Mark,
I’m not so sure I agree with this move since the question asked was clearly of an ethical nature.
<FC: This thread isn’t about slavery per se, in an abstract and absolute sens, but about Thomas Jefferson and the conditions that existed at a specific point in history when he lived (and also the history that led up to the existence of the society he lived in). Basically, yes it is an ethical question, but an applied ethical question, in this case applied to a specific point in history. In this discussion, knowing about history of Jefferson’s times is as important as knowing about the nature of slavery. If you want to start a thread on slavery as such in the Ethics forum, you’re more than welcome to. I may even reproduce there some of my posts here.>
bbrown,
Neither being a racist, in context, nor being a slaveowner, in context, is necessarily a vice. For example, yes, Jefferson may have expressed belief that the people of African race were somehow innately inferior. But in the context of his time, can you blame him? Let’s be brutally honest here and leave political correctness at the door. Only after establishment of America and other free European societies did the African people bloom intellectually into their own; when they were found by the early merchants, they were some of the most primitive people anywhere on Earth, with no book, song, building, government, anything at all to their credit. As these merchants found little to appreciate in the life of the coastal tribes, they continued exploring the continent, and kept looking for exceptions to this rule, but never found it. Every new tribe they encountered, every new sub-nationality, kept reinforcing their preliminary opinion. And, given the fact that European science at that point wasn’t advanced enough to dispel misconceptions about race and ethnicity, this dismal state of mind that the Europeans encountered in Africa was limited to people all of whom shared a very similar skin tone and facial features, why were the Europeans wrong in concluding that these were some kind of less developed humans?
Now, obviously Jefferson was wrong in his understanding, and there’s nothing biologically inferior in any race of human beings, African or otherwise, but if we try to condemn him out of context, and accuse him of prejudice and of ignoring scientific knowledge he couldn’t have possessed, we convict ourselves, not him. The truth of the matter is that he was right within the context of his knowledge and the state of science at the time; if there are African Americans who read this and get offended, as I assume they will be, I hope they realize that if they were back in that time period, and in Jefferson’s shoes, they would have been right to think what he did about the races, and wrong to think otherwise. In the context of that time, a claim that all races are biologically equivalent would have been arbitrary, at best.
Now, concerning the issue of being a slaveowner. Holding a deed to another person granted by the government, having a paper that says you may hit another man at your convenience, and force him to do your bidding, is not in itself anything bad. Following up on that paper is what is bad and wrong, and that is the only thing to condemn, in the private sphere (as opposed to condemning the government for existence of such papers in the public sphere).
There seems to be a misconception going around that somehow owning these slave deeds makes someone an evil and criminal man. Papers are meaningless in issues of morality, the only thing that counts is whether a man wants to initiate force against someone else, or doesn’t. And there have been plenty of men, even today, who initiate force at will - how are they different from slaveowners who beat their slaves? They aren’t! A presence or absense of some little paper makes no difference at all about whether one is moral or not.
Putting aside the evaluation of the government which allowed these offenses (old South) or criminalizes them (US government today), the only thing important in evaluating a person is not what legal papers he owns, but what he does or does not do. Condemning Jefferson for merely being a slaveowner is trying to be politically correct and giving his attackers a very powerful moral weapon against the man. In actuality, the only thing you need, to evaluate Jefferson’s morality, is to find out how he treated his slaves and that will tell you the whole story. To me, the fact that he made love to a Black woman shows that he was far from this evil slave overlord who hated and put down the African people, as his enemies portray him today (and whom you inadvertedly are helping).
Now once you see what I mean here, you can go very far in your evaluations in conclusions. The Ancient Greeks owned slaves, just a the old South did, so are the two equally bad? Absolutely not. The old South, as a general rule, had a vehement contempt for their slaves, and subjected them to terrible labor, and generally treated them inhumanely. The Ancient Greeks were far less mean to their slaves, as a rule treating them kindly and looking out for them.
An contemporary conservative, criticizing the Athenian society, noted with contempt that he could not tell just by looking, whether people on the streets were free men or slaves because they all were dressed comparably, and everyone was polite to everyone else and stepped aside to let others walk by. True, inhuman labor existed then just as it does today, in such places as mines for example, but Athenians condemned free men who were criminals to such places just as much as slaves. Romans took this even further, and had things like a special holiday (Saturnalia) when the roles of slaves and masters were reversed, when slaves ate first, and masters had to wait up for them and do their bidding everywhere. Slavery was not viewed with as much contempt as we may think, and road to freedom from slavery was in Rome a routine matter of course, a diametric opposite of everywhere else in the world. Many important people started their careers, intellectually or otherwise, as slaves (Polybius, Epictetus the Stoic, etc), and grew to positions of great renown. As someone noted once, it was better to be a slave in Rome than to be a free man anywhere else. You cannot say anything like that for the old South, where slaves were in abject and miserable plight, and there was no hope or end in sight.
So my main point about slavery, and being a slaveowner, is that you should try to stay away from blanket condemnations (because they’re too easy to make, and are usually either merely incorrect, or utterly unfair as it happens to be in this case). We should condemn the old South, but praise ancient Athens and Rome. We should condemn the majority of Southern slaveowners, but praise Thomas Jefferson.
Could Jefferson have done more for the cause of political equality? Hardly, if you know anything about his intellectual contributions. Ought he have freed his slaves and gone to prison according to Southern law? That’s up to him, morality is not in question here. Was he immoral for keeping the slaves? Not from that fact alone, no.