Can we treat humans without a rational capacity as property?

I came across something not too long ago about how in China they skin dogs alive without killing them for faux fur, then discard their alive bodies to live (I assume a short period of time, idk though) without their skin.

That seemed a little disturbing at least because I usually think of dogs with their skin on but it made me wonder… I believe I understand that the Oist position would be this is a good thing because it’s pro-human life (lower costs involved than in killing them themselves, so more productive).

So I was wondering if the same would be true with humans who are so retarded they do not have any rational capacity. Maybe they can walk around, but cannot talk, don’t understand concepts (I assume they were born this way) and lets say have less of a brain than a dog. And because of the nature of their problems they will not at any point in the future have a rational capacity

Now assuming no one wants to support this person by charity could this person be bought by companies and have similar things done to it? Like have parts of their skin removed to give it to burn victims, or amputate appendages to give to soldiers, etc?

This would seem moral to me according to Oism since the feeling of pain is not relevant and since they are not rational beings and will never be rational beings.

I believe I understand that the Oist position would be this is a good thing because it’s pro-human life (lower costs involved than in killing them themselves, so more productive).

No, you thoroughly misunderstand Objectivist ethics. You might approach the matter by looking to see what aspect Ayn Rand’s writing would support this conclusion, whereupon you would probably discover how seriously mistaken your conclusion is. We needn’t go further that this and cross the bright line involving humans, who in addition have rights.

No, you thoroughly misunderstand Objectivist ethics. You might approach the matter by looking to see what aspect Ayn Rand’s writing would support this conclusion, whereupon you would probably discover how seriously mistaken your conclusion is. We needn’t go further that this and cross the bright line involving humans, who in addition have rights.

I guess I’m asking why people who have no rational capacity have rights.

In that from everything I read I thought rights were predicated on a rational capacity. I can quote that part if that is what you mean.

Maybe the issue isn’t rights, but morality. I’m trying to find out why/if this is moral.

Here is why I say it:

<a href=“http://www.aynrand.org/site/News2?page=New…ws_iv_ctrl=1084” target=“_blank”>http://www.aynrand.org/site/News2?page=New…ws_iv_ctrl=1084</a>

"How do these advocates try to justify their position? As someone who has debated them for years on college campuses and in the media, I know firsthand that the whole movement is based on a single–invalid–syllogism, namely: men feel pain and have rights; animals feel pain; therefore, animals have rights. "

"This argument is entirely specious, because man’s rights do not depend on his ability to feel pain; they depend on his ability to think. "

Wouldn’t this mean that if a man can’t think at all he has no rights?

Would morality then be different? If we can certainly say a dog would have

no rights and skinning them alive should be legal, then could we say that

morally it’s wrong?

"This argument is entirely specious, because man’s rights do not depend on his ability to feel pain; they depend on his ability to think. "

I thought this made the issue pretty clear.

I think it’s possible you are unintentionally equivocating “man” (as in our species) with “man” (as in a single man). “Man” as in “Man’s rights” to our species and the rights garnered because of our nature as rational beings. A particular man’s capacity for rational thought may be diminished, but his nature is unchanged; he’s still a human being. In the same sense that a child or a baby is incapable of rational thought (to support themselves), you don’t just throw away their rights. While no person is obligated to care for them (necessarily speaking), no person gains the right to treat them as if they are not human or “man” in context of their nature.

Where he says “his”, he’s referring to man collectively as in our species, not a particular man.

I think it’s possible you are unintentionally equivocating “man” (as in our species) with “man” (as in a single man). “Man” as in “Man’s rights” to our species and the rights garnered because of our nature as rational beings. A particular man’s capacity for rational thought may be diminished, but his nature is unchanged; he’s still a human being. In the same sense that a child or a baby is incapable of rational thought (to support themselves), you don’t just throw away their rights. While no person is obligated to care for them (necessarily speaking), no person gains the right to treat them as if they are not human or “man” in context of their nature.

Where he says “his”, he’s referring to man collectively as in our species, not a particular man.

So then regardless if a person has a rational capacity or not they should still get the rights afforded to man, because man has the potential of being rational. Though I can’t see how that really makes sense that makes the distinction clearer.

So essentially if at some point some monkeys evolved to have a decent rational capacity I would assume we would have to treat all them with rights? Or is it based on how a species is as a whole (i.e. since most humans have a rational capacity, all get the rights)?

Thanks, I appreciate your feedback on this.

So essentially if at some point some monkeys evolved to have a decent rational capacity I would assume we would have to treat all them with rights?

