logic behind...

what is the logic behind the following statements:

“when you deny the rights of one man you deny them of all men.”

“controls necessitate and breed more controls.”

i assume they’re somewhat interconnected.

“when you deny the rights of one man you deny them of all men.”

If there are 10 identical yellow pegs and you point to one and say “it is not yellow”, then you are denying the yellowness of all, in principle. Of course, you can point to one of the others and say “that’s yellow”. However, your declaration would be whimsical. Given the first declaration, there is no basis for the second declaration. If you follow that “principle”, you could whimsically declare any yellow peg to be yellow or non-yellow.

Similarly, if you point to one man and declare – without any particular reason – that he has no rights, then (in principle) you could (using that method) point to any man and say the same thing.

“when you deny the rights of one man you deny them of all men.”

Given that rights are factual conditions which need to remain in place for a man to live among other men, then if one deny’s a right of one man, they are implicitly denying some necessary, factual, general condition for man as such to live among other men.

Rights are conditions that need to remain in place for any man to live and flourish among other men. Rights are derived by studying the fundamental nature of man as a living organism, i.e., by studying and discovering the abstract principles (general rules) necessary for the species as such to live and flourish (whether he is attempting to live by himself, or with others, but especially important when he is attempting to live among others).

Rights only become necessary, when a man is contemplating forming/joining a society, where many men will be volitionally interacting, and there is the possibility for others to forcibly remove one of the necessary conditions needed for any given man to live and flourish.

A right to one’s life is a necessary condition for any man to live among other men.

A right to freedom is a necessary condition for any man to live among other men.

A right to dispose of one’s property is a necessary condition for any man to live among other men.

When one deny’s the right of one man, they are implicitly claiming,

“I or someone else needs to be able to dispose of their own property as a necessary condition for living among men (including you), but you… you don’t have such a necessity.”

Or

“I or someone else needs to be able to continuously act on my own judgment as a necessary condition for living among men (including you), but you… you don’t have such a necessity.”

To deny a right of a man, is to deny a general, necessary condition of his nature as a certain kind of living organism; a condition which is required for man to live and flourish among other men; a condition if forcibly denied would mean his death, either all at once, or by slow drawn out torture.

In “For the New Intellectual” pg 182, Ayn Rand puts the point,

“The source of man’s rights is not divine law or congressional law, but the law of identity. A is A—and Man is Man. Rights are conditions of existence required by man’s nature for his proper survival. If man is to live on earth, it is right for him to use his mind, it is right to act on his own free judgment, it is right to work for his values and to keep the product of his work. If life on earth is his purpose, he has a right to live as a rational being: nature forbids him the irrational. Any group, any gang, any nation that attempts to negate man’s rights, is wrong, which means: is evil, which means: is anti-life.”

See: Ayn Rand Lexicon: Individual Rights