Doing a rapid search on rational debates, I compiled the following – with unequal value and many repetitions. I am not very motivated to correctly structure this comment, but I think it might be useful for the reader and for @dream_weaver
A). THE FORUM for Ayn Rand Fans, from Rules and Guidelines:
-
Be sure that your posts are well-grounded in facts and logic
-
Avoid mind reading – inferring what someone is thinking or wants or feels when the person hasn’t said so and then treating that inference as a fact. This is poor reasoning, presumptuous, derails discussions, leads to flame wars, and is usually wrong.
B). From The ten rules for rational-critical argumentation (with explanations and examples)
1. Freedom rule
Parties must not prevent each other from advancing standpoints or from casting doubt on standpoints.
This rule prohibits argumentum ad baculum
2. Burden of proof rule
A party that advances a standpoint is obliged to defend it if asked by the other party to do so.
3. Standpoint rule
A party’s attack on a standpoint must relate to the standpoint that has indeed been advanced by the other party.
4. Relevance rule
A party may defend a standpoint only by advancing argumentation relating to that standpoint.
5. Unexpressed premise rule
A party may not deny premise that he or she has left implicit or falsely present something as a premise that has been left unexpressed by the other party.
6. Starting point rule
A party may not falsely present a premise as an accepted starting point nor deny a premise representing an accepted starting point.
7. Argument scheme rule
A party may not regard a standpoint as conclusively defended if the defense does not take place by means of an appropriate argumentation scheme that is correctly applied.
8. Validity rule
A party may only use arguments in its argumentation that are logically valid or capable of being made logically valid by making explicit one or more unexpressed premises.
9. Closure rule
A failed defense of a standpoint must result in the party that put forward the standpoint retracting it and a conclusive defense of the standpoint must result in the other party retracting its doubt about the standpoint.
10. Usage rule
A party must not use formulations that are insufficiently clear or confusingly ambiguous and a party must interpret the other party’s formulations as carefully and accurately as possible.
C** ).** From Ten Commandments[?] of Rational Debate (with examples)
-
Don’t attack a person’s character, but the argument itself. (Ad hominem)
-
Don’t misrepresent or exaggerate a person’s argument in order to make them easier to attack. (Straw Man Fallacy)
-
Don’t use small numbers to represent the whole. (Hasty Generalization)
-
Don’t argue your position by assuming one of its premises is true. (Begging the Question)
-
Don’t claim that because something occurred before, it must be the cause. (Post Hoc/False Cause).
-
Don’t reduce the argument down to only two possibilities when there is a clear middle ground. (False Dichotomy)
-
Don’t argue that because of our ignorance, a claim must be true or false. (Ad Ignorantiam).
-
Don’t lay the burden of proof onto the person who is questioning the claim. (Burden of Proof Reversal).
-
Don’t assume that this follows that, when it has no logical connection. (Non Sequitur).
-
Don’t claim that because a premise is popular, therefore, it must be true. (Bandwagon Fallacy).
D). Various
-
concentrating on essential(s)
-
Speakers may not bring up new points in a rebuttal speech (releasing a dozen of rabbits to be chased)
-
there is no obligation to have an opinion in a subject one have not researched. I have no opinion on this (yet?) is the honest attitude to have in such cases.
“That which can be asserted without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence.” (C. Hitchens?)
“You cannot reason people out of something they were not reasoned into (Jonathan Swift?)”
“Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity Hanlon’s razor”
“A bad argument is worse than ineffectual: it lends credence to the arguments of your opponents. A half-battle is worse than none: it does not end in mere defeat – it helps and hastens the victory of your enemies. (Ayn Rand)”