Would our theoretical monkeys survival depend on their rational capacity, or would they still depend on their “teeth and claws” to survive?

If the former, my answer would be (in theory) yes. This assumes that their rational capacity does not include taking over the planet though. :dough:

Would our theoretical monkeys survival depend on their rational capacity, or would they still depend on their “teeth and claws” to survive?

If the former, my answer would be (in theory) yes. This assumes that their rational capacity does not include taking over the planet though. :dough:

Haha that’s funny. Monkeys in the work place…

See though it seems that Ayn Rand supports the position that not all humans are given rights, that you do have to have some rational capacity or a possibility of having one to gain rights:

Q: Do severely retarded individuals have rights?

A: Not actual rights–not the same rights possessed by normal individuals. In effect, they have the right to be protected as perennial children. Like children, retarded people are entitled to protection because, as humans, they may improve and become partly able to stand on their own. The protection of their rights is a courtesy extended to them for being human, even if not properly formed ones. But you could not extend the actual exercise of individual rights to a retarded person, because he’s unable to function rationally. Since all rights rest on human nature, a being that cannot exercise his rights cannot have full human rights.

-From Ayn Rand Answers: The Best of her Q&A

It’s a “courtesy extended”?.. that doesn’t really make sense to me

A: Not actual rights–not the same rights possessed by normal individuals. In effect, they have the right to be protected as perennial children. Like children, retarded people are entitled to protection because, as humans, they may improve and become partly able to stand on their own. The protection of their rights is a courtesy extended to them for being human, even if not properly formed ones. But you could not extend the actual exercise of individual rights to a retarded person, because he’s unable to function rationally. Since all rights rest on human nature, a being that cannot exercise his rights cannot have full human rights.

-From Ayn Rand Answers: The Best of her Q&A

It’s a “courtesy extended”?.. that doesn’t really make sense to me

The way I look at this is (to paraphrase Rand a bit too), is that they are treated like children, in that they have rights, but since they cannot exercise them (due to age/retardation) they cannot have all the rights that older or mentally healthy people can, like driving… All humans are to be protected from those that initiate the use of force, whether you are a child, adult, severely mentally retarded, and so forth, because you are a human being.

The way I look at this is (to paraphrase Rand a bit too), is that they are treated like children, in that they have rights, but since they cannot exercise them (due to age/retardation) they cannot have all the rights that older or mentally healthy people can, like driving… All humans are to be protected from those that initiate the use of force, whether you are a child, adult, severely mentally retarded, and so forth, because you are a human being.

What makes human beings so special? As she said they get those rights only because of the possibility of improving. But in a case where we know there is no chance why do they get that right?

THanks

What makes human beings so special? As she said they get those rights only because of the possibility of improving. But in a case where we know there is no chance why do they get that right?

THanks

Don Watkins essay on “broken units” is excellent and I’d highly recommend reading it to anyone here on the board, but I cannot find a link to it, and I do not think it’d be appropriote to quote from it, so I won’t until I do. I have it in one of my Axiomatic magazines, it deals specifically with this matter, if I remember correctly. (at least epistemologically speaking)

In chat tonight, ~Sophia~ pointed us to a post by Don Watkins (aka “DPS”) entitled “The Nature Of Broken Units, What are they and why does it matter?” on OO.Net at <a href=“http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.php?showtopic=1099” target=“_blank”>http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.php?showtopic=1099</a>

I think this essay sheds some light on this issue.

In chat tonight, Sophia pointed us to a post by Don Watkins “DPS” entitled " The Nature Of Broken Units, What are they and why does it matter?" on OO.Net at http://forum.ObjectivismOnline.com/index.php?showtopic=1099

I think this essay sheds some light on this issue.

THAT’S IT!!!

Don Watkins essay on “broken units” is excellent and I’d highly recommend reading it to anyone here on the board, but I cannot find a link to it, and I do not think it’d be appropriote to quote from it, so I won’t until I do. I have it in one of my Axiomatic magazines, it deals specifically with this matter, if I remember correctly. (at least epistemologically speaking)

That article actually makes my entire point for me. Here is a quote (thanks for Old Toad for finding the quote)

“A brainless baby, on the other hand, has no rights, because rights follow from the characteristic which, in him, is broken, i.e., non-existent – a rational faculty.”

This is my entire point

That article actually makes my entire point for me. Here is a quote (thanks for Old Toad for finding the quote)

“A brainless baby, on the other hand, has no rights, because rights follow from the characteristic which, in him, is broken, i.e., non-existent – a rational faculty.”

