Even though I come from a strong Christian background, I’ve found my relatively rapid “conversion” to Objectivism to be remarkably smooth. Any time that an ingrained, irrational premise or belief was challenged by the tenets Objectivism, I’ve never had to spend more than a little while puzzling things over before coming to a fully integrated conclusion – always deciding in Objectivism’s favor. However, I seem to have hit a snag.
The issue with which I am having so much trouble could be resolved if only I could justifiably answer the following question: at what point along the gradient from two-celled organism (immediately after conception) to fully-grown does a biological human being become a person? In other words, at what point does a human being acquire rights, specifically the right to life? As you have probably guessed, I am struggling with deciding my position on abortion.
An embryo is obviously not a rights-bearing person. An embryo cannot perceive its environment, and thus has no consciousness nor a conceptual faculty. Similarly, a newborn baby is obviously a rights-bearing person. But what separates a newborn baby from one who is still inside his mother late in the third trimester? Does the unborn, but comparably developed, baby possess the same rights as the newborn? If so, at what point during developing in the womb does a fetus become a person? If not, why? (Is it simply the fact that he has not yet been born? If so, why does an event that can happen in a fairly wide range of time – my niece was 3 weeks premature, my nephew a week late – determine whether a human being has rights?)
If man’s rights have their origin in his nature as a rational being, as Objectivism says they do, when is human being rational enough to have those rights, to be man?
Please understand that I am not approaching this from an anti-rights, anti-life position as so many “pro-lifers” do. I am very much pro-life in the Randian sense. As I said, an embryo obviously doesn’t have rights, while a baby does. My concern actually comes from my great esteem for the rights of man: I am troubled that I cannot tell with finality when a human being is a right-bearing person and when they are just a bundle of cells, because that leaves open the possibility that I might condone the destruction of a right-bearer.