Thomas Jefferson

Jefferson was from the South.  Freeing his slaves meant a WORSE life for the slaves, and possible capture and enslavement by somebody much, much crueler than Jefferson.  Many slaves did not want to be ‘free’ because they enjoyed a very healthy, free life with their owners.

Be careful of jumping in and attacking people like this.  Especially when you have very little facts, and are around people (myself) who highly admire Jefferson.

The good things that Jefferson did, which are all part of American lore, should be greatly admired.

However, one need only look to Jefferson’s “Note on Virginia” to see him cobble a feeble defense of the slavery together. One must also remember that Jefferson often contradicted himself on many issues of which slavery is probably the most blatant.

To the above quotes, there was a sizable free black population in the South at the time the country was founded and until 1830 there were more anti-slavery and abolitionist groups in the South than in the North. To say that many blacks did not want to be free because they enjoyed a “health, free life with their owners,” is an absurdist claim in the extreme. First of all, as a slave one is never “free” in any sense of the word. Secondly, any pleasurable experience one got while in slavery depended wholly upon who owned you. One might make out pretty well under George Washington (if you know anything about how Washington handled his slaves this will make more sense, he was lenient to the point of ruining the fortunes of Mt. Vernon) but under other owners ones experience may have been entirely different, with frequent beatings for not meeting the cotton quota or some other infraction. The problem with being free for black people was racism and the fact that most were unskilled initially and had to take the worst jobs. But even in the early 1800’s many free blacks in the south were artisans of various kinds in many Southern cities. One should also veer away from the notion that someone didn’t want to be free, because 1) it was a favorite argument of pro-slavery southerners against moves to limit or abolish slavery and 2) it takes the position that since one has been enslaved for a period of time and thus doesn’t know freedom, that they no longer have any right to it. It is never acceptable to own other people, and their immediate emancipation, no matter how long they were owned is the only proper recourse.

On a sidenote, Washington’s estate provided pensions to all the older slaves that were freed because he understood that they had been raised as slaves and might not adjust very well to freedom, which makes different demands upon a person. I believe the last pension payment occurred in the early 1830s.

Jefferson was from the South. Freeing his slaves meant a WORSE life for the slaves, and possible capture and enslavement by somebody much, much crueler than Jefferson. Many slaves did not want to be ‘free’ because they enjoyed a very healthy, free life with their owners.

Jefferson had no right to decide what was good or bad for his slaves and then force them to act the way HE wanted them to act.

Giving Jefferson the freedom to decide other peoples’ fate is no different than giving a dictator the freedom to decide what the people should do.

Be careful of jumping in and attacking people like this. Especially when you have very little facts, and are around people (myself) who highly admire Jefferson.

I have not made any false claims about Jefferson.

If we cannot condemn Jefferson for his handling of slavery, then we have no right to admire him for his achievements. I am not denying that Jefferson didn’t accomplish anything. What he achieved very few can achieve. But IMO, his dark side almost completely overshadows his bright side.

The question here is not political - who had the right to do what, and why. The question here is moral - who treated men around him in what fashion, and how was it a reflection of his own moral values.

Thus, politically Jefferson had no right to maintain his slaves. But morally, a very good case can be made that the choice he made was less unhealthy than some others. I’m not willing to go and completely say he was right not to free the slaves, but I at least will deny that his slave ownership was an easy open-and-shut case of hypocrisy and immorality.

After all, what do we mean by slavery? Legally that definition is having a right to initiate force upon another person. However, that’s not what we really think about when we think of slaves. We think of whips, a lot of wanton pain, endless toil without respite for men, unwanted sexual advances and rape for women.

Which of these two aspects of slavery is more immoral for a person? To hold a ‘deed’ to another man but yet pay him well and treat him with utmost respect, or unjustly beat a man into submission while admitting his sovereignty and rights?

Thus, not all slave owners are created equal. Not all slave societies are equally bad.

