16 hours ago, AlexL said:
Therefore freedom means doing/saying what you are allowed to !
If you’re allowed to do it, then you’re free to do it. Sounds synonymous to me. On the other hand, this syllogism seems wrong:
- In a capitalist society, all forums are privately owned.
- There is no freedom of speech on a privately owned forum.
- Therefore, there is no freedom of speech in a capitalist society.
An exception is that you would have free speech if you owned your own forum. However, it should certainly be possible for a forum owner to allow free speech if he wants to, and I think that would be a good idea. (Of course, the government has to allow free speech, too, or free speech cannot exist.)
15 hours ago, AlexL said:
doesn’t make sense to me (I am not sure anymore that I am allowed to tell this to you directly
).
I have no objections.
Regarding free speech, though, I think it’s important to allow mistaken arguments even though they are mistaken. It may be possible and even necessary to learn from those mistakes, and to learn how to identify them as mistakes.
15 hours ago, AlexL said:
No, the above definition of “arbitrary” is very clear and the check is straightforward: was a justification given or not? Maybe you believe that only a justification that the other person finds convincing is a valid justification in this context, but no, the definition does not demand that, and I am conscious of this fact. Any justification removes the arbitrariness.
Maybe I am misunderstanding you, but that seems like a formula for infinite regress: I could offer a justification, only to be told that it, too, is arbitrary, so I would have to offer a justification for that, and so forth.
Ultimately the best I can do is tell you what part of reality needs to be looked at. The fact that there is a part of reality that can be looked at, should be enough to establish that the claim isn’t arbitrary. Most of the time, though, the part of reality involved is obvious. But nobody can offer any kind of proxy or substitute for that reality. You’re just going to have to look at reality.
4 hours ago, dream_weaver said:
My special interest in any topic I have interest in is to remain as objective as my knowledge and mental capacity allow me to. The notion of having no opinion and dispassionate neutrality flies in the face of what drew me to this philosophy.
There is a difference between how you run your own mind and how you run this board. You can decide (and say) that a point of view is invalid, without preventing it from being expressed.
An Objectivist book seller, for example, might well sell copies of the Critique of Pure Reason in his bookstore, even though he disagrees with it. He might want people to see its mistakes for themselves.
I suppose I believe the old saying that if you give the mistaken people enough rope, they will hang themselves. (Yeah, I’m aware that this might apply to me, too, but I’m willing to take the risk.)