Today's Science Clashing with Objectivism?

I do recall that Rand was a blank slatist, which was a popular idea in her day, but my impression was that modern Objectivism no longer held to that given the large body of scientific evidence that has since accumulated to the contrary.

Much of today’s science clashes with Objectivism; that doesn’t mean Objectivism will change its position according to what science “has accumulated”.

Much of today’s science clashes with Objectivism; that doesn’t mean Objectivism will change its position according to what science “has accumulated”.

That’s wrong, and definitely not an Objectivist position.

That’s wrong, and definitely not an Objectivist position.

I guess some examples are in order?

  1. Big Bang theory

  2. environmental science (e.g. Global Warming theory)

  3. Gödel’s incompleteness theorem

  4. a hefty portion of quantum physics (e.g. Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle)

  5. (most likely all of) sociology

  6. praxeology

  7. analytic philosophy

  8. realism in psychology

  9. …

I guess some examples are in order?

If this is going to be explored in any detail, I suggest someone start a new topic.

If this is going to be explored in any detail, I suggest someone start a new topic.

There’s a tremendous difference between saying

“Objectivism is at odds with today’s science”

and

“Objectivism is at odds with science”.

A completely different context is assumed, with all of the relevant implications.

I guess some examples are in order?

  1. Big Bang theory

  2. environmental science (e.g. Global Warming theory)

  3. Gödel’s incompleteness theorem

  4. a hefty portion of quantum physics (e.g. Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle)

  5. (most likely all of) sociology

  6. praxeology

  7. analytic philosophy

  8. realism in psychology

  9. …

Most of that isn’t even established science, they’re just claims open to debate.

And, more importantly, whatever they are, Objectivism (Ayn Rand’s philosophy, as described in her published works and works she personally sanctioned) has no position on them.

Just because you, or even Leonard Peikoff himself, find flaws in something, doesn’t mean your findings suddenly become a part of Objectivism. (Dr. Peikoff would be the first one to tell you that, btw.)

Most of that isn’t even established science, they’re just claims open to debate.

I guess the incompleteness theorem is now just a claim open to debate.

I guess most of quantum physics are now just claims open to debate.

I guess the “cognitive revolution” never happened:

"Scientists recognize that the entire cerebral cortex is indeed preprogrammed and organized in order to process sensory input, motor control, emotions, and natural responses.[5] These programmed mechanisms in the brain then act to learn and refine the ability of the organism.[6][7] For example, Steven Pinker argues that while the brain is “programmed” to pick up spoken language easily, it is not programmed to learn to read and write, and a human generally will not spontaneously learn to do so.[8]

Important evidence against the tabula rasa model of the mind comes from Behavioural genetics, especially twin and adoption studies. These indicate strong genetic influences on personal characteristics such as IQ, alcoholism, gender identity, and other traits.[8]"

– http://en.wikipedia…iki/Blank_slate

“After all, the theory of evolution is only a hypothesis.” – Ayn Rand

And, more importantly, whatever they are, Objectivism (Ayn Rand’s philosophy, as described in her published works and works she personally sanctioned) has no position on them.

That does not negate the fact that much of today’s science flies in the face of Objectivism.

Just because you, or even Leonard Peikoff himself, find flaws in something, doesn’t mean your findings suddenly become a part of Objectivism. (Dr. Peikoff would be the first one to tell you that, btw.)

Right, “Objectivist’s position” != “Objectivism’s position”, but by virtue of thought, any rational individual will come to notice that there is a huge, huge breach between today’s scientific findings and what Objectivism has to say about the world.

I guess some examples are in order?

  1. Big Bang theory

  2. environmental science (e.g. Global Warming theory)

  3. Gödel’s incompleteness theorem

  4. a hefty portion of quantum physics (e.g. Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle)

  5. (most likely all of) sociology

  6. praxeology

  7. analytic philosophy

  8. realism in psychology

  9. …

  1. Why is the Big Bang at odds with Objectivism?

  2. (A)GW “theory” is nothing but a collection of faulty models based on faulty premises, and has IMO, been solidly debunked. Objectiv_ists_ may have a position on this debate (maybe even pro-AGW), but Objectiv_ism_ does not.

  3. Gödel’s theorem applies to mathematical axiomatic systems. Objectivism has axioms, but its various truths are found not through succesive combinations of and derivations from axioms (the way math theories are). Objectivists principles may be better described as applications of axiomatic truths to inductively connected observations.

