Offensive display of superiority or self-importance; overbearing pride.
What would be an “inoffensive” display of superiority?
“Offensive” to whom, and for what reason?
What if the person is, actually, superior? How do you not “display” it?
What would it mean to be self- “unimportant”?
What would a “display” of self-unimportance look like?
What is non-overbearing pride? Overbearing to whom and for what reason?
–These questions are used to highlight that the definition provided is based on a certain moral code.
Having a definition based on a certain moral code is possible, but it is inappropriate to smuggle the code into the definition as if the underlying moral code is axiomatic, i.e., taken for granted.
In this case, the smuggled-in moral code is Altruism, and when we take the obverse of its elements, we get a hint as to the moral standard being suggested: humility, or non-superiority, i.e., inferiority; self-unimportance, i.e., low, little, or no-self-esteem; non-overbearing, under-bearing and/or no bearing pride…
Ayn Rand, stated in ITOE, the truth or falsehood of all man’s conclusions depends on the truth or falsehood of his definitions. So, she obviously believed definitions were very important.
How do we know if a definition is true or false?
We have to validate it, and if necessary, derive the definition ourselves, first hand.
Often in O’ist lectures, it is said a decent (non-circular etc) definition is a good place to start when trying to understand a concept; but that the dictionary is only a starting point.
What we want to do is use it as help to getting to the actual referents of the concept, i.e., we want to find the objects in reality the concept actually refers to.
Sometimes this is easy for concepts with a low level of abstraction and/or a high degree of specificity, e.g., concepts such as: ball, eagle, laugh, beside. Other times it’s very difficult, such as in the case of concepts like: justice, freedom, arrogance, honesty, good and/or bad.
Ayn Rand, in her lectures on fiction and non-fiction states one needs to be totally Aristotelian when dealing with concepts, as opposed to Platonic.
In part, what she meant is one needs to first look to the facts, then abstract from there, and classify and define first-hand from the data provided by our senses and/or direct perceptual concretes, and move progressively more abstract; that one’s abstractions must only be derived from actual referents, and not invented, or taken for granted.
If we want to know what “arrogance,” actually means, we need to actually find instances of the subject matter and observe, first hand to discover what subject matter is supposed to be referenced; we need to actually find people behaving as “arrogant,” (if possible) according to the best definition we can get our minds on.
If the concept is valid at all, we should be able to uncover, and gather the context in which the conventional concept is defined. If the concept is completely invalid, such as “god” or “Santa Claus,” we will run into problems immediately, and will not be able to find a context in which we can observe, e.g., god.
In the case of arrogance, we can infer some of the necessary context for which it is claimed that the phenomena of “arrogance,” occurs. For example, we can easily gather a basic “genus” of the claimed concept, i.e., we can find the wider category for which it is a specific member. We need to ask, what kind of thing is arrogance? Arrogance is supposed to be a certain kind of human behavior.
Next, we need to find what characteristics of “arrogance,” separates it from other forms of human behavior. We want to find the concept “arrogance” closest relative, i.e., we want to find the concepts which are not arrogance, but could be confused with it.
Even using the provided definition of arrogance, we can infer some helpful information. We probably get a sense the term in the current definition is intended to be pejorative, thus it is a normative concept, which means it is evaluative, which should key us to begin uncovering the moral standard, being used to make the evaluation.
I hope this is a helpful lead,
Regards,
I highly recommend, Harry Binswanger’s lecture on Logic, he provides a great set of pointers on how to build a definition first hand.