I take something of a Nietzschean stance on this question.
First of all, if we aren’t supposed to eat animals, then why are they made out of meat?
Second, the cruelty doesn’t matter at all. By our evolution and our nature, we are hunters. I take pride in my nature as a predatory ape, and relish in the fact that a genetically engineered bovine died for the juicy hamburger that I’m eating. (If you don’t buy the “genetically entineered” bit, ask yourself why cows are different from buffalo, and what “domesticate” really means. It’s eugenics, baby, yeah!)
We are the master species of this planet, and have a right - nay, a DUTY - to eat everything and anything tasty that doesn’t posess a conceptual consciousness. If you can’t do math, you’re food. (Sometimes I think that perhaps the world would be a bit better if this principle were applied to homo sapiens as well…
) Who cares whether or not they can suffer? They can’t talk. Eat them.
A proper morality is not based on suffering, but on a rational being’s right to pursue happiness. Suffering doesn’t enter into the equation. Even if a human were suffering, I may help him out of generousity, but I am not morally bound to do so. And if a pig or a cow suffers? Who cares? They’re tasty, they’re not people and they’re not pets - that makes them food.
Certainly, this is not to say that causing suffering to an animal for no reason is a good thing. That is most often indicative of an obsessive fixation on suffering and death, which is not healthy. It’s the same obsessive fixation that leads people to altruistic vegetarianism, and perhaps that is why they always throw the dog-torture argument at us omnivores. They cannot conceive of a benevolence or a morality that is based on life and happiness, rather than death and suffering.
If refraining from eating meat makes you happy and healthy and all that, great, do it. But that’s a matter of preference quite outside the scope of philosophy.
Don’t try to tell me that eating meat is immoral, or I’ll eat you.