I wanted to start this new thread to disuss Writing and the Publishing Industry. First, it can be a place where writers can come and talk about any difficulities and struggles they are having with writing, as well as the joys of writing. Second, a place to talk about finding out where to get works published.
Since I am the one who started this thread it will be up to me to get matters started I suppose. I am not sure how many writer’s we have on the board here, but I do know that one of the problems that I have facing me is the fact of trying to distinguish the motivational reasons of wanting to write a particular piece. Such as some of the story ideas I had going for a while, even though when I originally thought up these ideas I couldn’t wait to begin writing them. Yet, eventually I wouldn’t go to write them and I could never figure out why. After checking my premises I came to realize that the motivation behind writing these stories was strictly for propaganda purposes. As such, I’ve had to forget these ideas and start from scratch. Anybody else have these problems or have faced something similiar?
[…] when I originally thought up these ideas I couldn’t wait to begin writing them. Yet, eventually I wouldn’t go to write them and I could never figure out why. After checking my premises I came to realize that the motivation behind writing these stories was strictly for propaganda purposes. As such, I’ve had to forget these ideas and start from scratch. Anybody else have these problems or have faced something similiar?
Yes, I did, perhaps 30 or 40 years ago. The problem was that I did not have a clearly defined central purpose in life (CPL) and did not connect each project up to that CPL. That is a problem of integration – or rather, lack of integration.
The solution? Define one’s CPL appropriately, pick projects appropriate to one’s skill level, and select projects congruent with the CPL. In effect, this approach engages the “gears” of one’s values. That’s what is required to get through the long, often unpleasant process of conceiving, planning, developing, drafting, editing, and proofreading a writing project.
Further, you are right to see that a desire to propagate someone else’s ideas is not an enduring motivator. The ideas (that is, themes) you want to show need to be your own ideas, even if you originally heard them from someone else (such as Ayn Rand).
Thanks Burgess, as I have said I have realized this and the whole notion of the CPL is thought provoking. Something I will surely have to sit back and think on. As I said in my last response to you in the Free Time post, this is what I have been doing mostly. I also think something I need to do is sit down and just define what it is I wish to do with my writing and define other such concepts. Find my CPL…:goes away to think: BTW have you read my poetry? ![]()
It is possible to have an idea one wants to express but as Burgess said you have to own it. In this area, basically said, one needs to see the hierarchy that one’s events will dramatize.
It is usually best to pick a scene that one wants to get to. For example, the short story in this section was conceived from the idea of keeping them from having sex on one day of work. I wanted them to want it, make the desire believable, but have them wait. It was a very inductive process … and even stream of consciousness. I do not adhere to conscious rule of literary writing except as those ideas are automatic in me. The goal was that scene, and a goal of 10 pages.
Another story that is longer and which I am more proud of I had no page limit. I knew that I wanted someone to fall off his balcony in the name of love. In the process of writing I realized that I could not possibly make him jump off. So at a certain point I realized that I could make him not jump off, and thus his love would be possible on this earth.
A moral question still open is one of forgiveness–Objectivism might not advocate the forgiveness over attempted suicide … but I know that Romanticism would, i.e., it would still be a good story … and the best that I could do.
Yes, central purpose is the key. When writing, the story is the central purpose of one’s life during the time of writing, any secondary financial job serves that. That has always been my view. And if this is the case, then one is usually more serious at the money-paying job because of the crucial place that creative writing has in one’s life, i.e., one’s happiness, and thus the fuel for any other endeavour.
Now publishing, I know nothing about. Maybe someone has some good advise. Writing has to truly be about the writing, the final unity of one’s best creativity, and not about the publishing. The work should matter in relation to eternity, and not in relation to the current market.
Americo.
Hey Burgess can you explain the CPL just a bit better by possibly given an example? I think I could have it though, but I want to be sure. Trying to work matters out in my head and am coming to certain conclusions. I guess what I am trying to figure out is something along the lines of this, is my CPL something I define then in order to acheive my CPL is through my writing?
Is this what you have done?
Actually I just noticed that I made a mistake about the location of my story, AFTER WORK.
It is in the Culture-Productivity section.
Sorry and thanks,
Americo.