Thomas Jefferson treated his slaves with utmost deference, fully as other human beings on par with him. The deed he held on them gave him legal permission to initiate force upon them. Had he taken advantage of this permission, one could speak of his immorality. But he knew he wouldn’t beat and curse his men, and rape his women, and they knew they could expect a good salary and a respectful treatment. A stupid paper with a stupid stamp on it is a nuissance, just a tiny wrinkle on what overall is a very moral existence, a behavior we all ought to aspire to, and that few of us here are anywhere near.

As JRoberts said, don’t be so quick to condemn great men, especially by following the lead of modern historians.

The question here is not political - who had the right to do what, and why. The question here is moral - who treated men around him in what fashion, and how was it a reflection of his own moral values.

Thus, politically Jefferson had no right to maintain his slaves. But morally, a very good case can be made that the choice he made was less unhealthy than some others. I’m not willing to go and completely say he was right not to free the slaves, but I at least will deny that his slave ownership was an easy open-and-shut case of hypocrisy and immorality.

After all, what do we mean by slavery? Legally that definition is having a right to initiate force upon another person. However, that’s not what we really think about when we think of slaves. We think of whips, a lot of wanton pain, endless toil without respite for men, unwanted sexual advances and rape for women.

Which of these two aspects of slavery is more immoral for a person? To hold a ‘deed’ to another man but yet pay him well and treat him with utmost respect, or unjustly beat a man into submission while admitting his sovereignty and rights?

Thus, not all slave owners are created equal. Not all slave societies are equally bad.

Thomas Jefferson treated his slaves with utmost deference, fully as other human beings on par with him. The deed he held on them gave him legal permission to initiate force upon them. Had he taken advantage of this permission, one could speak of his immorality. But he knew he wouldn’t beat and curse his men, and rape his women, and they knew they could expect a good salary and a respectful treatment. A stupid paper with a stupid stamp on it is a nuissance, just a tiny wrinkle on what overall is a very moral existence, a behavior we all ought to aspire to, and that few of us here are anywhere near.

As JRoberts said, don’t be so quick to condemn great men, especially by following the lead of modern historians.

It is precisely morally where Jefferson was extremely wrong and immoral in not freeing his slaves.

Were Jefferson’s slaves allowed to do what they wanted, go where they wanted and work on whatever they wanted without any restrictions? If yes, then Jefferson had implicitly freed his slaves.

But they were NOT allowed this.

I point you to this thread where there was some discussion of Jefferson and Slavery.

thread

Thomas Jefferson treated his slaves with utmost deference, fully as other human beings on par with him. The deed he held on them gave him legal permission to initiate force upon them. Had he taken advantage of this permission, one could speak of his immorality. But he knew he wouldn’t beat and curse his men, and rape his women, and they knew they could expect a good salary and a respectful treatment. A stupid paper with a stupid stamp on it is a nuissance, just a tiny wrinkle on what overall is a very moral existence, a behavior we all ought to aspire to, and that few of us here are anywhere near.

As JRoberts said, don’t be so quick to condemn great men, especially by following the lead of modern historians.

He did not treat or think of his slaves as full human beings on par with himself, this is an absurdity. Read Jefferson’s own writings on this subject, yes he thought Britain introducing African slavery was immoral and wrong, but he also considered the Africans themselves to be an inferior sort of people. And of course he took advantage of his ability to initiate force on his slaves, though I don’t know if he did so personally, I very much doubt that. But slavery, by its very nature, requires the use of force, and the continual threat of force to stay effective. Slaves had to be beaten for slacking off, force is the only incentive a slave has to work at all. No slave at Monticello could walk up to Jefferson and announce he was going to leave to head north and get an industrial job, if he did or tried to do such a thing he would be caught and most likely be beaten very harshly.

I don’t think anyone on this thread is saying that everything positive Jefferson did is negated by his holding of slaves or his overtly racist comments about slaves, but it does no one any good at all to try to “pretty up” the reality of slavery at Monticello by making it appear to be some sort of utopia when it wasn’t and could not be. Plus trying to make Jefferson sound like the ideal slave-holder is wrong when it is clear, historically, that Washington did more to help and free his slaves than Jefferson ever did for his own. Thomas Jefferson was a great man, but he was a slaveholder who did not end up freeing his slaves and actually laid the foundations for the pro-slavery arguments the south would use right up to the Civil War, and then afterwards to rationalize segregationist laws. To not deal with this simple fact of history is a terrible evasion of reality.

