Again, what is given in perception is the given, but must be identified – in explicit conceptual terms – requiring volitional cognition. And the senses do not create an entity, which you have alluded to several times. The entity is there, and we perceive it with the senses. In other words, we don’t perceive an output, say on a screen, and then have to interpret what it is that we are watching on our little internal movie screen. We perceive the entity, not a processed image of the entity.
Actually, I do have a little internal movie screen, called the retina. Only instead of “me” watching it, I have millions of individual visual receptors watching. Each of them reports the level and color of incident light from a particular vector direction to the visual cortex, which based on differences between adjacent levels, discovers discontinuities, then correlates the discontinuities to discover edges, then correlates connected edges to discover shapes, then correlates shape areas to discover entities… etc. But all of that is immaterial because I only know about the rods and cones through the medical sciences, and I can’t consider that information in my philosophy, so my perception of entities just happens.
Or something like that?
So I’m still trying to figure out if an illusion is an entity. For instance if twins turn to each other and bring their faces close, is the outline of a vase an entity? Are patterns formed by the random alignment of multiple entities, entities, or just patterns? Is the outline of Orion or Ursa Major an entity? (These are serious questions which seek to establish the precise definition of your terms.)
You can imagine it, but I doubt that if you went blind that you could perceive the world via infrared. At least no one has ever reported this happening.
David Odden did, on Dec 11, at 11:14 a.m. (Sorry, David)
In the case where the receptors are pinpointed, the brain automatically integrates together similarities and differences in relation to the surface area in question. In other words, the pattern is given in perception , but the subject must learn to identify the entity via this new perceptual source.
I think you’re wrong there. Imagine feeling a sour spot go from right to left across your tongue. At the same time you hear someone walk across the room, from right to left. Getting an unfamiliar sensory input, your conscious mind makes a connection between the two movements, but it doesn’t just automatically correlate and begin perceiving entities by taste, you have to play with it for a while to make sure you really are sensing what you think you are, that is, you’re comparing, differentiating, correlating with effort, the movement on your tongue. Once you’ve determined the sense data is consistent with reality, your mind starts to take over, learning to refine by continuing the correlation process. In other words, it learns to perceive entities through taste, a sense, which by a previous post, you conceded provided attributes only, and not “entities qua entities.” (which I take to mean “entities.”)
I see you’re holding on tenaciously to the entity as the irreducible primitive of perception, although I see some cracks.
By declaring the primacy of entity is self-evident, you are eschewing any need to prove your point of view. I accept that, logically, but I remain skeptical of the asserted principle.
My “problem” is probably that I don’t see the Kantian trap from presuming a learned, automated integration of attributes into an entity. The rational mind is obsessed with eliminating contradictions, so in the given example, if you tried to take a bite out of that apple and instead got a purple tusk in the eye, you’d be served with a contradiction between perception and reality. I take it as self-evident that my perception is completely consistent with reality, because I perceive no contradictions, and I can, for instance, correlate all of my senses, pick up a rock and toss it into a drainage pipe 50 feet away. Pink elephants don’t routinely appear and disappear in my living room. Every aspect of my perception is consistent with every other aspect, and this completeness, this perfection, proves to me that my perception is representative of reality. I can comprehend intellectually that my senses provide an artificial encoding of attributes, such as color, sound tones, brightness, etc., but regardless of anyone’s views on whether they are or are not equal to reality, I can see, hear, feel, etc. that they are representative and consistent, so I don’t have any doubts that my perception is “real.” To be a metaphysical (term?) skeptic is to abrogate any useful definition of reason, so I reject the irrational conclusions or suspicions of Kant and nihilists.
I believe Rand, in her hatred of Kant, may have overshot the mark when attacking his philosophy, and in doing so rejected his premises and any possibility of a causal (and thus vulnerable) processing chain between reality and perception, when in fact she only needed to recognize the weak links in his logic to reject his conclusions.
But just as a final point (and then I’m done - promise), would you say that your perception of reality is consistent with subatomic physics? If not, do you reject that branch of science as not representative of reality, or do you recognize a limitation of your perception’s representation of reality? I don’t think this is a minor point of missing senses, like UV, radio, etc., because there are behaviors apparent in QM that truly are counter-intuitive and incompatible with our (my) perception of reality.