  4. Again, Objectivism has nothing directly to say about the Uncertainty Principle.

  5. (most likely all) a pseudoscience, mostly because correlation isn’t causation and free will exists.

6+) I’ll need to look these up, but you should get the idea. Objectiv_ism_ does not have a position on anything outside of philosophy (metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, politics, aesthetics), unless the physical/mathematical theory contradicts an Objectivist philosophic principle, it is left to the physicists/mathematicians.

Almost forgot… “Tabula rasa” as referred to by Rand and Peikoff means that humans are born without concepts. Objectivism doesn’t deny that we are born with means of processing sensations into perceptions.

A forum search and some reading should make it clear what is specifically meant by “tabula rasa” in Objectivist writings. It is applicable only at the conceptual level.

  1. Big Bang theory: Not a problem for Objectivism. Big Bang Theory is only a problem for people who don’t know metaphysics and get wrapped up in paradoxes about the “beginning of time” problem.

  2. environmental science (e.g. Global Warming theory): I thought this thread was supposed to be about science, not socialist agitprop? The climate changes continuously but there is no Catastrophic Anthropogenic Global Warming.

  3. Gödel’s incompleteness theorem: I suggest reading Godel’s Theorem: An Incomplete Guide to Its Use and Abuse. I have. Almost no one resorting to the reference of this theorem in rhetoric has a clue of what it actually applies to. It is not a general disproof of the possibility of certainty. It is of no threat to Objectivism whatsoever.

  4. a hefty portion of quantum physics (e.g. Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle): It is only when the so-called “Copenhagen interpretation” is read to support radical subjectivism and metaphysical primacy of consciousness that there is a conflict with Objectivism. The conflict is not only with Objectivism, but any philosophy that has no room incorporate pure fucking magic.

  5. (most likely all of) sociology: There is a thread on Sociology and Objectivism here.

  6. praxeology: Since when is praxeology considered “part of today’s science”?

  7. analytic philosophy: Assuming you meant this, of course Objectivism conflicts with it. But it is not a science it is an opposing philosophy, so how did it end up on this list?

  8. realism in psychology: Is psychology a science yet? How could it ever become a science without embracing realism? What is the issue here? Links?

  9. …

Right, “Objectivist’s position” != “Objectivism’s position”, but by virtue of thought, any rational individual will come to notice that there is a huge, huge breach between today’s scientific findings and what Objectivism has to say about the world.

By that logic “I, a self professed Objectivist, think you’re wrong” and “what you’re saying clashes with Objectivism” are logically equivalent statements.

I could understand if you said that some interpretations of QM, once the physicists stray from interpreting empirical data, and attempt to make philosophical statements that deny the foundations of science (like the primacy of existence and the law of identity), clash with Objectivism. But how on Earth does climate science clash with Objectivism, except if you define “clash with Objectivism” as being mistaken or partially mistaken? Climate science makes no philosophical or political claims, it simply studies the Earth’s climate. Right or wrong, they don’t clash with anyone’s philosophy. The politicians who rely on it might (not because of climate science, but because they are ideologues: socialists and environmentalists), but Al Gore isn’t a scientist, and his propaganda isn’t science. No one in the scientific community thinks it is.

Do you go around telling everyone you disagree with that their views clash with Objectivism? If so, please stop.

Grames said:

“1) Big Bang theory: Not a problem for Objectivism.  Big Bang Theory is only a problem for people who don’t know metaphysics and get wrapped up in paradoxes about the “beginning of time” problem.”

Yes,not a problem for Oism because all the reasons BB cosmology is wrong are non philosophical reason that fall in the category of special science topics.(well there’s may be one or two ontological reasons). Just pointing out that your “only” isn’t universal.

A couple things. THese are not necessarily in order of apperance in the thread or in the initial list.

First, if you want to argue any of this, you should actually establish how Objectivism is at odds with these theories. Objectivism can only be at odds insofar as a scientific theory makes claims of philosophic import. What exactly are the philosophic claims of the Big Bang Theory itself? Of AGW? Godel’s incompleteness theorem says nothing of Objectivism. It’s a very limited theorem that put to bed a project of early analytic philosophy, to explain all of mathematics by the use of first order logic. If there is any mathematical philosophy espoused by Objectivism, it doesn’t run afoul with Godel.