First of all Jefferson was a slave himself, as were all colonialists to the King, the only diffence was one of degree. We are slaves today because we pay taxes. And the industrialists have it worse than us.

I doubt, although I don’t know for sure, but the best and most intelligent slave was no where near to the intelligence of Jefferson. I am so glad that Jefferson was born white! And most of his slaves were probably no where near as intelligent as his friends. In a culture where the history of man recognizes the phenomenon of slaves, forget about them being black, it is unfair to ask Jefferson to sacrifice his life, which was America, to be “stubborn” about the slave question. I’m sure Jefferson observed that it seemed that blacks were a different and inferior species: that was his observation.

Who was the first black genius in America?

Jefferson was a genius.

How could you ever fu#4’n forget that without the Declaration of Independence, blacks would never be free. Yes, yes, Europe abolished slavery before America. But without America’s fight, the Europeans would have never FREED THEMSELVES!

Come on–if you live in America–please show respect to the man responsible for making possible you current freedom. Without Jefferson Canada would have never had the courage 100 years later, to ASK for their self-government. It was not until 1982, when Canada became it’s own country. Unfortunately, Canada is still a constitutional dictatorship.

Take care,

Americo.

Just fyi I grew up in Canada and for all practical purposes the US is not any freer a country than Canada. Maybe on paper Americans have more rights than Canadians, but not in practice. That was rather a shock to me when I moved here.

And Canada’s becoming self-governing was more of a formailty than anything else; they had been making their decisions themselves since 1867. The head of state is still the Queen, but she has no actual power over the country.

Segration laws:

In a free society, If I own some property, I have the absolute right to ban any man for what ever reason from my property. If I don’t like THE HAT he is wearing then he will be booted off my property. I will put a sign out of courtesy, of course.

Yes, it would be absurd to ban a competent black man from my property because he could be a valuable trade partner. But I have a right to be as bigoted as I want to be.

The segregation laws were about public property but there shouldn’t be public property. The profit motive will end slavery when the demand market has shown the value of slaves, hispanics, AND BUSINESS MEN.

Jefferson may have supported segregation laws but so do I. Property rights is inalienable.

Let’s say a founding father wanted to INTEGRATE blacks into society. If they are of no profitable use then what do I owe them, if I did not make them slaves? I probably inherited them.

Maybe keeping them is wrong but what do I do with them then? I’ll free them. What will happen to them if I do? That is not the justification for slavery. But it is the practical reality that liberty-minded liberators had to deal with.

The attacks on Jefferson are unfair. For those who attack Jefferson I would like to know what your understanding is of the issue of: Errors of Knowledge versus breaches of morality. Tell me, please.

Take care,

Americo.

Godless Capitalist:

Have you read our Charter of Rights and Freedoms?

The only way that Canada can avoid a dicatorship is through constitutional reform. That’s true, right?

So America is the only country in the world, that has a constitution that BY PAPER protects individual rights.

Local government has much to do with the freedom of Canadians. However, since we want to fund every social program possible, we take away from the protectors of individual rights, and there are not enough cops on the streets.

Same in American, eh? Of course, because they are running away from the practice of the founding fathers.

No?

Take care,

Jose.

It is precisely morally where Jefferson was extremely wrong and immoral in not freeing his slaves.

Were Jefferson’s slaves allowed to do what they wanted, go where they wanted and work on whatever they wanted without any restrictions? If yes, then Jefferson had implicitly freed his slaves.

But they were NOT allowed this.

For your own sake, I would advise that you re-read your post and note the cynical tone. You are more intent on making Jefferson look evil than you are on learning the truth.

