The mind easily equates frequencies of 220Hz, 440Hz, 880Hz, etc., in fact we have a conceptual term that encompasses all of these exponentially related freqs: ‘A’
Where’s our disconnect?
Well, since you now seem to get the point I was making about exponential relations in the frequency domain, I think the disconnect (disagreement? I don’t know what “disconnect” means anyhow) would be over whether you can discover these kinds of facts about human perception just by reason and ordinary observation, with me saying you can’t.
If humanity was blind, and I was born with sight, my eyes would be “special instruments,” and thus any observations I made based on my visual perception of reality would be off limits from blind-mankind’s philosophy?
You know we hate unreasonable hypotheticals: being blind is not man’s nature.
The statement about “normal adult” has some serious implications for the primacy of the individual. It seems to put a scope on philosophy based on the arbitrary, average of humanity.
I don’t think it has anything to do with the “average” of humanity. What it means is that there are non-normal people who can’t see, or can’t hear; there are also mentally damaged adults who cannot reason. But philosophical questions can be resolved by reference to ordinary knowledge, meaning among other things stuff that you can see and hear, using reason. So if a person is abnormal because they can’t see or hear, or if a person can’t reason because they are brain-damaged, that does not then mean that all questions become scientific questions. It means: look at the range of knowledge gainable by man by simple observation of the world combined with reason, without special training or the derivatives of special training (instruments) – that is the domain of philosophy. It’s not a distinction defined by reference to the nature of each individual, it’s defined by reference to “man” and what “man” can know by a certain method, in general.
Perhaps it would help to rephrase “philosophical questions” as “questions that can be answered by philosophical methods”, idem “scientific questions” are “questions that can be answered by scientific methods”. Are you arguing that there is no difference at all between philosophy and science? Let me suppose you will say that is your claim – then how will you defend your claim? (I reject the claim, so I want to see how you think you can answer any questions in your way of approaching knowledge). If you do think that science and philosophy are different and you just disagree with Rand’s line, I want to see how you define the difference.
Also, if science answers (or studies) a question pondered by philosophy, does that question automatically become exempt from philosophical exploration?
Whether or not a question is properly a scientific vs. a philosophical question isn’t determined sociologically, by whether professed scientists vs. philosophers are addressing the question. The distinction lies in the nature of the question itself. Thus the claim that there are 15,747,724,136,275,002,577,605,653,961,181,555,468,044,717,914,527,116,709,366,231,425,076,185,631,0
31,296 protons and as many electrons in the universe is a scientific question, not a philosophical one. The question whether “The simplest theory is the best” is not a scientific question, it is a philosophical one (a kind of dumb one at that).