I find it funny that this thread has continued to grow.
Agrippa: you have managed to get Thomas to argue with you about the specific nature of entities when you haven’t even acknowledged that entities exist!!! As attested to here:
In order to make any sense of the questions you’re asking we would first need to know what your fundamental view of reality is.
Is it: Primacy of existence or Primacy of consciousness;
do you think that existence exists, that there is one reality and that it exists independent of consciousness, that consciousness perceives what actually exists?
OR
do you think that reality only exists in the mind, that the mind constructs the reality that we see, that there is no one objective reality, that reality is different for each person?
If you need perceptual proof, just open your eyes; if you need conceptual proof, just try to frame an argument or say a sentence without accepting that existence exists.
If this question seems pedantic to you, your answer is not so obvious to me, because of what you say below (with emphasis added):
Are you leaving open the possibility of some sort of feedback loop in which one’s consciousness can alter reality?
Also, I think you should be careful about challenging the logic of Ayn Rand’s position when you have admitted that you don’t know her position.
Okay, these are fair. Entities exist. Existence exists. Reality is the source of all sensory inputs.
All entities have attributes and are identified by them. Attributes can not exist without entities.
Here’s my problem with entities being primary, from the beginning of perception (i.e., birth or in utero): perception of an entity (which is being defined here as an object in reality, made of matter, with a definite boundary) requires the brain to organize the inputs of rods and cones to perceive the boundaries that define an entity. If the brain, at the moment of first perception, is able to make assumptions about the relative positions of the individual rods and cones input signals, in order to perceive shapes, it means that at that instant the brain must know the nature of the geometric relationship inherent in those neural entry points (into the visual cortex). This implies that the brain must know something, at least about itself, prior to the first input of sensory perception. This is a contradiction. To resolve the contradiction, I posit that the brain receives what appear initially to be random neural inputs from all its senses. It begins correlating movements, shapes, etc. to create a model of reality that is consistent with its sensory inputs. As we gain experience in resolving the sensory inputs into entities, we transfer that function to a subconscious so to the adult it is as if we just perceive entities. We perceive the attributes of entities and the entities themselves seemingly simultaneously.
I back this up on two fronts:
First, that it is impossible for us to make positive assertions about first perceptions by looking at our adult perceptions.
Second, that I believe I’ve shown at least two examples of conscious integration of heat and taste sensations into entities.
The feedback question is interesting, because there certainly is a “feedback loop” in which consciousness can alter reality. It’s called “action.” (But, no, perception is unidirectional from reality to the mind)