owned.
  • There is no freedom of speech on a privately owned forum.
  • Therefore, there is no freedom of speech in a capitalist society.

An exception is that you would have free speech if you owned your own forum. However, it should certainly be possible for a forum owner to allow free speech if he wants to, and I think that would be a good idea. (Of course, the government has to allow free speech, too, or free speech cannot exist.)

15 hours ago, AlexL said:

doesn’t make sense to me (I am not sure anymore that I am allowed to tell this to you directly​:worried:).

I have no objections.

Regarding free speech, though, I think it’s important to allow mistaken arguments even though they are mistaken. It may be possible and even necessary to learn from those mistakes, and to learn how to identify them as mistakes.

15 hours ago, AlexL said:

No, the above definition of “arbitrary” is very clear and the check is straightforward: was a justification given or not? Maybe you believe that only a justification that the other person finds convincing is a valid justification in this context, but no, the definition does not demand that, and I am conscious of this fact. Any justification removes the arbitrariness.

Maybe I am misunderstanding you, but that seems like a formula for infinite regress: I could offer a justification, only to be told that it, too, is arbitrary, so I would have to offer a justification for that, and so forth.

Ultimately the best I can do is tell you what part of reality needs to be looked at. The fact that there is a part of reality that can be looked at, should be enough to establish that the claim isn’t arbitrary. Most of the time, though, the part of reality involved is obvious. But nobody can offer any kind of proxy or substitute for that reality. You’re just going to have to look at reality.

4 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

My special interest in any topic I have interest in is to remain as objective as my knowledge and mental capacity allow me to. The notion of having no opinion and dispassionate neutrality flies in the face of what drew me to this philosophy.

There is a difference between how you run your own mind and how you run this board. You can decide (and say) that a point of view is invalid, without preventing it from being expressed.

An Objectivist book seller, for example, might well sell copies of the Critique of Pure Reason in his bookstore, even though he disagrees with it. He might want people to see its mistakes for themselves.

I suppose I believe the old saying that if you give the mistaken people enough rope, they will hang themselves. (Yeah, I’m aware that this might apply to me, too, but I’m willing to take the risk.)

14 hours ago, dream_weaver said:

My special interest in any topic I have interest in is to remain as objective […]

I will comment on this later, but I would like you to first answer my two  questions I asked earlier - here -  about the requirement of justifying one’s claims if asked to.

10 hours ago, necrovore said:

On 2/17/2023 at 12:55 PM, AlexL said:

Therefore freedom means doing/saying what you are allowed to !

If you’re allowed to do it, then you’re free to do it. Sounds synonymous to me.

:grin:No, they are not.

Quote

[…] you would have free speech if you owned your own forum. However, it should certainly be possible for a forum owner to allow free speech if he wants to, and I think that would be a good idea.

Yes, the forum’s owner should be able to decide what limits he wants to put, including no limits at all. But I think that putting no limits at all will rapidly transform the forum into a garbage dump.

Quote

Regarding free speech, though, I think it’s important to allow mistaken arguments even though they are mistaken.

I was not against allowing mistaken arguments. I was against systematically tolerating claims which are advanced without arguments and where the claimant refuses systematically to justify its claims. Proving ones claims is an essential element of a rational debate. Exactly in the same way as forming opinions based only on facts (vs on faith) is the essential characteristic of a rational adult. The link between the two is obvious: if one accepts conclusions w/o having based them on facts, one will be unable to justify them for third parties, if asked to. I thought all this is sooo obvious for the readers of this Objectivism forum…

10 hours ago, necrovore said:

On 2/17/2023 at 1:47 PM, AlexL said:

No, the above definition of “arbitrary” is very clear and the check is straightforward: was a justification given or not? Maybe you believe that only a justification that the other person finds convincing is a valid justification in this context, but no, the definition does not demand that, and I am conscious of this fact. Any justification removes the arbitrariness.

Expand  

Maybe I am misunderstanding you, but that seems like a formula for infinite regress: I could offer a justification, only to be told that it, too, is arbitrary, so I would have to offer a justification for that, and so forth.

Maybe you misunderstood me. Let us take an example, a realistic one (maybe even a real one). A person A claims that Russia attacked Ukraine because Ukraine was about to attack Russia and therefore, Russia’s attack was a preemptive one. (A preemptive attack in the above context is often considered legitimate). Now: a person B asks A to justify its claim - that Russia’s attack was preemptive and not simply an aggression.

Assume that A does answer (whoa! yeah, a rare occurrence): “A document with attack plans was found on an Ukrainian officer.” 

I continue: “Have YOU seen the document? If you haven’t, how do YOU know it is true? Can I see it? Why is it not published?” No answer from A…

There is no infinite regress in this realistic/real example ! The arbitrariness of the initial claim was rapidly established. The arbitrariness in both aspects: as claim presented on this forum without proof, as well as a conclusion accepted by A without proof.

Quote

You’re just going to have to look at reality.

Yes, ultimately someone has to… But where can you look to find the hows and the whys of the facts of reality - dead people, demolished houses… ? Let’s go into this some other time…

1 hour ago, AlexL said:

I will comment on this later, but I would like you to first answer my two  questions I asked earlier - here -  about the requirement of justifying one’s claims if asked to.

There is no metaphysical requirement to justify one’s claims if asked to.

Neither is there a requirement for an unjustified claim to be accepted by the recipient.

Given that there are three ways to express your displeasure, I’ve not taking little umbridge with your approach.

 

1 hour ago, AlexL said:

I will comment on this later, but I would like you to first answer my two  questions I asked earlier - here -  about the requirement of justifying one’s claims if asked to.

There is no metaphysical requirement to justify one’s claims if asked to.

Neither is there a requirement for an unjustified claim to be accepted by the recipient.

 

3 hours ago, AlexL said:

A very cool comment by @Nicky in the 2014 “Ukraine” thread mentioned above !

As a side note, (from another thread,) I noticed that Nicky had been banned from this site because a moderator did not care for his posting style. Even though I’ve since rescinded the ban (after I discovered it much later), I don’t think the poster has tried accessing the site since.