Eating Meat and Animal Rights

vo·li·tion ( P ) Pronunciation Key (v-lshn)

n.

The act or an instance of making a conscious choice or decision.

A conscious choice or decision.

The power or faculty of choosing; the will.

Who determined that animals don’t have volition? What sources did they use? Who’s research to back it up? This is the one area of Objectivism that I vehemently disagree on. Every animal I’ve ever known has used volition, and since that is a defining character of the rights idea, I believe animals have rights. I will agree that plants do not have volition, and therefor have no rights.

Styles, if you carefully read dondigitalia’s posts above, you’ll note that man is the only being with a volitional and conceptual consciousness. In other words, we can choose whether or not to think and we also have the ability to form concepts, which other life forms do not. It is from these attributes that our rights are derived.

I think most O’ists would agree that many animals make limited “choices” (if you want to call them that). I suppose a salmon “chooses” to swim upstream, rather than downstream, to spawn. A dog chooses to roll over on it’s back when you whistle because it has been conditioned to expect a treat after it performs that behavior. However, the choices these animals make are based on instinct or biological factors that are designed to ensure their continued existence and/or the continuation of the species. This is quite different from having a volitional and conceptual consciousness, as man does.

This is quite different from having a volitional and conceptual consciousness, as man does.

And, as a result, animals do not have rights. Do I need to point out that the concept “animal rights” is a bromide which wipes out the concept of human rights.

Animals are beasts. Simple as that. They do not posess the ability to recognize human rights. If they can’t, by their very nature, respect our rights, then they cannot be said to posess rights of their own.

If you carefully read dondigitalia’s posts above, you’ll note that man is the only being with a volitional and conceptual consciousness.

You’re absolutely right, but isn’t this definition of volition a man made definition? Some guy thought that up, and although it sounds perfectly feasible enough to be accepted by the entire contemporary world, is my doubting it any less valid if I come up with reasons why it may be valid to put it up for examination? You can’t deny that as intelligent as you think we are, a million years from now, our future race wouldn’t even so much as raise an eyebrow to any idea we find profound. We are obsolete minds, even though there is no superior race to compare us to, there will be, and very well can be. I believe that lots of what we think we know as facts, are just things that are accepted for the meantime. I don’t mean all things, that would be a ridiculous statement, but much of what we know though pure observation has got to be thrown to the can eventually. Just like 100 years ago, perfectly educated contemporaries didn’t know what the hell was going on. You might know more than them, but truth certainly doesn’t stop with your lifetime.

Like all animals, we only communicate among our species, with Only other humans. Likewise, birds only communicate with other birds, and rhinos spend their time with each other, and no one else. Even ants work together, and have no inclination to develop a form of understanding with different insects. In fact, most animals and insects that find themselves walking into a member of another species, feel nothing but a sense of physical threat, obviously they have no intention to build a bridge of communication between each other. And if there is no threat, you still can’t communicate with them above an emotional level. They are hardwired differently, two totally different things.

I think most O’ists would agree that many animals make limited “choices” (if you want to call them that). I suppose a salmon “chooses” to swim upstream, rather than downstream, to spawn. A dog chooses to roll over on it’s back when you whistle because it has been conditioned to expect a treat after it performs that behavior.

If I took time to really empathize with a dog instead of looking at it with Benign bewilderment, wouldn’t I realize that my dog is actually thinking, and he is trying to tell me that with his eyes? You who have pets might know what I’m talking about.

a million years from now, our future race wouldn’t even so much as raise an eyebrow to any idea we find profound.

But regardless of this, we remain rational and volitional beings, which therefore posess rights. If those future beings were smart enough to be Objectivists, they would recognize our rights, no matter how “slow” we are in comparison.

What you’re missing is that our volitional, conceptual consciousness makes us fundamentally different from every other creature on earth. We’re not just smarter; we’re a complete paradigm shift.

In fact, most animals and insects that find themselves walking into a member of another species, feel nothing but a sense of physical threat, obviously they have no intention to build a bridge of communication between each other. And if there is no threat, you still can’t communicate with them above an emotional level. They are hardwired differently, two totally different things.

