where's the official dictionary?

I have been wondering a bit about the fact that neither Ayn Rand nor the Ayn Rand institute has published an official dictionary of the concepts employed in presenting objectivism itself.

It is explicit in objectivist epistemology that concepts need to be defined, so it would only make sense to apply the standards of objectivism to presenting objectivism itself. In fact when objectivism isn’t presented based on a dictionary of concepts that can all be accounted for by explicit induction and which is logical consistent I think objectivist will always stay vulnerable to attacks of rationalists who are smart in dissecting the terminology employed.

I have found the Ayn Rand lexicon: http://www.aynrandlexicon.com/ but I find this insufficient. It doesn’t use genus-differentia and it is also not comprehensive. It is for instance not possible to find all concepts used by Peikof in The Ominous Parallels and OPAR. Personally I think the very least that would be required is a dictionary of nouns. I did find this site: http://objectivism101.com/IOP/Dictionary.html, but I do not consider it authoritative. I think it an official dictionary requires an official institute, this also gives contemporary objectivist authors the opportunity to express the fruits of their labour unambiguously.

Which words do you believe are used in a non-standard way and this require definition? Ordinary English words do not require such definition, since they already are defined. Give me a half-dozen examples so I can see what problem you are referring to.

http://www.aynrandbookstore2.com/prodinfo.asp?number=CK58E

I have been wondering a bit about the fact that neither Ayn Rand nor the Ayn Rand institute has published an official dictionary of the concepts employed in presenting objectivism itself.


What prevents you from organizing such a book?

What prevents you from organizing such a book?

That’s a bit unfair. It would be the responsibility of ARI to publish something like that, if there was a real need for it.

I don’t think there is, I have no problem finding definitions in Ayn Rand’s books, but if there was a need, there would be plenty of things preventing everyone except a few established American intellectuals from coming up with a book that would be taken seriously.

There are quite a number of projects that would be interesting and useful but which are of a lower priority than promotion and activism at this point in time. There are only so many people in the ARI and elsewhere able to do the kind of work required for these lower-priority projects. There are only so many Objectivist intellectuals who are educated and immersed enough in a given topic to do a soberly professional job, as opposed to enthusiastic amateurs whose efforts are apt to be cringe-worthy (eg see the resulting need on the part of Dr’s Binswanger and Norsen to ask people to stop posting to the MP blog unless they really knew who and what they were dealing with). This was precisely one of the things that Dr Brook lamented during OCON08, and he noted that we needed more intellectuals in a variety of fields to fill all these little gaps, and not just the lower-priority ones either but also the top-priority ones.

One day the lower-priority works will get done, but not until there are more professional intellectuals who can spend time doing them. Certainly, projects could be carried out over the course of time by Objectivist professionals simply because they like the work (and whose efforts would indeed do their part to further our cause), but as far as ARI-commissioned work goes the issue of priorities remains extremely strong for the foreseeable future. In the mean-time, we’ll either have to do fragments the work for ourselves as we need (which are are never really absolved from doing anyway) or, as Prof Odden has suggested, make use of forums to ask questions. And, as A is A suggested, if you’re a professional in the field then why don’t you be the first one to attempt the creation of what you have in mind?

JJM

What prevents you from organizing such a book?

if you’re a professional in the field then why don’t you be the first one to attempt the creation of what you have in mind?

JJM

Time, I am no professional so I do not have the time required for thorough research and analysis.

That’s a bit unfair. It would be the responsibility of ARI to publish something like that, if there was a real need for it.

thank you.

Which words do you believe are used in a non-standard way and this require definition? Ordinary English words do not require such definition, since they already are defined. Give me a half-dozen examples so I can see what problem you are referring to.

I beg to differ. Ordinary English words don require such definitions, loads of common words are highly ambiguous. I think homonyms have no place in presenting something that requires very precise language.

http://www.aynrandbookstore2.com/prodinfo.asp?number=CK58E

ah, no small hypocrisy after all, this might just be what I was looking for…thanks.

I still want to see evidence that there is a real need for such a dictionary. That would imply that Rand had changed the standard meanings of English words, and I challenge anyone to show that she did so.

I still want to see evidence that there is a real need for such a dictionary. That would imply that Rand had changed the standard meanings of English words, and I challenge anyone to show that she did so.

Selfish.

David, what would you accept as an accurate reference for the “standard meanings”? A dictionary?

Aren’t all dictionaries based on common use, meaning that “standard meaning” is the same as “how it’s most commonly used”? It is a very strong theme here that the “standard meanings” of several words need to be changed because the standard meanings are often “package deals”. Cue the difference between the dictionary definition of “selfish” and Rand’s usage of the term. Rand defined it as “having concern for oneself” while the '67 Webster defines it as “having concern for oneself with disregard to others”. Rand would refer to the latter definition as a package-deal, right?

[edit] fixed wording.

Selfish.

So go ahead and show me how Rand defines “selfish” in a non-standard way.

I have to say I come across this assertion every time im in a debate with someone of any philisophical significance. Ive yet to have a single person give one instance of her “redefining” any word. Im always hearing people tell me that im using “technical” definitions/words. The folks at Maverick have been doing just this.

David, what would you accept as an accurate reference for the “standard meanings”? A dictionary?

Not “any dictionary”, but that which is agreed to by the the three most authoritative dictionaries of English (the OED, Webster’s Unabdridges, and the AHD).

Aren’t all dictionaries based on common use, meaning that “standard meaning” is the same as “how it’s most commonly used”?

They should be, though not all dictionaries are. The aforementioned dictionaries are based on solid empirical research; they accurately express the facts of the language.

Cue the difference between the dictionary definition of “selfish” and Rand’s usage of the term. Rand defined it as “having concern for oneself” while the '67 Webster defines it as “having concern for oneself with disregard to others”.

The AHD (I don’t have the print version on hand) reads “Concerned chiefly or only with oneself”. The clause “disregard to others” is unwarranted editorialization, thus is not part of the definition (the essential characteristics). A more accurate statement, if one were to make any additional statement beyond “concern for oneself” would be “not placing the interests of others above your own” – the “disregard to others” attempts to say something correct, but fails in the particular wording (which AHD does not use).

Not editorializing is a fundamental virtue for lexicography, which good dictionaries strive towards though sometimes fail at (as in the Webster’s definition). An editorialization has no effect on the referents of a term, and any clause which does not function to define the term – to broaden or narrow the class of entities referred to by a word – is not part of the definition.

BTW Rand define selfishness, not selfish, as “concern with one’s own interests” (VOS vii).

You asked how she redefined the “standard meaning,” not the “dictionary definition.” There are tons of “dictionary definitions” that do not match up with the way that words are used by most people. Ask any person on the street what the word “selfishness” means, and they are likely to mention something about disregard for others or being willing to “step on” other people to get what you want.

You want the word to mean something other than what it means to most people. And–since the word is generally thought of as negative by virtually all non-Objectivists–the continued use of such an esoteric definition does little more than diminish whatever influence Ayn Rand’s philosophy has on the world.