I find these a very strange set of sentences. “Neither can be decided . . .”?
If by “strange” you mean “unfamiliar,” then I certainly agree with you. The idea – the very idea! – of considering one’s own desires within the overall context of one’s own purpose is certainly unfamiliar to most of the business people I have met. Such people were pragmatists who considered only the bucks, never mind how they were gained.
You can decide exactly who OO.net’s customers are , and know why they visit, without any theoretical thinking at all.
(Bold added for emphasis throughout my post here.)
Here is what SoftwareNerd said in the opening paragraph of this thread: “In order to market/advertise ObjectivismOnline.net, one of the critical starting points is to ask ourselves who we want to market ourselves to. Here is a tentative description of our potential’customers’.”
This exercise isn’t an analysis of present customer base, but about who OO’s customers should be – given a context-setting purpose for OO (which, I assume, fits into the administrators’ own ultimate purpose in life).
The point is, as always, to look at reality.
Absolutely. The question is, should we take the pragmatic businessman’s approach of looking at only one patch of reality, or should we look at all of reality as we have experienced it, understood it, and used it as a basis for setting overarching – and therefore context-setting – purposes?
Determine first who are your customers and what are their specific needs, then draw your purpose from that data.
I radically disagree. I prefer the approach of the fictional character, Howard Roark, and the real-life inspiration of Ayn Rand: Decide one’s hierarchy of purposes and then go looking for customers who will pay to see those purposes put into reality to their benefit. The idea is to decide what one wants to do (within the context of a rational understanding of the whole world, not just a patch of it), and then make it pay as well as possible.
In other words, you don’t begin by asking: “What would we like to do?” You begin by asking, “What can we do?”
Again, I disagree. First, one should ask, “What, based on all that I know about myself and the world around me, do I want to do?” If the answer is objective – that is, conclusions are drawn logically from the facts of reality – then the “can” is already included.
Or in still other words, your purposes and desires are totally unimportant — until and unless you clearly understand your customer’s purposes and desires.
To the contrary, the business owner’s purposes should be paramount on all the essentials of designing a business. The negotiating with customers comes only in the nonessentials. If I love designing and manufacturing cars, I won’t design baby-buggies, no matter how much money customers might throw at me. I don’t care about color or internal fabric, so I can make a range of those available to potential customers, but one should not let them dictate changes away from what one loves to do.
The order of causation, at least in a successful business, is exactly the reverse of what you mention.
Guy Francon was successful in business. Thanks, but no thanks.
Sadly, for many businesses, your statement is true. I saw that in my own 20 years of experience in business as a writer, editor, and publications manager. Most business people strive for only the bucks and have no satisfaction in creating products and services they love, as part of their basic purposes in life.