Hello Everyone, I’ve been reading a TON about Objectivism and I love it. My brain is sore but I have the satisfaction of a good workout.
Anyway I want to know how to properly describe the following situation:
A person is presented with an issue or a problem
The person immediately knows the answer, or at least has a very strong lead
The person is proven correct through investigation
When I do this in my personal or business life people sometimes ask “how did you know that?” and honestly I was just trying the first thing that my brain produced. Internally I’m using concepts that I’ve built up over a lifetime and so I go from point A to point Z without thinking about it. I can’t necessarily draw out the entire conceptual hierarchy that went into coming up with that answer, but I know that it exists.
“I don’t know” (how I know) is obviously not the correct thing to say here. What is?
PS - My mind is like an automatic “Occam’s Razor” so I have a hard time backfilling everything to communicate it to other people, I’m trying to improve on that through studying Objectivist Epistemology
When I do this in my personal or business life people sometimes ask “how did you know that?” and honestly I was just trying the first thing that my brain produced. Internally I’m using concepts that I’ve built up over a lifetime and so I go from point A to point Z without thinking about it. I can’t necessarily draw out the entire conceptual hierarchy that went into coming up with that answer, but I know that it exists.
“I don’t know” (how I know) is obviously not the correct thing to say here. What is?
But you do know how you know, you just described it. You know a lot of stuff and your mind works really fast. What’s the problem with that? You didn’t consciously go through every single step from point A to point Z on this particular occasion, but that’s because you have done all the separate steps in the past and no longer need to spell it all out in every single separate situation.
Of course sometimes it may not work out so well, and then you may have to consciously go through each step to see where you’ve improperly integrated some fact or made some unwarranted assumption. You say you can’t do that, but I’m sure that if you sat down and tried, you’d find that you can.
But you do know how you know, you just described it. You know a lot of stuff and your mind works really fast. What’s the problem with that? You didn’t consciously go through every single step from point A to point Z on this particular occasion, but that’s because you have done all the separate steps in the past and no longer need to spell it all out in every single separate situation.
Of course sometimes it may not work out so well, and then you may have to consciously go through each step to see where you’ve improperly integrated some fact or made some unwarranted assumption. You say you can’t do that, but I’m sure that if you sat down and tried, you’d find that you can.
It’s not that I can’t identify certain points or certain assumptions that I need to change, it’s that I can’t spell out exactly every step in the process. So if I were to try to explain to someone exactly how I came to a conclusion I could tell them the key points in between but not necessarily all of the points.
If I somehow can’t recall any intermediary points, then I don’t put any stock in my “hunch.” However, I end up being right most of the time after further investigation. So there must have been a good bit of complex concept use going on, I just am not very good at identifying it.
It’s not that I can’t identify certain points or certain assumptions that I need to change, it’s that I can’t spell out exactly every step in the process. So if I were to try to explain to someone exactly how I came to a conclusion I could tell them the key points in between but not necessarily all of the points.
Practice explaining things. But I think it depends on what it is you are explaining. I’d like to know what field you’re talking about in particular. Anyway, what you’re talking about is described in the book Blink. Through extensive experience, practice and knowledge, you can eventually automatize your thinking process enough to make complex evaluations that are correct and valid in an instant. Your mind really does work that fast. Explaining your thinking process to other people is a whole different story. As bluey said, the mind works very fast. Inability to explain does not mean you’re relying on feelings. It might just mean that you didn’t hold each concept in your mind in the thinking process long enough to warrant “remembering”. There is much more important information to be actively keeping track of. This is the power of abstraction.
So if I were to try to explain to someone exactly how I came to a conclusion I could tell them the key points in between but not necessarily all of the points.
The advice to practice explaining things is good. If it’s practical, I would work with someone who knows less – who needs to learn what you’ve learned. Try to get them to solve the problem and (this is important) solve it in real time in front of you. Pay attention to their reasoning: they may say something that strikes you are bizarre, because they are making some bad assumption or they are engaging in a logical fallacy. This will tell you something about the thought processes that you have made automatic.
“Hunches” and “gut feelings” are just poor ways of describing how our subconscious makes connections. Our brain is, after all, a pattern recognition computer.