I’m a bit puzzled. I’m not sure if it’s something about the way Objectivist express themselves, or if it’s something related to the English language.
Let’s take Marx/communism.
I’d say he applied reason (induction&deduction) consistently on the WRONG premises. (using emotions or traditions as valid epistemological tools)
Many ideologies are appealing to reasoning people/youth exactly because they embrace “reason as tool”, but apply it to wrong ideas.
Even before meeting Objectivism, I was a passionate defender of reason. Unfortunatelly, I was applying it to wrong principles (e.g. there is class strugle, therefore I must hate capitalism… the existence of “class strugle” being the error)
Now, on the other hand, Objectivists mean by “reason” not only the “tools” (induction and deduction), but also their use on PROPER premises, such as the Axioms of Existence.
The question is even more complex, since premises are (in)validated by the existence of contraditions. So, since communism involves contraditions, is the failure of communists to reform their premisses irational? I would argue that it is. (but this is more like meta-reason, meta-principles)
On the other hand, we have people who are against “reason as tools” too. Mainly mystics.
So, I think that there are 3 level of i/rationality:
-
irationality: mysticism, whim-worshipping, etc - people actively against induction/deduction
-
reason with wrong premisses: communists, existentialists (some?) and other academia (there is SOME reason in academia, but horrible premises/principles)
-
reason with proper principles: Objectivism
Now, (2) is possible only if premisses are outside the scope of reason itself. (the axioms of existence are axioms after all)
Seeing my own questions on the matter, I usually tend to call communists and existentialists simply “wrong”, instead of going for “irrational”. I can name their errors, and usually, these errors are wrong principles, not wrong methods/tools.
As dr. Peikoff notes in his introductory course (the realplayer streams on ARI), failure doesn’t make people re-evaluate their principles, but rather makes them want to try harder, so I’m not sure that communists mean to escape reality as such. There is a big degree of evasion, but is that irrationality?
What are your oppinions on the links between reason’s tools, premises, principles and reality (the ultimate judge)?
DISCLAIMER: I don’t mean in any way to simpathise with, or condone, communism, or Sartre-wannabes (although I once was one). I am 100% sure that they are wrong. I only want o explore HOW and WHY they are wrong, and is reason includes correct premises.