How can you recognize this fact without realizing that the logical conclusion is that since animals cannot be reasoned with, they must be dealt with by force.? That is the inescapable conclusion!

Please please please please don’t start this discussion. It’s just not worth it. Just leave it at this (unless of course I’ve grossly mischaracterized the Objectivist position, which is not unlikely):

Man is capable of such powerful cognitive processes that his instincts become subject to evaluation before they are enacted. This is, as far as we know, a uniquely human process.

Therefore, while all other creatures that we are aware of act solely based on their brains’ biological programming, human brains are set up in such a way that they perceive biologically linked drives (emotions) differently. Humans self evaluate before acting, and thus they possess the ability to choose not to perform an action.

Because of this, humans can be held to a higher standard of morality. The systems approach in communication and social ontological theory describes this idea in this way: humans have agency for their actions, but are influenced by social constructions.

Because of the law of non-contradiction, no entity can claim a “right” for itself that it does not recognize for others. Because animals do not enter into the systems created by man, they can not reap the benefits that those systems allow. In other words, animals can not demand or recognize rights any more than we can stop our knee from jerking when it’s hit with a mallet.

So we eat them.

How can you recognize this fact without realizing that the logical conclusion is that since animals cannot be reasoned with, they must be dealt with by force.? That is the inescapable conclusion!

I’m disagreeing with this “logical conclusion”, I think it is more of an accepted belief. I’m not eager to argue the point, but I thought I explained my take on exactly what you are implying somewhere in my post, if you want to look through it.

I’m disagreeing with this “logical conclusion”, I think it is more of an accepted belief. I’m not eager to argue the point, but I thought I explained my take on exactly what you are implying somewhere in my post, if you want to look through it.

I don’t see any arguments in your post that disprove my statement, but that’s fine because the debate forum would be the place for such things. It is clearly the postion of Objectivism that animals do not posess rights.

If you’re not eager to argue the point, then that’s fine. Good day to you. If you change your mind, there is the debate forum, but please do not post any more anti-Objectivist arguments here.

How can you recognize this fact without realizing that the logical conclusion is that since animals cannot be reasoned with, they must be dealt with by force.? That is the inescapable conclusion!

Volition is the source of rights, and animals have no volition, and therefore no rights.

Force is the negation of volition. Since animals have no volition, there is no such thing as “force” in dealing with animals. What we use in dealing with animals is not properly called force. It is simply another means of man shaping and using nature in order to suit his needs, like digging up ore to make steel. Perhaps a better term for it would be “processing”. Ore needs the process of being dug up in order to further man’s life. Animals need the process of being raised and harvested in order to further man’s life.

Force is the negation of volition. Since animals have no volition, there is no such thing as “force” in dealing with animals.

Hmm, I don’t think I agree with that statement. Force is not defined simply as the negation of volition. It does in fact negate volition if there is any. But force means simply “the use of physical force” and so it is fine the way I said it.

Now, of course, you are right about the rest.

How can you recognize this fact without realizing that the logical conclusion is that since animals cannot be reasoned with, they must be dealt with by force.? That is the inescapable conclusion!

Is there any evidence to prove animals can not be reasoned with? I believe the only evidence available to us states in some form or another, that “We do not know how to reason with animals.” That sounds like a bit more suitable suggestion. And still, I would even narrow that down to a more acceptable statement: “Most people do not know how to reason with animals.”

On an atomic scale, our brains are relatively the same size as a birds. Perceptively, taking the entire universe into consideration, our brains could be inseparable in size from our entire planet. The vast irrelevance to size in this universe, and I just can’t imagine that the small difference in our brain sizes makes the difference between Big thinking, and No thinking.

