Rhetoric is something I sometimes give thought to. It’s one thing to know what to argue; it’s another to know how to argue it. My primary interest is in conversation between people who are judged to be fundamentally reasonable. Appealing to unreasonable people is another category, and rhetoric plays an important role there (as does propaganda), but I’m more interested in the question of how to deal with people who are basically reasonable. I do not take it for granted that because a man is reasonable, that any true argument will necessarily sway him; I think that rhetoric is a consideration yet. Reason requires its own, particular approach.
There are a number of different “stances” a person can take in a conversation or in an argument. Often I find people attempting to take on the role of a teacher or a lecturer. “I know what’s right. Your role is to listen to me and agree” is what it conveys.
But does that sort of conversation appeal to a reasonable person who has a disagreement? I don’t think it does very much.
While “ask and listen” sounds good – and I don’t mean to argue against it – I also find that sometimes people approach conversation like an interrogation or a trial. “List your reasons for X and put them in the following form…”
Again – and maybe this is only personal preference (but I do not believe so) – I don’t think sort of approach has much appeal. I don’t think it’s likely to make inroads.
In a conversation between reasonable people, I believe that it’s important – first and foremost – to convey one’s respect for both reason and the ability of one’s “opponent” to think critically and intelligently and honestly. It is a conversation among equals. The proper attitude in approaching some apparent controversy is to recognize that both parties believe something, but that they both must submit themselves to the following investigation. It’s an agreement that “while I currently believe X, if you can demonstrate Y, I will happily agree with you,” and asking the same in return.
I think that this is a call to put down some of the emotional baggage that often attends argument (and why that term is so often considered a negative thing). It reframes such argument from a competition (or a fight) to a collaboration: two minds cooperating to uncover truth.
I think it’s important to commit oneself to not hiding or dodging (as we are all capable of evasion or error; being “fundamentally reasonable” does not mean being flawlessly reasonable). Questions asked should be answered. Examples raised should be pursued. There is a necessary give/take to reasonable conversation, and a person who insists on always taking the lead or doing things his own way (“No, we’re not discussing that yet. This is what we must discuss first!”) is likely to exhaust his partner’s patience before coming to a point.
Common ground must be sought. Even if it’s basic and otherwise ridiculous, it helps to establish that the scope of the argument is not universal: that reasonable minds can agree, somewhere on something. In fact, I believe that every relevant point of agreement that can be found should be highlighted and cherished. This not only has the effect of assuaging a potentially doubtful or defensive mind, but it can help to isolate the true nature of the disagreement through relief. (It’s like testing the individual components of a faulty system.)
I think that reasonable conversation is mostly earnest (while “devil’s advocacy” style arguments or “reductio ad absurdum” or satire/sarcasm have their place, I find that they usually set me on edge more than they help to persuade, and especially when I am the target). It is cognizant of the fact that new ideas take time to consider/ingest/test/integrate, and does not demand immediate agreement or concession. It is generous in allowing the “benefit of the doubt,” and allowing for error or reconsideration (as opposed to “gotcha”).
Above all, reasonable conversation deals with ideas. The etiquette of such conversation demands that instead of discussing the supposed motivations of one’s partner, or trying to assess their morality (in holding to some position judged errant), or appeals to authority, or ad hominem, or poisoning the well through such tactics as “a reasonable person could never believe X,” an argument designed to appeal to another man’s reason concerns itself with the ideas under discussion.