Babies, despite not being rational, are humans.
Humans, despite having stages of growth, are always human, and when they do work for their own survival, rational.
It is logical to grant rights to humans, because of their nature. Criminals who act irrationally are punished accordingly. Humans in vegetative states are, in fact, euthanized if it can be reasonably proved that they are not, nor will ever again, possess consciousness (reason). Babies, then, by their nature, are rational beings in a state of incubation. On the one hand, there are the rights of their grown selves. On the other hand, all humans alive were necessarily once babies. Even if a baby was born with full rational capacity, it would still need time to learn how to survive before it could. It’s just the most basic common sense to grant rights to babies, for exactly the same reasons why one would grant them to human adults.
As for animals, this is a difficult question indeed. I have an answer though. Man lives morally so long as he does not demand of the world that which is beyond its nature. Thus a rational man may never improperly demand the compliance of another to his own will. Rational men do not live in such a world, nor do they or their actions permit or sustain it. This applies to animals in the sense that man may not attempt to impose on animals any sort of life that is contrary to that which is natural to the animal.
Thus, man may kill animals for food, breed them, kill them young even. He may manipulate them genetically, or through breeding, an create new and different types of animals with different natures.
What he may not do is that which is unnatural - torture, excessive exploitaton (force feeding an animal so depressed it would rather starve, or bizarre experimentation), and so forth. Again, the reason is for man’s sake. That which is ‘unnatural’ is that which seeks some gain from the animal that defies its nature. Torture fulfills man’s bloodlust, an arbitrary and abstract sickness, for which the nature of animalkind provides no given mode of fulfillment.
I’d say that mammals generally require happiness to sustain a limited volitional capacity. So, in general, torture or abuse is forcing mammals to live against their nature. Torture is a negative gain for man, an easy example, but what if there is a positive gain like increased meat capacity from torturous barn conditions? Unfortunately, the best answer I can come up with is as ambiguous and vague as the provision of the bill of rights that bans ‘cruel and unusual’ punishment. If the cattle ranch conditions are ‘unnatural’ - not as in unlike nature, but rather, as in, denying the very fundamental nature of the cow, turning it completely from a living organism into a meat factory - then perhaps at that point it would be immoral.
Even so, if it was immoral, there’d be only a limited claim for ‘rights’. Government is limited, and governs intra-man. Extending its authority to animals is tricky, because doing so grants it too much authority philosophically. I suppose one man could claim an abused animal from another, claiming stewardship. Thus the government would arbitrate between men. That would work, and I could see the torture type situations being regulated like this. I could also see commercial rules, such as banning sale of dogs to dog fightes. But if a dog fighter had some secret stash of puppies that the animal rights advocate couldn’t keep up with… well too bad really…
As for the cows, I think it’s a matter of consumption and choice. One would make the rather subjective decision about ‘unnatural stewardship’ and not purchase meat from factory farms if they could afford it. I don’t mean to say that ‘unnatural stewardship’ is a subjective standard, only that it’s complex. Being that it involves non-humans, the political process can only go so far in making conclusions by it. Hence, the personal choice. So, the ‘rights’ then, are limited, and ultimately retained by humans who love animals.
In fact, that’s one way to deal with babies - stewardship claims. If a child is abused or mistreated, stewards may claim it, and the arbitration is between rational adults, not an adult, the state, and the child. As for the state, it would have to assume responsibility for children of criminal adults whom it locks away. Although, if a child truly is not developed, can it not live in the prison with the parents? Or, basically something to that effect with an orphanage? Since the state must provide the needs of the incarcerated adult, as a steward of a child, the adult’s imprisonment extends that entitlement to the child. Again, the adult’s ‘rights’ are being met as a steward.