Why is volition at the root of validation

In OPAR I’m up to “Volition as Axiomatic”. It’s stated that

The concept of “volition” is one of the roots of the concept of “validation” (and of its subdivisions, such as “proof”). A validation of ideas is necessary and possible only because man’s consciousness is volitional. This applies to any midea, including the advocacy of free will: to ask for its proof is to presuppose the reality of free will.

Is this because “asking” a question contains the concept of volition?

Regardless of whether he chose to or was caused to ask a question by external factors - can someone who has no volition not still be capable of asking a question?

I found the answer here: http://dir.groups.yahoo.com/group/opar/message/133

From Thomas M. Miovas, Jr.

Regarding Dean’s blogspot article on the relationship of the

concepts “volition” and “validation”

(http://planoopar.blogspot.com/), I found it interesting and

intelligently written, but the relationship between “volition”

and “validation” is actually a bit more simple. Granted, he is

correct to say that we need to reduce our concepts to the

perceptually self-evident (so this is part of the relationship),

though I think the actually key is that we *have volition* and

therefore we need to *validate* our conclusions.

If we were automatons or some sort of biological machine, then

our minds would operate like computers – we would follow our

programing, without the ability to change our operating codes

ourselves (unless we were pre-programmed to do so), and

therefore we could not be held responsible for coming up with a

correct or an incorrect answer to a query: We would simple give

an output for a given input, which would be neither true nor

false nor arbitrary; since it would simply be the output (in a

similar way that a rock is neither true nor false nor arbitrary,

it simply *is*).

But we have free will (volition), and therefore we don’t simply

follow a programming code – we can chose to operate according

to reason and logic or we can choose to operated according to

some other operating code of behavior (or at a minimum choose

*not* to follow reason and logic). So the real root behind

“validation” (the compliance of our reasoning to match and

identify aspects of existence according to what they actually

are) is our necessity of *choosing* to operated according to

reason and logic, because as volitional living beings, we can

choose otherwise.

In other words, we must *chose* to follow [the concept

“volition”] a certain *method* that keeps our minds firmly

within the bounds of existence (because there isn’t anything

else) [the concept of “validation”]. Without volition, not only

would there be no need for validating our conclusions, it

wouldn’t even be possible – we would simply be doing something

with our minds in a pre-determined manner that would be neither

a right method nor a wrong method, it would simply be what we

do. So, the concept “validation” requires (or presupposes) the

concept “volition.”

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Philosophic essays based on the philosophy of Ayn Rand

http://www.home.earthlink.net/~philosophic-essays/

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

Who y’a gonna call? $ $ $

Kant Busters! $ $

Where KANT is a $ K K// $

FOUR letter word. K K//

And remember: $ KKK// $

Don’t KK// K

Get $ K// K $

SLIMED! $ // $

M.U.C.U.S. $ $ $

Masticating Undecipherable Conundrums Unmasks Sleazers

All rights reserved 2005 by Thomas M. Miovas, Jr.

This point is the basis of a familiar argument against determinism, attributed variously to Epicurus, Kant, Blanshard and Branden: if your beliefs were determined, you could say only that you had to accept them, not that you had any rational grounds for so thinking; this applies to the determinist thesis itself, so the determinist can’t claim that his belief is true.

Supposedely Russell’s theory of types points out something wrong with the argument, but I don’t know how that’s supposed to go.

I have heard determinists respond with, “but I was predetermined to question my beliefs and believe they are true.”

To question means choice. predetermined choice is an oxymoron.