In today’s world we hear endlessly about rights. Of our rights that are violated, of what our rights ought or ought not consist of, and over who will best defend them. Yet there is little talk - a brief statement of belief, if anything - as to the nature of rights, of where they come from and why we need them.
What is a right? A right is an agreement within a society that every individual has a legitimate, moral claim - thus, a “right” - to something. From the right to free speech to the right to government funded healthcare, what rights man has been debated endlessly.
How much freedom was contained in each man’s rights has waxed and waned throughout the centuries, but in the west, even in its darkest times, the question has largely been one of “what rights does man have?” instead of starting at the root question of it all, “ought men have rights?” The answer to that question - and the subsequent “Why?” - would lead you down a logical path that would easily answer what rights men had. If the answer to this first and all-important question is “yes”, the reasoning is correct, and the logic of applying it is sound, then the set of rights this system produces should be clear and easy to apply to the world.
Today’s popular theories on rights (such as they are) are simply two varients on the same theme. With them come the same fundamental problems, and the same holes which remain unaddressed. But these cannot simply be ignored in favor of just having some justification of rights and then moving on. An improper premise destroys that which it purports to justify. And so they have been used not only to defend rights, but, more and more as time goes on, as justification for the dissolution of rights.
In the USA especially, the religious defend rights on the grounds of faith. Man, they say, is a special creature. When he was created by God, he was endowed with special rights, which men are obligated to recognize - to be in line with God’s wishes. They rely on divine revelation to tell them what these wishes are.
Nonsense, the more secular say. Instead, they assert that rights are special privledges granted by the collective to its members, or to some segment of its members. The whims of “the people,” not some diety, determine what rights men have.
The common thread of these theories is that it is whim which determines the extent and nature of rights. Who’s whim - each equally arbitrary - is the only thing they differ on. Due to the nature of incorrect premises, these principles are now used as justification for the destruction of rights. Religious people think - quite logically - that if rights come from God, and we have rights because God says we do, why not follow His laws in other things as well? So they push for invasive government, paternalistic programs to promote “moral” behavior, and the outlawing of “sinful” practices (prostitution, homosexuality, etc.) The secularists descend into competing pressure groups, looking for their “rights” to be granted to them by the government. As both have progressed, they have gone from justifications for having rights to justifications to, in effect, have no rights. Rights that are subject to change by the whim of the people or can be nullified in the interest of a more moral law, then they do not exist.
Do men, then, need rights at all? Or are they, as some say, quaint constructions, with no basis in reality?
Men, like any beast, has certain requirements for living. Unique to all animals on earth, man’s only requirement to live is to be able to use his rational mind. He must be free to act on his own judgment about what course of action is best for him. Therefore, any other person who tries to make him act in contrary to his judgment (through fraud or force) has committed a great evil on the victim, and the victim is morally sound in stopping the act immediately and extracting value to compensate them for any time, effort or resources lost on the fraud or attempted use of force. This is the proper, moral reaction to such acts.
This does not change in a society. What does change is that, in a society, you may have a neutral arbiter of disagreements, and an objective set of laws which will set out the “rules” and allow these moral responses to force and fraud to be institutionalized, regulated and known to all people. These are what your “rights” are - in fact, your one and only right. A rule against anyone causing you to act against your own best judgment, either through fraud or force.
So, yes, man does have rights. He has one right - the right to act on his best judgment, free from coercion of any type from other men. That is the only thing that any man has the right to forbid other men to do - and, thusly, the only thing a moral government can forbid. To do anything more would be to violate this right on other people, and put the person who does this in the same moral category as a bandit.