So, why aren’t some of the higher animals treated as the same status as babies, morally and politically?
One part of that question is why rational capacity is what counts rather than actually being rational. You’d probably ask why a potential matters here, but not for a fetus having rights. I’m not working to answer this part.
What I am answering, though, is why animals don’t have a rational capacity. Answering that also answers why a fetus doesn’t either, as long as you agree with my reasoning that a fetus is not just a type of person - and assuming a fetus is a person begs the question that a fetus really has a rational capacity.
Rational capacity is the capability of being rational by virtue of the right types of neural and cognitive mechanisms being available. A baby has this capacity, although it develops over time. Still, they possess the right mechanisms, that’s how a baby learns human language. To be clear, I’m just giving a more detailed explanation of capacity than Rand did, she mostly answered the first question above.
Animals like dogs, cows, or alligators don’t have the right types of mechanisms. No matter how much you train or teach them, they won’t be rational. Their brain literally cannot do it. Their rational capacity can’t increase, it’s literally not there. You could make a case for elephants and dolphins as some sort of borderline rational capacity, but that’s an exhaustive list.
As for a baby, their rational capacity doesn’t change. In some sense, it does, as there are changes like greater counting ability, but that’s similar to adding RAM to a computer. Yes, it does more, but it still has the same general abilities as before. It still computes answers with the same general methods. Compare your current computer to a quantum computer though, and the general method is different.
The human method is cognition with concepts. The animal method is something perceptual and some type of calculation (it’s not behaviorism). These methods even distinguish babies from animals, despite often having similar abilities. The only way for an animal to cross over into the human method is evolution - it’s a potential. However! The animal would be a new species, a new entity entirely.