The Line- On Abortion

Using only birth as a criteria seems off base if the exact same being is there before. Another possible criteria that seems relevant is viability of the fetus outside the womb.

Both of these objections have been covered in the very lengthy, existing, thread on abortion.

I don’t see how they can be defended rationally, if you take the principle of individual rights seriously.

Birth is what creates an individual being. Before birth a “being” doesn’t exist.

Viability is a criterion that changes with the advancement of technology.

Taken together your two sentences, if enacted in law, would expose the mother to forced surgery.

“I don’t see how they can be defended rationally, if you take the principle of individual rights seriously.”

http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/argument…timidation.html

“Birth is what creates an individual being. Before birth a “being” doesn’t exist.”

Yes, and if for some reason the female waits too long, removing a fetus that is then capable of surviving is essentially a birth. I’m not referring to the “it could have become a person” fallacy. There is a point where removing the fetus from the female would just be a premature birth. It seems a worthwhile thing to research.

"Viability is a criterion that changes with the advancement of technology. "

Am I to infer that you are saying advances in technology shouldn’t have any sort of influence on ethics and morality? Just ignore any future data or technology? I also doubt that this has greatly changed. The embryo is just cells for quite a while, and for a while after that just a vaguely man shaped mass that would immediately expire upon removal. Thats nothing like a very late term fetus. Any Objectivist writing I could find refers to the cell or embryo phase of gestation, not say a ninth month pregnancy.

“Taken together your two sentences, if enacted in law, would expose the mother to forced surgery.”

No principle I’ve presented for debate forces anyone to do anything, and I’m not entrenched in them, I’m discussing potential views. If a principle was validated that led to the determination that abortions up to a certain month are ethical, but not after or changed our understanding of which procedures are ethical it wouldn’t be forcing anything on anyone. Determining that the procedure to achieve a certain result must be done a certain way at a certain time isn’t “force” against someone who desires the procedure.

http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/argument…timidation.html

This is completely absurd. Did you even read the entry you cited?

You need to develop a thicker skin. If you consider telling someone they’re wrong and then giving the reasons why to be argument from intimidation, then this may not be the place for you.

There is a point where removing the fetus from the female would just be a premature birth. It seems a worthwhile thing to research.

If she consents, then you may remove it. If she doesn’t consent, then you may not force her. That would be a violation of her rights.

Am I to infer that you are saying advances in technology shouldn’t have any sort of influence on ethics and morality?

Well its hard to predict the future. I suppose if we get to the Star Trek phase where a fetus can be molecularly transported out of the mother without any effect on her we might have something to talk about. Even there I should think you would need her consent. And certainly any procedure which involves surgery would require her consent.

No principle I’ve presented for debate forces anyone to do anything,

That’s why I said “if enacted in law”. If you just want to talk about ethics and not politics, and if you are only arguing for your right to call a woman who has a late term abortion “immoral”, then while I might disagree with you, I would defend your right to say such a thing.

Usually though, when abortion is the topic of discussion, we are discussing the woman’s rights with respect to the unborn fetus.

If a principle was validated that led to the determination that abortions up to a certain month are ethical, but not after or changed our understanding of which procedures are ethical it wouldn’t be forcing anything on anyone.

The ethics of the situation must address the woman’s rights and I cannot imagine a situation in which the rights of the woman are abrogated in favor of the fetus.

Determining that the procedure to achieve a certain result must be done a certain way at a certain time isn’t “force” against someone who desires the procedure.

OK, well, I’m not in favor of forced human incubation either.

If she consents, then you may remove it. If she doesn’t consent, then you may not force her.

Since we ARE talking abortion here, and partial birth abortion specifically given the stage of pregnancy this refers to, what exactly is the difference between delivering the baby and giving it up for adoption and just ripping it apart in place, then removing it? Seems to me like the former would be healthier for the woman at the very least, and I can’t imagine it being hugely more expensive for the woman, especially since the adoptive parents would presumably be willing to pick up the tab. Whose rights are violated in such a situation?