If you observed the agent Egyptians building a pyramid looking from the sky, would you see any difference in looking at ants, collectively building a triangular prism of an ant farm, obviously disinterested in anything outside of the purpose at hand. They might even go so far as to worship a queen, while having little thoughts about what life actually entails. The thing that separates these souls from human souls is they can’t speak English. So go out and buy some raid, they’ll accept their deaths as a fierce striking of the two legged gods. But how could they possibly believe humans are gods? Maybe the same way the Egyptians believe animals were gods.

…there is the debate forum, …

Good idea. Interested in starting a debate about animals Jon P. If so, check out the debate sub-forum, propose the subject for debate and your position and see if someone will take the other side of the argument.

Styles, if you carefully read dondigitalia’s posts above, you’ll note that man is the only being with a volitional and conceptual consciousness. In other words, we can choose whether or not to think and we also have the ability to form concepts, which other life forms do not. It is from these attributes that our rights are derived.

I think most O’ists would agree that many animals make limited “choices” (if you want to call them that). I suppose a salmon “chooses” to swim upstream, rather than downstream, to spawn. A dog chooses to roll over on it’s back when you whistle because it has been conditioned to expect a treat after it performs that behavior. However, the choices these animals make are based on instinct or biological factors that are designed to ensure their continued existence and/or the continuation of the species. This is quite different from having a volitional and conceptual consciousness, as man does.

So what, exactly, is it when my dog “chooses” one toy over another when playing by himself? What is it, exactly, when he “chooses” to curl up on the couch with my wife and I, or “choose” to lay on the floor? When the cat “decides” to play, or “chooses” which toy to play with? I’m sorry, but I disagree, while even limited in scope, animals have MANY volitional choices.

And in your first paragraph, man cannot choose not to think, just as an animal cannot choose not to think. Choosing not to make a choice IS making a choice.

Jon, I will not sanction your violation of the rules by responding to that last post. Was any part of what I said unclear?

(mods feel free to delete this post if you delete Jon’s…)

There comes a point in the life of a thread where the discussion shifts from the topic to “meta-issue” of whether the topic ought to be discussed, etc. I think this thread needs a breather, so I’ll close it for a while. Meanwhile, if a couple of people want to start a debate in the debate sub-forum, amen. [meaty-issue –> meta-issue]

Is there any evidence to prove animals can not be reasoned with?

Here you are asking for proof of a negative – and then using the lack of such proof to traffic in the arbitrary. The proper approach is to ask if there is any evidence that animals other than man can operate at the conceptual level. I have heard of no such evidence.

So what, exactly, is it when my dog “chooses” one toy over another when playing by himself? What is it, exactly, when he “chooses” to curl up on the couch with my wife and I, or “choose” to lay on the floor? When the cat “decides” to play, or “chooses” which toy to play with? I’m sorry, but I disagree, while even limited in scope, animals have MANY volitional choices.

Volition and choice are not identical. Volition refers to man’s ability to choose to operate at the conceptual level, i.e. to invoke his faculty of reason and engage in a process of thought. Lower animals have the ability to choose among alternatives – but there is no evidence that they ever move beyond the perceptual level.

Who determined that animals don’t have volition? What sources did they use? Who’s research to back it up? This is the one area of Objectivism that I vehemently disagree on. Every animal I’ve ever known has used volition, and since that is a defining character of the rights idea, I believe animals have rights. I will agree that plants do not have volition, and therefor have no rights.

The definitions you gave for volition are not the same ones used in Objectivism. None of those concepts logically lead to rights. The concept that does is: the ability to regulate one’s level of awareness, which is what Objectivists mean when they use the term “volition.” Remember, it’s not the word “volition,” which has different meanings in different contexts, that’s important here; it’s the concept it refers to within the context of Objectivism.

You’re absolutely right, but isn’t this definition of volition a man made definition?

Of course it is. They all are.

If I took time to really empathize with a dog instead of looking at it with Benign bewilderment, wouldn’t I realize that my dog is actually thinking, and he is trying to tell me that with his eyes? You who have pets might know what I’m talking about.

I have had pets, and I know what you’re talking about, but it’s not thinking. To suppose that it is thinking, without any evidence of conceptual activity, would be anthropomorphizing.

