Thomas Jefferson

I consider The Declaration of Independence to be one of the greatest documents ever written. It is a beacon of freedom which defines individual rights and government’s purpose. It is so beautifully written and I consider its author to be an enlightened genius and personal hero.

Yet, today in the halls of academia (not saying much I know) he is considered by many a villain whose philosophic genius must be discounted because of his slaveholding and hypocrisy. (I was reminded of this in another thread where someone says “all slaveholders are evil” – a statement which I must agree with).

I defend him by pointing out that it is his writings which eventually helped end slavery (how ironic). Still, these are stinging rebukes.

Others withhold judgement on the basis of historic time and context which sometimes rings hollow to me since from his writings he clearly knew slavery to be immoral.

How do you reconcile his actions with his thoughts?

A more accurate statment would be: All slaveholding is evil, and all slaveholders are commiting an evil act. Many great men have committed evil acts, and, though they are not to be excused from their evils, they may remain great men.

I heard a quote somewhere that I believe was attributed to Jefferson. Maintaining the institution of slavery, he said, was “like holding a wolf by the ears: you don’t like it, but you don’t dare let go.”

Here is an article written by Jefferson on slavery:

http://odur.let.rug.nl/~usa/P/tj3/writings/slavery.htm

I share your love for the Declaration of Independence.

It must be remembered that in Jefferson’s time slavery was not merely allowed, it was enforced by law. Jefferson repeatedly attempted to free his slaves, but the state of Virginia’s constitution forbade the existence of “free negroes” within its borders and the surrounding states had restrictions against the importation of “free negroes”. Jefferson tried – unsuccessfully – to get the state constitution changed.

In addition, the draft of the Declaration of Independence that Jefferson submitted to Congress included what John Adams called, “the vehement philippic against negroe slavery”. It is the last of Jefferson’s charges against the king:

“He has waged cruel war against human nature itself, violating its most sacred rights of life and liberty in persons of distant people who never offended him, captivating and carrying them into slavery in another hemisphere, or to incur miserable death in their transportation thither. This piratical warfare, the opprobrium of infidel powers, is the warfare of the Christian king of Great Britain. Determined to keep open a market where MEN should be bought and sold, he has prostituted his negative for suppressing every legislative attempt to prohibit or to restrain this execrable commerce; and that this assemblage of horrors might want no fact of distinguished die, he is now exciting these very people to rise in arms among us, and to purchase that liberty of which he deprived them, by murdering the people upon whom he also obtruded them; thus paying off former crimes committed against the liberties of one people, with crimes which he urges them to commit against the lives of another.” (All emphasis is Jefferson’s.)

Only Jefferson could have written something so eloquent, moving and DAMNING. Unfortunately, Congress omitted this passage from the final document.

I have always believed that had Jefferson participated in the Constitutional Convention, American History would be significantly different.

Thomas Jefferson is by far the greatest American born phillosopher of all time and he realized that it was the philosopher that determined the destiny of nations not politicians or kings.

There is no doubt that Jefferson was racist. But this is missing the point. Accusing Jefferson for failing to see the flaw of racism is like accusing Newton of failing to grasp relativity: it reverses the hierarchy of knowledge. Jefferson should be admired as a hero of freedom because the laid the groundwork that provided his successors the inspiration to reject slavery and racism.

The quality of one’s character does not in and of itself affect the quality of his work.

The quality of one’s character does not in and of itself affect the quality of his work.

Except in the quality which directly pertains to that work…

You normally wouldn’t hire a pedophile to babysit your kids

I did not know that Jefferson was a racist. I googled him, and found some quotes that are defenitely racist.

That’s horrible.

However, this cannot change your perception of the Declaration of Independence. Your view of it depends on its content, not its author.

As to “all slaveholders are evil”… What if by officially owning a slave, but treating him as a sovereign being, you would be saving him from real slavery somewhere else? I don’t mean this as an implication on this particular case, but it sounds like a dogmatic, context-dropping rule. The official fact of “owning” a slave on paper does not encapsulate the real relationship in all cases.

In forming an opinion on a particular individual, you must take into account all aspects of his life, character, and actions. An opinion doesn’t have to be black or white, because many people are not black or white.

I think in this particular case more study is required (at least for me), before forming a verdict.

WHY was he racist?

Did he just adopt the idea uncritically from his environment, or was he an active advocate?

Did he believe white supremacy to be a scientific fact, and if so - what did he offer as evidence (were the evidence even remotely plausible, given his context)?

Did he ever change his mind?

Was he ever confronted on this subject, and how did he react?

How did he treat his slaves, and other black people?

How did he react to evidence contradicting his racist theories?

I think if you give me accurate answers on all these questions, I can form a more accurate opinion. On the meantime I can remind you that some men are geniuses in one area while completely irrational or ignorant in another. If this is the case, as it seems, we are dealing with two contradicting parts of a personality. Which means Thomas Jefferson the great hero never fully existed, but was only suggested by the real Thomas Jefferson.

erandror

Did you have a chance to read my post earlier in this thread? It addresses some of the questions you raise.

erandror

Did you have a chance to read my post earlier in this thread? It addresses some of the questions you raise.