Sociology is a very broad field, within which there are many different theories and frameworks. It’s a controversial field within itself. There aren’t many unifying theories within sociology that bring it together as a science. It’s a hodge podge.

Praxeology 1) isn’t accepted science and 2) isn’t at odds with Objectivism, for the most part. The Misesian conception might be, but I think Rothbard showed well enough that its a priori foundations are not necessary.

Analytic philosophy isn’t science. It’s not even a philosophy. It is, giving it a lot of slack, a way of doing philosophy that emphasizes clarity with use of concepts and language and use of formal logic. These are not things Objectivists oppose. What Objectivists oppose is linguistic philosophy, which is a particular strand within the tradition. Analytic philosophy itself is just a way of doing philosophy. It’s not how Rand did it or how most “system builders” would, but you can work within the analytic tradition and within the Objectivist tradition respectively.

I don’t know what you mean by psychological realism.

I’m going to have to show agreement with TheEgoist’s request that you show how the theories conflict with Objectivism. I try not to make it a habbit of chiming in with a, “ditto,” but it seemed appropriate in this case.

More material to think about regarding the blank slate:

“Research on the structure and development of the brain in animals supports Kant’s theory, at least for the perception of space; that is, spatial representation of the environment includes an innate component that predates any actual perception of the environment itself.”

– (an older revision of a) Wikipedia entry on Immanuel Kant

This also ties into the next segment:


Regarding realism in psychology:

“Rand’s notion that we can observe reality directly (known in philosophy as direct or naïve realism) is refuted by the current consensus in neuroscience, psychology, and the cognitive sciences (which accepts various forms of indirect or representative realism). In the cognitive sciences, raw input is called “bottom-up perception” and the way the brain interprets this input is called “top-down perception.” The visual, auditory, etc. cortices essentially “reconstruct” the input from their respective sense organs, meaning there is always some element of top-down interpretation of raw stimuli. Thus, we do not experience reality directly but in some sense a perceptual facsimile of reality constructed by the brain. A simple example of this is the fact that the image formed on your eye’s retina is upside-down, but the visual cortex flips it right-side up. There are numerous other examples as well, including hallucinations and cognitive illusions.[9]”

– http://rationalwiki…m_in_psychology


Usually, replies to bringing up these issues are such:

  • “that’s rationalism”

  • “those are just claims open to debate”

  • “<insert discipline here> is not a science”

etc.


Well if Gödel’s incompleteness theorem doesn’t conflict, why was it attacked in OPAR? Granted it was a single mention, but still.


More on Rand’s conflict with the theory of evolution – more striking excerpts:

Branden’s entry on her (Branden might have been lying here, don’t know):

“I remember being astonished to hear her say one day, “After all, the theory of evolution is only a hypothesis.” I asked her, “You mean you seriously doubt that more complex life forms — including humans — evolved from less complex life forms?” She shrugged and responded, “I’m really not prepared to say,” or words to that effect. I do not mean to imply that she wanted to substitute for the theory of evolution the religious belief that we are all God’s creation; but there was definitely something about the concept of evolution that made her uncomfortable.”

Her “missing link” theory (also discussed in an essay in P:WNI) slashing humans into two subgroups (human and sub-human):

"In her notes for Atlas Shrugged in 1946, she writes:

"The supposition of man’s physical descent from monkeys does not necessarily mean that man’s soul, the rational faculty, is only an elaboration of an animal faculty, different from the animal’s consciousness only in degree, not in kind.” (pp. 465-466.)

Her most interesting comment on the implications of evolution may be the following, also from her notes for Atlas Shrugged:

“We may still be in evolution, as a species, and living side by side with some “missing links.” [. . .] We do not know to what extent the majority of men are now rational. (They are certainly far from the perfect rational being, and all the teachings they absorb put them still farther back to the pre-human stage.) . . . . (Most men are rational beings, even if none too smart; they are not pre-humans incapable of rational thinking; they can be dealt with only on the basis of free rational, consent.)” (p. 466-67.)

“She goes on the same entry to describe those incapable of rational life as “sub-human” who need to be “enslaved” and “controlled.” (p. 467.)” [emphasis mine]"

–

http://rebirthofreas…Evolution.shtml

  1. Rand’s opinions on scientific issues were just that, her opinions on scientific issues. They weren’t a matter of philosophy.

