How seriously should we take the Founders who compromised (nay, Sold Out) on the matter of slavery? There is a Dark Side to the Founders or at least some of them. The same religion that the Founders tolerated or favored was used to justify chattel slavery. Go figure.
Bob Kolker
Bob,
You arent seriously laying slavery at the feet of Christianity are you? I believe that slavery predates the birth of Christ by a millenium or two. As for the founders, they may not have ended slavery, but they laid down the principles that Lincoln would later use to argue for its abolition. The contradiction between the idea ‘that all men are created equal’ and idea that one man could own another could not last forever.
You arent seriously laying slavery at the feet of Christianity are you? I believe that slavery predates the birth of Christ by a millenium or two. As for the founders, they may not have ended slavery, but they laid down the principles that Lincoln would later use to argue for its abolition. The contradiction between the idea ‘that all men are created equal’ and idea that one man could own another could not last forever.
No. I am not. But Christianity was used to -justify- chattel slavery. Slavery is as old as civilization, itself.
I am more concerned that the Founders sold out on the issue. Thomas Jefferson, who righteously proclaimed that all men are endowed with certain inalienable right somehow manages to hold onto his slaves during his lifetime. John Adams who detested slavery, went along with it for the sake of getting a constitution. Do you see a problem here? I do.
He is correct. The Old Testament laid down plenty of laws concerning slaver and the New clearly treated it as a normal state of affairs.
There is frankly nothing in the Bible that could be used as an argument against slavery.
I don’t know of any arguments in the bible against slavery either, but I do think it should be noted that a large majority of the people in the abolitionist movement were Christians. Perhaps it is something something unrelated to their religion, but it does cause one to think that maybe something about Christian ethics lead them to believe the suffering of slaves to be wrong.
I don’t know of any arguments in the bible against slavery either, but I do think it should be noted that a large majority of the people in the abolitionist movement were Christians. Perhaps it is something something unrelated to their religion, but it does cause one to think that maybe something about Christian ethics lead them to believe the suffering of slaves to be wrong.
A large majority of the population of both the United States and Great Britain were Christians during each country’s respective abolition movements, including those who were for maintaining chattel slavery.
The Bible does have some explicit references on how to properly maintain one’s slaves. According to The Brick Testament, these passages are included in this: 1 Corinthians 7:21, 1 Timothy 6:1, Titus 2:9-10, 1 Peter 2:18.
At the time that Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence, the colonies were still under the rule of a “king”. Throughout the history of mankind, rule by kings implied by it’s nature that those that lived under a king had rights that were only granted to them by the king they lived under, and the concept of individual inherent rights of man that are naturally endowed in the absence of a ruler or king had not been practically developed or evolved to a point where a man living under a king was actually free.
So the argument could be made at the time…what was worse…a king ruling over tens of thousands of people that were essentially slaves since they lacked any fundamental real rights or liberties outside of what the king allowed them to have, or an individual owning a few slaves and having power over them. The dominance and rule of kings over large groups of men had to end prior to the concept of individual men owning slaves could even begin to be addressed, and individual liberty as a concept and the natural evolution man being free could occur.
As far as being able to free slaves, there was no way at the time that they could have been practically integrated into society, due to racism. But the same could be said if a few hundred white colonists were brought to somewhere in Africa at the time. They hardly would have been able to integrate into any society that existed in the central regions of that continent for the same reasons.
The founding fathers mistake, given all relevant facts of reality at the time, was in not freeing them and allowing them to return to their land of origin. The colonies (America) even at the time were a rich geographical region and could have easily financed the returning of free slaves to Africa and solved the entire problem. As human beings, once free they were hardly in a position to just stay within a nation or region where they were once enslaved and so much racism existed. It would have also been possible to set up a territory farther west for them to go and inhabit, but native Indians that existed farther west would have resisted the influx of African people the same way they resisted the westward movement of white Europeans.
A large majority of the population … were Christians during each country’s respective abolition movements, including those who were for maintaining chattel slavery.
Yes, since both sides were Christian, its reasonable to assume that Christianity had nothing to do with abolition. A Quaker and a slave-owner might read the very same bible and come to different conclusions about slavery; both might then try to justify their views based on selections from the bible. However, the fact is that the bible had been around for ages, while the real change was in the view of man.
jws1776 notes the relationship between wanting to be free from a king and thinking that slaves should be free from masters. I don’t think it’s necessary for one of those ideas to have come to practical fruition before the other. On the other hand, they’re basically “sub-ideas” under the same more abstract idea of man’s rights. In 1780, when Pennsylvania adopted a law to slowly phase out slavery, they explicitly mentioned the relationship between their demand to be free from a king and the idea that slaves should be freed.
The credit for the end of slavery should go to the intellectuals who championed the individual, perhaps with John Locke as the most proximate one to whom credit should be given.
Today, I was surprised to read that when Indiana Territory was established, slavery was allowed. One aspect was to allow existing slaves to continue to be owned; but, there was also a push to allow importation of new slaves. The northern part – now Illinois – faced the same issue, with pro-slavery people battling against abolitionists. One of the Illionois abolitionists was a man named James Lemen, who created a schism in his Baptist church over this issue, and formed his own church.
Why is this relevant to Jefferson? Because, Lemen was a friend and agent of Jefferson’s and years before, Jefferson had asked him to move to Indiana territory, and – when he did – supported Lemen’s efforts in fighting to make Illinois a free state. One historian recounts the story in “The Jefferson-Lemen compact”, arguing that Jeffersen asked Lemen to move to Indiana specifically to have him in place in the fight that would (predictably) ensue over whether it should be a slave state of a free one.
One thing that I don’t think anyone has mentioned here is that Jefferson could not free his slaves. Jefferson lived most of his life in debt due to his time found the country as well as the University of Virginia then his Presidency. I believe it was against the law in those days for someone in debt to give away property (for obvious reasons).