So what, exactly, is it when my dog “chooses” one toy over another when playing by himself? What is it, exactly, when he “chooses” to curl up on the couch with my wife and I, or “choose” to lay on the floor? When the cat “decides” to play, or “chooses” which toy to play with? I’m sorry, but I disagree, while even limited in scope, animals have MANY volitional choices.

I’ve already addressed this in my response about definitions. In many contexts, one might call it “volition,” but in those contexts, it does not refer to the concept that gives rise to rights.

And in your first paragraph, man cannot choose not to think, just as an animal cannot choose not to think. Choosing not to make a choice IS making a choice.

It’s not a binary think/don’t think choice. I don’t think it’s possible for a normal human being to completely shut of his conceptual faculty and engage in no thought whatsoever, but we can regulate the level at which is operates. This is the key distinction between us and animals.

Someone earlier asked where it had been proven that animals cannot think (I’m not going back and re-reading everything to find it). I want to issue a reminder that one cannot prove the non-existence of anything, so the onus of proof is on anyone who makes the positive claim that animals can use concepts. I am extremely open to evidence on this issue, as I think it would be a fantastic thing to discover a conceptual faculty in another species (I don’t doubt that evolution will take some of the other apes down that road, eventually).

Here you are asking for proof of a negative – and then using the lack of such proof to traffic in the arbitrary. The proper approach is to ask if there is any evidence that animals other than man can operate at the conceptual level. I have heard of no such evidence.

The proof is in the pudding. Thinking in conceptual form - would you say that this can only be done in the form of words, spoken aloud in some form of human language? Or can conceptual thinking be formed in your mind, without language? If a bird makes a nest, wouldn’t you say that the bird is actually forming in reality, his idea of nest building? Or does he need to be able to discuss his ideas to be considered conceptual? Maybe he does discuss his ideas with other birds, with his body language, and intricite chirps. And he learned these things using the same form of language.

And so the question remains, must an animal speak a language that uses vocalized words, that require human lung capacity to be considered alive? They have two eyes, a heart, and a pair of breathing lungs, just like us. Since when did only humans have receptive ends to their eyeballs, while the other animals just connected to nothing?

Jon P, Wouldn’t you marvel at a human being who can spin a thin web the way a spider does? And, if nobody had ever spoken to that human being, wouldn’t that be even more spectacular. I think it would be unbelievable for a human child to whom nobody has ever spoken, to up and spin a web. [This example is borrowed from Charlotte’s Web, by E.B.White]

Would you conclude (not argue hypothetically, but really conclude to yourself) that human beings are intellectually inferior to spiders, or to dolphins, or migratory birds? If you do not think it is possible to determine which species is intellectually superior, then – in what way are they different?

BTW: Here are some related threads (link #1) and (link #2) and (link #3)

Jon P, Wouldn’t you marvel at a human being who can spin a thin web the way a spider does? And, if nobody had ever spoken to that human being, wouldn’t that be even more spectacular. I think it would be unbelievable for a human child to whom nobody has ever spoken, to up and spin a web. [This example is borrowed from Charlotte’s Web, by E.B.White]

Yes, that would all be very surprising.

That whole idea is a stumper, and would really seem to diminish some of my hocus pocus beliefs. But, babies wouldn’t weave symmetrical webs in the first place because they don’t have the body designed for it. The spider does however. It also has eight eyes, and uses them to calculate the “web design” process. You can’t deny that this creature is actually using its brain.

Would you conclude (not argue hypothetically, but really conclude to yourself) that human beings are intellectually inferior to spiders, or to dolphins, or migratory birds? If you do not think it is possible to determine which species is intellectually superior, then – in what way are they different?

No. But, if evolution responds to animals who flourish to natural habitats by giving them super learning intelligence that differs from their distant ancestors slow learning, but “conceptual” intelligence, I don’t see why either wouldn’t have the ability to think at the very least, in reasoning form.

BTW: Here are some related threads (link #1) and (link #2) and (link #3)

I’ll check these out.