  2. There is still a lot of controversy over direct VS representational realism in psychology and philosophy. I’d say those that grant representationalism are making a philosophic judgment error, but it’s not a matter of science.

  3. I’m not sure what you are getting at with your first reference to spatial representation. This doesn’t seem to have much to do with the blank slate theory.

That wiki is kind of garbage. I don’t know anything about neruology and I really don’t care about it. However it seems like quoting a webpage designed to attack Ayn Rand in order to show a conlfict between her philosophy and the finding of neurologists is a bad idea.

The mechanics of the brain are not important to Objectivism. We know that data is organized automatically into percepts. However we also know that that data is actually reflective of reality. Its like claiming that an online bank statements isn’t accurate or “direct” because it is broken down into 1’s and 0’s and then reorganized into other forms of code and then finally reorganized into text for you.

Neurology and Epistemology address different issues, its best not to confuse them.

Really if you want to discuss this issue further, I would suggest making a separate thread about Neurology and Epistemology and how they relate. Objectivism rejects the idea altogether that Neurology can contradict epistemology because epistemology is fundemental in the hierarchy of knowledge. Neurology is not. You aren’t going to get anywhere with us unless you can get past that.

  1. Leonard Peikoff probably didn’t undersand the idea completely when he wrote the book. He also attacks Herbert Spencer in OPAR and his ideas about Herbert Spencer are not entirely accurate either.

I think that what made her uncomfortable about evolution is that Nietzsche, Herbert Spencer, and H L Mencken all went nuts with the concept and came to a lot of unfortunate conclusions in their own way. In some ways those were her intellectual predecessors, and she found a lot of fault with their ideas. Her specific opinions seemed to have changed over time. The quotes show that her opinions on that matter weren’t consistent over her life time. They also happen to not be essential to her understanding of philosophy.

More material to think about regarding the blank slate:

“Research on the structure and development of the brain in animals supports Kant’s theory, at least for the perception of space; that is, spatial representation of the environment includes an innate component that predates any actual perception of the environment itself.”

– (an older revision of a) Wikipedia entry on Immanuel Kant

That is an utterly trivial statement. Having an eyeball is an innate component that predates any actual vision of the environment. Kant asserted (paraphrasing) that consciousness and the senses had an identity. Rand agreed with that. Rand disagreed that the identity of consciousness and limitations of the senses rendered anything existential intrinsically unknowable, or that inter-subjectivity could be a substitute for objectivity.


Regarding realism in psychology:

"Rand’s notion that we can observe reality directly (known in philosophy as direct or naïve realism)

Stop. Strawman, because Rand does not teach or favor naive realism. All she herself writes about perception is "…the arguments of those who attack the senses are merely variants of the fallacy of the “stolen concept.” {Foreword to ITOE, page 3) The detailed unravelling and painstaking refutation of representationalism in perception is done by Dr. David Kelley in The Evidence of the Senses ($9.99 pdf version available here).

Well if Gödel’s incompleteness theorem doesn’t conflict, why was it attacked in OPAR? Granted it was a single mention, but still.

It wasn’t attacked. The only thing close I could find was the following paragraph from the epilogue:

Modernist intellectuals are comparable to a psychopath who murders for kicks. They seek the thrill of the new; and the new, to them, is the negative. The new is obliteration, obliteration of the essential in every field; they have no interest in anything to take its place. Thus the uniqueness of the century behind us: philosophy gleefully rid of system-building, education based on the theory that cognition is harmful, science boastful of its inability to understand, art which expelled beauty, literature which flaunted antiheroes, language “liberated” from syntax, verse “free” of meter, nonrepresentational painting, atonal music, unconscious psychology, deconstruction in literary criticism, indeterminacy as the new depth in physics, incompleteness as the revelation in mathematics —a void everywhere that was acclaimed by the avant-garde with a metaphysical chuckle. It was the sound of triumph, the triumph of the new anti-ideal: of the unknowable, the unreachable, the unendurable.

The focus of the attack here is Modernism and the celebration of incompleteness in mathematics as if that implied anything about what world-view or philosophy was correct. It is an misuse of Gödel’s work and an abuse of logic to attempt to draw philosophical conclusions from it.

Something Kelley writes in Evidence of the Senses chapter six has a direct bearing on this.