Hmmm. Nope. Sorry.

I’ll check it out now.

Well, now that I have - I think I need more than the answers you gave. You treated mostly the subject of slavery, while I’m more concerened with Jefferson’s purported racism.

I think racism is a very ignorant notion, and I find it hard to believe that in Jefferson’s time he was not be exposed to contradicting facts or ideas.

Condemning Jefferson for having slaves is like condemning the Wright brothers for not inventing the space shuttle.

One step at a time, surely…

It is because of the Jeffersons of the world that many of their descendants arenot racist.

I did not know that Jefferson was a racist. I googled him, and found some quotes that are defenitely racist.

That’s horrible.

Keep in mind that virtually everyone in the civilized world prior to the 19th century held views that we would today call racist. There are reasons for this. Before that time, the entirety of their contact with people of other races suggested that they were all ignorant, barbaric aboriginals. It was a mistake to generalize on the basis of the inessential characteristic of race and say that all dark-skinned peoples are necessarily irrational, but that is the most obvious difference they could see at the time and it is no surprise that people several hundred years ago would make that kind of error. Jefferson and others during his time were the ones who began identifying this as an error and provided the philosophical basis for the eventual abolition of slavery (and “racism” for that matter).

To put it briefly: The problems of slavery and racism were not created by Jefferson; rather, he, and those like him (from like-minded contemporaries of his all the way up through Lincoln), inherited and helped solve them.

Thank you Ash Ryan for adding context to history.

Thank you Ash Ryan for adding context to history.

I agree. Excellent post Ash. I hate when Jefferson is condemned as a racist. To me a proper understanding of any historical era or figure must take into account the context of knowledge available to that era or person. Jefferson lived during a time where the state of biological and anthropological knowledge was at its infancy. Most of the founders thought that Africans or “dark skinned” people were not anthropologically connected to the human race. This was wrong and led to terrible consequences but their context must be observed. And to repeat what has been said before, it was because of the advances that the Founders made in the field of political theory and applied government that we live in a culture where chattel slavery is now unthinkable.

I say chattel slavery and not total slavery because unfortunately voices for the return of the draft are resurfacing (from both the left and the right) and the draft is nothing more than sacrificial slavery.

Condemning Jefferson for having slaves is like condemning the Wright brothers for not inventing the space shuttle.

No, it is not. The difference is that Jefferson, of his own free will, denied the rights of his slaves. The Wright Brothers constructed something, they did not willfuly deny or abrogate rights of other people.

Keep in mind that virtually everyone in the civilized world prior to the 19th century held views that we would today call racist. There are reasons for this. Before that time, the entirety of their contact with people of other races suggested that they were all ignorant, barbaric aboriginals. It was a mistake to generalize on the basis of the inessential characteristic of race and say that all dark-skinned peoples are necessarily irrational, but that is the most obvious difference they could see at the time and it is no surprise that people several hundred years ago would make that kind of error. Jefferson and others during his time were the ones who began identifying this as an error and provided the philosophical basis for the eventual abolition of slavery (and “racism” for that matter).

To put it briefly: The problems of slavery and racism were not created by Jefferson; rather, he, and those like him (from like-minded contemporaries of his all the way up through Lincoln), inherited and helped solve them.

If Jefferson cannot be blaimed for slavery just because during his era, many of his peers held racist views, then Lenin cannot be blamed for the wrongs he did because many of his peers held those views and altruists cannot be blamed for the views they hold because most of the people consider altruism as right.

A great man does not bow down to the majority.

George Washington freed his slaves. Why couldn’t have Jefferson?

Jefferson advocated abolishing slavery, yet didn’t free his own slaves. This can be nothing other than hypocrisy. Jefferson might have written great and rational things, but he was not practicing what he preached.

Jefferson advocated abolishing slavery, yet didn’t free his own slaves. This can be nothing other than hypocrisy. Jefferson might have written great and rational things, but he was not practicing what he preached.

Jefferson was from the South. Freeing his slaves meant a WORSE life for the slaves, and possible capture and enslavement by somebody much, much crueler than Jefferson. Many slaves did not want to be ‘free’ because they enjoyed a very healthy, free life with their owners.

This can be nothing other than hypocrisy

Be careful of jumping in and attacking people like this. Especially when you have very little facts, and are around people (myself) who highly admire Jefferson.

I agree with Tommy. Opposing slavery and racism in Jefferson’s day was not like inventing relativity or the Space Shuttle. Many people at the time recognized that blacks were just intelligent and rational as whites and deserved to be treated as equals. The facts were freely available to everyone.

Jefferson was from the South.  Freeing his slaves meant a WORSE life for the slaves, and possible capture and enslavement by somebody much, much crueler than Jefferson.  Many slaves did not want to be ‘free’ because they enjoyed a very healthy, free life with their owners.

To add to this, I was told in my U.S. History class that laws against freeing slaves were, in fact, put in effect as a measure of protection for slaves. Contrary to popular impression, slaveowners had some degree of responsiblity for the welfare of their slaves. These laws prevented a slaveowner from “freeing” slaves who had become undesireable due to old age, bad health, or injury and thus absolving himself of any responsibility for their welfare.