Jefferson, as were the other Founding Fathers, were men of principles, products of the enlightenment of the 18th century. Men who eschewed medievil religious fanaticism, who sought to seperate religion and state, and they are being compared to the likes of evil men like Lenin, Stalin, and other dictators? Absurd and ridiculous! They fashioned a document and an idea of limited government which was to be subservient to the people, an enlightened Bill of Rights, and promoted the correct idea of the soveirgnty of the individual. Those who denigrate Jefferson and his achievements, along with those of any of the Founding Fathers are not lovers of liberty, nor are they true Americans. Revisionism, aided by the forces of big Lincolnesque government, government indoctrination centers (public schools) have spun history to the point were the Founding Fathers have been denigrated and pilloried. No wonder our society or government no longer has any respect for our BoR, private property, small minarchist government, or individual achievement and initiative.

I disagree that Jefferson was racist – at least to the extent that has been implied here.

Many of his observations about negro slaves in his Notes on Virginia, were entirely reasonable observations based on the available evidence. Jefferson even qualifies his observations with acknowledgement about the dangers of overgeneralization (my term here – I haven’t time to quote the original), and announces his final conclusions with regret, becasue he is worried that Negroes (alleged) deficiencies in some areas would weaken the case against granting them full human rights.

Later in his life, Jefferson writes to a European aquaintance who has sent him writings from a European black astronomer (don’t remember the name… again, I dont’ have the source right in front of me) that he is happy to learn that the qualities he attributed to negroes were a matter of their circumstances in America rather than intrinsic qualities of their “race” (my scare quotes – I don’t believe the concept “race” is valid).

To me, this sounds like a method of evaluation antithetical to racism (or, as close as any had come at that time).

I doubt, although I don’t know for sure, but the best and most intelligent slave was no where near to the intelligence of Jefferson.  I am so glad that Jefferson was born white!  And most of his slaves were probably no where near as intelligent as his friends.  In a culture where the history of man recognizes the phenomenon of slaves, forget about them being black, it is unfair to ask Jefferson to sacrifice his life, which was America, to be “stubborn” about the slave question.  I’m sure Jefferson observed that it seemed that blacks were a different and inferior species: that was his observation. 

Who was the first black genius in America?

Jefferson was a genius.

You might want to read the story of Benjamin Banneker, which doesn’t make Jefferson look too good.

Altogether though, I think Jefferson’s strengths far, far outweighed his flaws. But, I’m probably more a fan of (John) Adams than of Jefferson anyway.

It is interesting to note that Jefferson considered blacks mentally and physically inferior. Today, the latter part of his judgment is widely regarded as erroneous but the former still has some “validity” in many minds. The historical joke will be on those who do not realize that the former, too, is invalid.

Godless Capitalist:

Have you read our Charter of Rights and Freedoms?

The only way that Canada can avoid a dicatorship is through constitutional reform.  That’s true, right?

So America is the only country in the world, that has a constitution that BY PAPER protects individual rights.

Local government has much to do with the freedom of Canadians.  However, since we want to fund every social program possible, we take away from the protectors of individual rights, and there are not enough cops on the streets.

Same in American, eh? Of course, because they are running away from the practice of the founding fathers.

No?

Take care,

Jose.

You are in Canada? Yes I’ve read the Charter. Yes on paper the US protects individual rights and other countries do not (or at least not as absolutes). The problem is that the US courts do not actually follow the Constitution. A dictatorship is just as possible here as in Canada.

Anyway, I am not really sure what you are getting at …

To add to this, I was told in my U.S. History class that laws against freeing slaves were, in fact, put in effect as a measure of protection for slaves.  Contrary to popular impression, slaveowners had some degree of responsiblity for the welfare of their slaves.  These laws prevented a slaveowner from “freeing” slaves who had become undesireable due to old age, bad health, or injury and thus absolving himself of any responsibility for their welfare.

I’m a little late but…

This is a good point, I taught an Afro-American studies class in high school, and a point a lot of kids didn’t agree with (though it was true) was that a lot of slaves DID NOT WANT TO LEAVE their masters. Andrew Johnson handled reconstruction poorly, in that it heightened tensions between races. In the 1860s Gen. NB Forrest creates the Klan and the Freedmen are afraid of what they might find off the plantation. So many stayed.