It is typically assumed that justification occurs only at the level of propositional knowledge, that what justifies a judgment or assertion is another judgment or assertion according to the logic of propositions. Propositional justification is incompatible with any theory in which perception is a source of justification, such as the realist theory of perception presented in this book.

The massive abstraction which is mathematics is explicitly dedicated to propositional justification. The philosophical significance of the fact that Gödel was able to prove that any system of propositions was limited in what it could prove is simply that existence, life and the foundations of knowledge are not propositions. It is a megalomaniacal vanity to presume that starting from “Cogito, ergo sum” (or “A is A”!) that everything that exists or is true can be deduced.

More on Rand’s conflict with the theory of evolution – more striking excerpts:

Rand does not have a conflict with the theory of evolution because she does not have an opinion on it. The world would be a better place if everyone would refrain from commenting about subjects of which they know little, rather than posturing and bullshitting.

"The supposition of man’s physical descent from monkeys does not necessarily mean that man’s soul, the rational faculty, is only an elaboration of an animal faculty, different from the animal’s consciousness only in degree, not in kind.” (pp. 465-466.)

That is true as far as it goes. It is not necessary, meaning that it cannot be validly deduced, from the mere fact of descent from an earlier form that there cannot be a difference in kind (meaning “an important, essential, fundamental difference”). Consider also that “quantity has a quality all its own”.

“She goes on the same entry to describe those incapable of rational life as “sub-human” who need to be “enslaved” and “controlled.” (p. 467.)” [emphasis mine]"

–

http://rebirthofreas…Evolution.shtml

Now see, this is the problem with relying on Neil Parille, a non-objective commentator if there ever was one. He strategically paraphrases here and does not give the actual quote in order to make you believe Rand actually thought that. It is not Branden who lies, it is Neil Parille. I will quote the text in full:

Men’s intellectual capacities have always been so unequal that to the thinkers the majority of their brothers have probably always seemed subhuman. And some men may still be, for all the evidence of rationality, or lack of it, that they give. We may still be in evolution, as a species, and living side by side with some “missing links.” […]

We do not know to what extent the majority of men are now rational. (They are certainly far from the perfect rational being, and all the teachings they absorb push them still farther back to the pre-human stage.) But we do know that mankind as a whole and each man as an individual has a chance to <jrnl_467> survive and succeed only to the degree of their general and individual intelligence. That is all that a rational man can deal with, count on or be concerned with. Let him, without wondering about actual numbers or percentages of intelligence in others, act on the basis of “addressing himself to intelligence”-and he will win. And he will find that he does not have to fear stupidity. (Most men now are rational beings, even if not too smart; they are not pre-humans incapable of rational thinking; they can be dealt with only on the basis of free, rational consent.)

If it’s asked: what about those who are still pre-human, or near enough to it, and incapable of rationality as a method to guide their lives? What if such do exist among us? The answer is: nothing. Their way of living is not ours; in fact, they have no way of living, no method or means of survival—except through imitating us, who have acquired the human method and means. Leave us to our way of living, man’s way—freedom, individual independence-and we’ll carry them along by providing an example and a world of safety and comfort such as they can never quite grasp, let alone achieve.

We do this—but even if we didn’t, so what? If those creatures incapable of rational existence are sub-human, are we to sacrifice ourselves or be sacrificed to them? Are we to descend to their level? Are we to make them the goal of our existence, and service to them our only purpose? If these pre-humans are incapable of rational thinking and of independence, and therefore they need an enslaved, controlled, regimented, “protective” society in order to survive—we cannot survive in such a society. By definition, we are then two different species. Their requirements are opposite to ours. They’ll perish without us, anyway. But we will not he sacrificed to them. We will live in freedom—whether or not others will or can live that way.

Rand here merely entertains the implicit view of man inherent to socialism, that of a “pre-human … incapable of rational thinking and of independence” and therefore needing “… an enslaved, controlled, regimented, “protective” society in order to survive” presumably by their betters. (Reminder: this is the logic of socialism and the socialist ideal of a better person and Rand’s will differ massively. A critical plot point of Atlas Shrugged is that Rand’s ideal man would refuse the job of dictator when offered or even ordered on pain of torture). She concludes that even if it were true (and she never concedes that it is true) that would still not justify socialism for actual humans.