This article makes my entire point for me. I’ll quote him right back at you with this:

“This objection can be refuted very simply: by pointing out that in raising the objection, one concedes that we are able to identify the brainless baby as a baby.”

A brainless baby, can’t think, which it’s supposed to be able to. A baby born deaf, is still a baby, one that can’t hear like it should be able to. These are instances of “broken units” which does not change the definition of what a baby is, or a human being as such. As Watkins says: “A broken unit, in other words, is one that lacks a characteristic it should have but doesn’t.” A baby should be able to hear or think, by virtue of being a baby qua human being, but it lacks a particular characteristic, but that characteristic isn’t the only one that make it a human being.

(edit to add: fatdogs, your point had to do with retardation, not brainlessness.)

This article makes my entire point for me. I’ll quote him right back at you with this:

“This objection can be refuted very simply: by pointing out that in raising the objection, one concedes that we are able to identify the brainless baby as a baby.”

A brainless baby, can’t think, which it’s supposed to be able to. A baby born deaf, is still a baby, one that can’t hear like it should be able to. These are instances of “broken units” which does not change the definition of what a baby is, or a human being as such. As Watkins says: “A broken unit, in other words, is one that lacks a characteristic it should have but doesn’t.” A baby should be able to hear or think, by virtue of being a baby qua human being, but it lacks a particular characteristic, but that characteristic isn’t the only one that make it a human being.

So because something ‘should’ be something but isn’t it gets rights? I don’t see that point making any sense.

Why should something be given just because it “should” have that?

That’s a pretty strange dichotomy to me.

It might still be a human being, Fatdogs isn’t discrediting that, but why does it gain rights on virtue of being human? Rights are meant to protect man’s mode of survival, but someone with no conceptual faculty, or one diminished beyond use, would have no mode of survival, let alone a rational one.

Reading through this, I’m siding with Fatdogs as well, because I thought rights were given to all men, on the presumption that they can only survive by reason - not because they are bi-pedal, 20-digited, opposable thumbed (etc) creatures, born of previous bi-pedal, 20-digited, opposable thumbed (etc) creatures.

So because something ‘should’ be something but isn’t it gets rights?

No, because it IS something that it gets rights; a human being. Whether or not a person can excercise them is a different issue, whether or not they contain any broken units is a different issue. The fact is they are born a human being and by our defintion of human being, they are whether as a baby or as an adult, a deaf baby or a severely retarded adult, but have different rights due to age/maturity/developmental differences, but all are protected by virtue of being a human being.

Reading through this, I’m siding with Fatdogs as well, because I thought rights were given to all men, on the presumption that they can only survive by reason[…]

No, they are upon birth, upon becoming an actual human being. Whether or not or to what extent they can excercise their rights, is a separate issue.

No, because it IS something that it gets rights; a human being. Whether or not a person can excercise them is a different issue, whether or not they contain any broken units is a different issue. The fact is they are born a human being and by our defintion of human being, they are whether as a baby or as an adult, a deaf baby or a severely retarded adult, but have different rights due to age/maturity/developmental differences, but all are protected by virtue of being a human being.

This really doesn’t follow. We are protected by virtue of being a human being… That seems to be the answer, but there doesn’t seem to be a reason why they should be protected. Meaning simply: Why are human beings granted the rights they are to begin with? If they are granted these rights because of because they look the same, breath the same and move around then they are being granted rights which have nothing to do with their ability. As Tenure says I thought rights are meant to protect man’s mode of survival…

I guess in this case they are just handed out to those who don’t have that basic thing that sets man apart from things like dogs, cats and everything else.

No, because it IS something that it gets rights; a human being. Whether or not a person can excercise them is a different issue, whether or not they contain any broken units is a different issue. The fact is they are born a human being and by our defintion of human being, they are whether as a baby or as an adult, a deaf baby or a severely retarded adult, but have different rights due to age/maturity/developmental differences, but all are protected by virtue of being a human being.

But why? Why does a human being have rights?

And you’re putting up a false analogy by talking about deaf babies. A human’s fundamental method of survival isn’t his hearing – it’s his conceptual faculty, his reasoning ability. If you take that away, what exactly do rights mean to him?

As for a child, I can understand a child having reduced rights, because whilst it doesn’t yet have mature mental faculties (something we can argue, biologically, a human doesn’t have until about 20 years old), it still does possess the rational faculity, and that faculty will still grow (barring interference or accident - but then we don’t live our lives based on the premise that something bad like that will happen).