Who determined that animals don’t have volition? What sources did they use? Who’s research to back it up? This is the one area of Objectivism that I vehemently disagree on. Every animal I’ve ever known has used volition, and since that is a defining character of the rights idea, I believe animals have rights. I will agree that plants do not have volition, and therefor have no rights.
The definitions you gave for volition are not the same ones used in Objectivism. None of those concepts logically lead to rights. The concept that does is: the ability to regulate one’s level of awareness, which is what Objectivists mean when they use the term “volition.” Remember, it’s not the word “volition,” which has different meanings in different contexts, that’s important here; it’s the concept it refers to within the context of Objectivism.
You’re absolutely right, but isn’t this definition of volition a man made definition?
Of course it is. They all are.
If I took time to really empathize with a dog instead of looking at it with Benign bewilderment, wouldn’t I realize that my dog is actually thinking, and he is trying to tell me that with his eyes? You who have pets might know what I’m talking about.
I have had pets, and I know what you’re talking about, but it’s not thinking. To suppose that it is thinking, without any evidence of conceptual activity, would be anthropomorphizing.
So what, exactly, is it when my dog “chooses” one toy over another when playing by himself? What is it, exactly, when he “chooses” to curl up on the couch with my wife and I, or “choose” to lay on the floor? When the cat “decides” to play, or “chooses” which toy to play with? I’m sorry, but I disagree, while even limited in scope, animals have MANY volitional choices.
I’ve already addressed this in my response about definitions. In many contexts, one might call it “volition,” but in those contexts, it does not refer to the concept that gives rise to rights.
And in your first paragraph, man cannot choose not to think, just as an animal cannot choose not to think. Choosing not to make a choice IS making a choice.
It’s not a binary think/don’t think choice. I don’t think it’s possible for a normal human being to completely shut of his conceptual faculty and engage in no thought whatsoever, but we can regulate the level at which is operates. This is the key distinction between us and animals.
Someone earlier asked where it had been proven that animals cannot think (I’m not going back and re-reading everything to find it). I want to issue a reminder that one cannot prove the non-existence of anything, so the onus of proof is on anyone who makes the positive claim that animals can use concepts. I am extremely open to evidence on this issue, as I think it would be a fantastic thing to discover a conceptual faculty in another species (I don’t doubt that evolution will take some of the other apes down that road, eventually).