Although I think Jack is a little off base with the apparent assertion that one can’t determine a person’s intentions from their own stated intentions, setting up a straw man isn’t doing anything to prove it. A suspicious or threatening verbal statement is not the same thing as a direct physical threat.
What strawman? I simply picked a second example of someone logically, rather than arbitrarily, determining another person’s intentions, based on his previous actions rather than an admission. You know that raising his gun at you is meant as a threat through logically determining his intentions, not through an arbitrary guess. Same way I can tell that a gang-member who’s buying a gun intends to use it to initiate force, not just in self defense.
It wasn’t a strawman, it was an example that easily defeats the claim that another man’s intentons are a complete mistery unless he tells me what they are. Was that not Jackethan’s claim?
Isnt this subjectivity? Or is there a certain classification of actions that warrant the relevance of motive? Why would it matter what an individual is going to do with a gun permit but not with a gun?
You can only legally buy a gun with a permit. I did not differentiate between guns and permits.
I simply differentiated between the right to self defense, and the need for a firearm. While the right to self defense is inalienable , and my motives for saying that and living by it are irrelevant as far as the truth of that statement (in bold) is concerned, granting someone a gun permit, thus allowing them to buy a gun, should not be done if there is a reasonable expectation, based on facts, that he intends to use it in a crime. (as opposed to for self defense) Those facts can be a previous criminal record, membership in a gang, intentions stated explicitly, etc.
And absolutely, motive (intentions, to be exact) can only be determined based on actions, or stated threats. Not based on arbitrary guesses about thought. It’s just that logic applied to someone’s actions and behavior in general is not an arbitrary guess about his thoughts, it’s a proper method of identifying a threat. We know Iran is a threat not because they called us to let us know, but based on past performance and current behavior, for instance. There’s nothing subjective or arbitrary about it. I believe I am in agreement with you on this, only Jackethan claimed otherwise.
That said, I’m in favor of citizens having guns, for self defense purposes, and a huge fan of Charlton Heston’s speeches at NRA conventions. But I’m also a fan of carry permits in big cities, I don’t see how they violate individual rights (in this case, the only relevant part, the right to self defense), as long as they aren’t designed to discourage gun ownership by law abiding citizens. (as they are today, in places like NYC)