Lincoln knew that reconstruction would cause so much tension that he actually held negotiations w/a S. American diplomat to create a state in S. America for freed slaves.

Although I don’t like the fact that he owned slaves, in Jefferson’s defense..He had to edit the slave clause he, Franklin(the abolitionist), and Adams put in the D of I to get the vote past Rutledge and S. Carolina (1776 Slaaaaves, Molasses, and Rummm…). Also the contitutional convention (Jefferson was not present, he was in france) took slavery as a serious issue, and banned the trans-atlantic slave trade beginning in 1801. Although he may have had some biggoted sentiments, he didn’t take the issue lightly.

I do have a question though…

Would having a slave to protect him from other more brutal slave owners be pragmatism? An obvious principle is being violated…or is it? Are all rights equal, or should some superceed others (in this case life superceeds freedom)?

I agree with Tommy also in his view that Jefferson can be blamed for his actions. I don’t like the idea that slavery was a vice of the times, not of the man. There were people who opposed slavery and were not racist during Jefferson’s time. Abolition was a debate during Jefferson’s lifetime. I also find it hard to believe that one could live in close proximity to slaves and be incapable of identifying them as humans.

I admire Jefferson very much, but I think it is completely proper to be able to admire someone yet condemn some of his actions. The thing is, slavery really isn’t an important part of the reasons we admire Jefferson. It is a contradiction in his ethics, but as with Aristotle, the mistakes don’t invalidate the achievements. I definitely don’t think that it is worth the time educators spend on teaching kids about Jefferson owning slaves.

I look at Jefferson the same way I look at Ayn Rand; I acknowledge that their greatness, but I also acknowledge that they were humans who made mistakes. Diefying Ayn Rand would be a contradiction of Objectivism. Jefferson wasn’t perfect, but there was so many great things about that wonderful man that they overshadow any shortcomings he had.

the problem that arises and makes people reluctant to accept that is the fact that other people tend to use a person’s shortcomings in an Ad Hominem attack in an effort to discredit a philosophy they couldn’t discredit any other way.

oh by the way, I’m pretty sure that Jefferson was bound by his state’s law that he couldn’t arbitrarily release slaves. He found a loophole in his laws that if he didn’t name a successor to his slaves, they became freemen.

Many (but not all) of those discussing this topic appear to have spent insufficient time studying the FACTS about Thomas Jefferson. At the very least, get “The Life and Selected Writings of Thomas Jefferson” in Random House’s Modern Library series (edited by Adrienne Koch and William Peden), and READ Jefferson’s own words. If you’re close to a large library, try looking through the many volumes of Jefferson’s letters, as well.

I believe it’s in Jefferson’s Autobiography that he states that his FIRST act in public life, his FIRST week in the House of Burgesses, was to persuade a more senior member to introduce a bill, allowing masters to free their slaves. According to Jefferson, that provoked such a storm of criticism that the senior member almost lost his seat in the legislature.

Also, in that same work, read Jefferson’s ORIGINAL draft of the Declaration of Independence, in which he condemns the slave trade as “cruel warfare against human nature.”

SEARCH through Jefferson’s writings, including his letters. There are many surprises. At least one surprise is a nasty one. There exists a passage in which Jefferson says he believes that the apparent inferiority of black people is not due merely to their status as slaves, but to inherent inferiority. HOWEVER, there are many more PLEASANT surprises in his writings, as well. In particular, there is a later passage in which he reconsiders the same issue, and states a diametrically opposite conclusion, saying there is NO proof that black people are inferior. He goes on to say (I’m paraphrasing, I don’t have this in front of me): even if it were true they were inferior in intelligence (which, he insists, he does NOT admit), that would in no way imply that they were in any way inferior in rights–after all, Isaac Newton was more intelligent than others but that didn’t give him any extra rights!

Unfortunately I cannot provide an exact source of that quote. I believe it was in one of Jefferson’s letters, as quoted in a book from about 10 years ago vindicating the Founding Fathers. The book was sold, at the time, by Second Renaissance Books. (Sorry I can’t be more precise than that, at the moment. I will try to find the book in their old catalogs.) The book offered many interesting details about exactly when various states banned slavery, and which states during which years allowed black people to vote.