Also the Lexicon has, under abortion,

One may argue about the later stages of a pregnancy, but the essential issue concerns only the first three months.

The first clause clearly indicates that the issue is debatable regarding later pregnancies, quite possibly due to the recurring viability issue. The state of medical science was far more primitive when the Lexicon entry was written (1968) than today’s, so I think this issue deserves more than a “birth is the border between birth and nothingness, next topic!” I mean, what about the partial birth abortion, which involves half delivering a viable baby and then vacuuming out its brain? By the time someone is getting a partial birth abortion, they’ve had plenty of time to consider whether it’s wanted or not, and its perfectly viable.

Roe v. Wade was decided in 1973 so I think what Ayn Rand was referring to (if it was in 1968) by “but the essential issue concerns only the first three months” was the fact that abortion was illegal and the fact that most abortions are performed in the first trimester.

Here is more of what the Lexicon has:

An embryo has no rights. Rights do not pertain to a potential, only to an actual being. A child cannot acquire any rights until it is born. The living take precedence over the not-yet-living (or the unborn).

Abortion is a moral right—which should be left to the sole discretion of the woman involved; morally, nothing other than her wish in the matter is to be considered. Who can conceivably have the right to dictate to her what disposition she is to make of the functions of her own body?

Since we ARE talking abortion here, and partial birth abortion specifically given the stage of pregnancy this refers to, what exactly is the difference between delivering the baby and giving it up for adoption and just ripping it apart in place, then removing it? Seems to me like the former would be healthier for the woman at the very least, and I can’t imagine it being hugely more expensive for the woman, especially since the adoptive parents would presumably be willing to pick up the tab. Whose rights are violated in such a situation?

This isn’t really the way it usually works. Rarely are adoptive parents found before birth and even more rarely are they willing to pick up the tab.

And if the mother is forced into surgery or into continued incubation, then clearly her rights are being violated

The first clause clearly indicates that the issue is debatable regarding later pregnancies, quite possibly due to the recurring viability issue. The state of medical science was far more primitive when the Lexicon entry was written (1968) than today’s, so I think this issue deserves more than a “birth is the border between birth and nothingness, next topic!” I mean, what about the partial birth abortion, which involves half delivering a viable baby and then vacuuming out its brain? By the time someone is getting a partial birth abortion, they’ve had plenty of time to consider whether it’s wanted or not, and its perfectly viable.

Late term abortions are rare and doctors that perform them are very rare but you can imagine many scenarios in which one might be necessary, such as: the health of the mother is in jeopardy, a congenital defect is discovered, the father is killed or leaves and the mother doesn’t want to continue … etc. etc. etc.

This is a very personal decision, a decision that should be left to the judgement of the woman and her doctor. Do you think that someone else’s judgement should be involved? Even if the decision is made on the basis that the woman just doesn’t want to continue the pregnancy, should that decision be overridden and the woman’s rights denied in favor a potential life?

As to viability, if we use that as the deciding criterion, then you can definitely imagine that not to far into the future an embryo will be viable outside the womb using some new technology. What then? Forced surgery to remove unwanted embryos within the first trimester?

And I wasn’t trying to cut off debate it is just that this ground has been covered before in a 55 page thread here

The issue is settled in my mind and I have stated my reasons but if you are unsure, please continue. Maybe the other thread has covered the issues you have.

Edit to add last paragraph

I admit I am proposing scenarios that do not apply very well to what most folks actually do. What I was trying to get at is the fact that partial birth abortion is still a form of surgery - why undergo the procedure rather than induce a delivery or get a c-section, then give the child up for adoption? Is one procedure significantly more expensive or dangerous than the other?

I concede that I’m not the best informed on the technical details here, and I’m not trying to continue the endless abortion debate here, just trying to expand my own knowledge of the issue with these questions.