14 hours ago, intrinsicist said:
…you’ve admitted there’s a possibility of being wrong, you’ve admitted that you don’t believe universals necessarily hold true, yet you’re saying you have certainty…
You put a lot of words in my mouth that I didn’t say. I said there needs to be evidence of the possibility that you’re wrong, just like there needs to be evidence for any proposition. A capacity for error doesn’t mean there is evidence of one. In the case of the swan example, one might point to the fact that other types of animals come in different colors, so suspecting there might be a non-white swan is reasonable; the definition might be too narrow. But if you don’t think of that, then your “all swans are white” universal will be wrong.
Also, my point about “holds true” was that it can’t be the basis for your proposition, because you haven’t seen the proposition “hold true at all times in all places.” That’s part of the proposition itself, it’s not part of the evidence for it. The evidence is limited to the observations you’ve made yourself or heard about, which includes only some times in some places. But, again, being subject to human fallibility doesn’t mean there is always a possibility that you’re wrong.
I think the problem here is that you’re a proponent of the Logos, and I am not. But now I’m mostly repeating myself, so I’ll move over to your new thread on metaphysical universals and consider your arguments there.