George Washington, as you should know, was a man whose library contained more works on hunting and farming than philosophy; he was not as intellectually inclined as, say, Thomas Jefferson. Yet I have read an account saying that even Washington FIRST ATTEMPTED TO FREE HIS SLAVES IN 1770–fully 6 years before the Declaration of Independence! (Again, I do not have an exact source for this. I read it several years ago in “Cricket,” the children’s magazine.)

I dearly wish that Jefferson had been a fiery, crusading abolitionist, taking a public stand at every opportunity to denounce slavery, in spite of the harm such an unpopular stand would have done him politically and economically. He was not. But neither was he the hypocrite that some moral pygmies in academia and the media have slandered him as. WHO, in the 1700s, did MORE than he to lay the foundation for the eventual abolition of slavery?

* * *

On this same general subject, here’s an article I hope you have read:

“The Anti-Jeffersonian Revolution: Academic Irrationalism and the Sally Hemings Controversy,” by J. Patrick Mullins ( The Intellectual Activist, July 2002)

Hello Bill.

I agree with you. Please see my post in this thread. It is post number 5.

Unfortunately I cannot provide an exact source of that quote.  I believe it was in one of Jefferson’s letters, as quoted in a book from about 10 years ago vindicating the Founding Fathers.  The book was sold, at the time, by Second Renaissance Books.

Here is the book I referred to: “Vindicating the Founders: Race, Sex, Class, and Justice in the Origins of America,” by Thomas G. West (Rowman & Littlefield, 1997). It’s still in print; many new and used copies are available at Amazon, at AddAll.com/Used, etc. I’ve just ordered a copy.

And here’s a list of relevant passages I found, in “The Life and Selected Writings of Thomas Jefferson”:

p. xxiii in 1783, at the Confederation Congress, Jefferson attempted to have slavery excluded from the Northwestern Territory

p. xliii Jefferson’s unwillingness to overwork his slaves was a drain on his pocketbook

p. 5 (Autobiography) in 1769, Jefferson’s first act in the House of Burgesses was an unsuccessful bill allowing owners to free their slaves (also p. xviii and pp. 641-642, letter to Edward Coles, Aug. 25, 1814)

Pp. 21, 25 (Autobiography) passage in the original draft of the Declaration of Independence, denouncing slavery as “cruel war against human nature itself, violating its most sacred rights of life and liberty”

p. 40 (Autobiography) in 1778 Jefferson got a bill passed banning the importation of slaves into Virginia

p. 51 (Autogiography) when the laws of Virginia were revised, Jefferson hoped that a call for gradual emancipation would be included; however, there was too much opposition. Jefferson also expresses the opinion that the two races would not be able to live together under the same government, and favored transportation to Africa

p. 255 (Notes on Virginia, Query XIV) more details on the proposed emancipation

pp. 258-262 (Notes on Virginia, Query XIV) Jefferson compares the situation of black slaves with that of slaves in ancient Rome; and considers whether black people are inferior by nature. In one sentence he thinks it’s pretty much proved; however, in three later sentences he says that opinion is a “conjecture,” must be “hazarded with great diffidence,” and ends by saying it’s “a suspicion only.”

p. 278 (Notes on Virginia, Query XVIII) Jefferson observes that slavery seriously degrades the moral character of the slave-owners

p. 304 (A Summary View of the Rights of British America, 1774) Jefferson attacks the king of England for hampering efforts to outlaw the slave trade; he says “the rights of human nature” are “deeply wounded by this infamous practice.”

pp. 313-314 (Report of Government for the Western Territory, 1784) Jefferson proposes that “there shall be neither slavery nor involuntary servitude in any of the said states”

These are the results of only a quick check; there may be other passages I’ve missed. I wish I had a good, thorough biography of Jefferson at hand (or a nearby library with his complete works), but I don’t. Hopefully some of you will be INSPIRED to carry on the search!

* * *

Quoting “A is A”

“Hello Bill. I agree with you. Please see my post in this thread. It is post number 5.”

Thanks!