A person holds a concept without a necessary distinction as a result of lack of knowledge.
…
As I reread number two, I recall that in ITOE Rand wrote something to the effect that a concept as held by two individuals, if properly integrated, holds no contradictions and only differs in scope.
If I hold a concept with some lack of knowledge, and if I have integrated it correctly, am I really in error?
You might be, but don’t be thinking that errors are evil. Evasion is what’s evil. Peikoff’s discussion of “certainty” in OPAR helps to make this point clear – quoting from p. 179:
A conclusion is “certain” when the evidence in its favor is conclusive; i.e., when it has been logically validated. At this stage, one has gone beyond “substantial” evidence. Rather, the total of the available evidence points in a single direction, and this evidence fulfills the standard of proof. In such a context, there is nothing to suggest even the possibility of another interpretation. There are, therefore, no longer any grounds for doubt.
My favorite concrete example is crow color. There are two basic facts which you have to know to evaluate the claim “all crows are black”, and while I think most educated people know the first fact, many do not know the second. Namely, coloration in animals is often determined by species, and there is more than one species of crow. In my older uninformed days, I could conclude – in error – that all crows are black. In fact, I must conclude that, because I was in possession of no knowledge whatsoever that casts doubt on the black crow conclusion. To deny the conclusion on the grounds “maybe I am mistaken” is the same kind of appeal to the arbitrary that allows skeptics to generally deny that we can have knowledge. However, once I know that there are dozens of species of crow, say goodbye to certainty (and a few months in East Africa really drives that point home since the predominate species of crow in the areas I was in is black and white).
The particular conclusion that all crows are black is in error, but it was arrived at by proper use of logic. The empirical factor that tripped you up was the fact that you didn’t know of species variation in crows (in contrast to lions and polar bears).
In fact, I must conclude that, because I was in possession of no knowledge whatsoever that casts doubt on the black crow conclusion
But couldn’t have you said to yourself, “Since many, if not all other animals I have observed come in different colors, and even though all crows I have observed have been black, I cannot conclude that all crows are black.” Or would that be an arbitrary claim? (obviously the extent of your knowledge in terms of animals and species and what not is important, but I’m just throwing a possible example to see if it would be arbitrary).
How many crows must one observe before he can be certain that all crows are black, white, or a mixture of many colors?
But couldn’t have you said to yourself, “Since many, if not all other animals I have observed come in different colors, and even though all crows I have observed have been black, I cannot conclude that all crows are black.” Or would that be an arbitrary claim? (obviously the extent of your knowledge in terms of animals and species and what not is important, but I’m just throwing a possible example to see if it would be arbitrary).
Given that (for the purposes of this discussion) you’re aware of the relation between morphology and species, and given your observations of variable species such as dogs, cats and cows, then with a “large enough N” where all observed crows are black, if all crows are a single species, you have to conclude that this is a valid law (even if you can’t identify the exact genetic mechanism behind it). Large N is really a cheap substitute for knowing that other factors are not relevant (such as environment or family genetics); if you’d like a free number, I like the number 20, but again that kind of extrapolation isn’t valid unless you have a random sample. In lieu of which, I tend to like 100.
Let me strongly recommend the last lecture of Peikoff’s Understanding Objectivism course for a more detailed treatment of inherently dishonest ideas. The category never made any sense to me whatsoever until I heard that lecture. I suspect that others will find it illuminating.
An idea is inherently dishonest if it cannot be believed, when fully understood, because it is clearly inconsistent with everyone’s experience of reality. Thus anyone who advocates it in a seemingly coherent way must be a hypocrite and a liar.
I have heard it defined as a concept that is ‘so in conflict with reality’ that it would not have been possible to arrive at it as a result of an ‘honest error’ but only as a result of evasion. Concepts such as ‘Marxism’, ‘Slavery’, ect.
The problem is that it is not clear how to qualify a concept as ‘so in conflict with reality.’
Why would you want to qualify such a statement? If an idea is inherently dishonest, what would be the point of trying to look for a way to create an exception, so as to excuse some particular dishonest statement?
qualify – v.i.
…
to attribute some quality or qualities to; characterize, call, or name.
to modify or limit in some way; make less strong or positive.
…
I think that DavidOdden misunderstood Proverb.
Proverb was using sense 2 of “qualify”. He wanted to know what one needs to check to determine whether a concept is “so in conflict with reality” as to constitute an inherently dishonest idea.
DavidOdden thought Proverb meant sense 3 of “qualify” – what can one do to weaken the concept of inherently dishonest ideas for some unknown purpose.
An idea is inherently dishonest if it cannot be believed, when fully understood, because it is clearly inconsistent with everyone’s experience of reality. Thus anyone who advocates it in a seemingly coherent way must be a hypocrite and a liar.
Wasnt Ayn Rand good friends with a postitivist and a Marxist? Would she have classified them as hypocrits and liars?
… the last lecture of Peikoff’s Understanding Objectivism course for a more detailed treatment of inherently dishonest ideas.
Diana, Thanks for bringing this to my attention. For those who have not listened to the UO tapes, I add my strong recommendation to the ones that have been made elsewhere in the forum. Audio material is much more expensive than books, but – within the genre of Objectivist audio-material – UO would be my top-most choice.
In my mind, the archetype of an inherently evil idea is the idea that reality does not exist. Still, that does not mean everyone who supports such an idea is evil. From time to time, we’ve had people come to this forum and say that reality does not exist. Two examples I remember are members named AllenAtsea and ArvindIn. Both say “reality does not exist”. However, if one finds their posts and compares them, one will find that AllenAtsea really appears to be saying: “I don’t know how to prove that reality exists, so I have to assume it’s just a belief that I have and that I cannot challenge someone who says it doesn’t”, while ArvindIn is saying “I’ve studied this a lot and read all the literature and only someone who is stupid would think that reality exists.” Online posts are not the best way to judge a person’s ethics. However, even with the limited information in this example (read the posts if you really want to understand) one can see that the two people are at different “levels of morality” as of the date of posting.
When it comes to judging the person rather than the idea, one has to take into account more than just the idea. One has to take into account their experience and information, their age (as a proxy for the previous), and their level of commitment to the idea.
To take a single example from the UO lecture: Dr. Peikoff mentions that many religious people are not evil, even though an Objectivist might wonder: how can anyone honestly believe in the existence of God.
If someone were deliberately and consistently avoiding certain topics of conversation (religion most often comes to mind) for reasons stated such as “in my experience there is no point to discuss such matters”, or “nothing good can come out of it”, or “such discussions should be avoided and I refuse to consider the matter any more” etc., either as a result of mentioning the topics or a few lines of conversations exchanged that made them feel uneasy about their position, could this be considered evasion, and more so, moral cowardice?
If someone were deliberately and consistently avoiding certain topics of conversation (religion most often comes to mind) for reasons stated such as “in my experience there is no point to discuss such matters”, or “nothing good can come out of it”, or “such discussions should be avoided and I refuse to consider the matter any more” etc., either as a result of mentioning the topics or a few lines of conversations exchanged that made them feel uneasy about their position, could this be considered evasion, and more so, moral cowardice?
It might mean that, but it might not. Personally, I know there are a few topics that I have discussed quite a bit over the years with various people, and most of the time I have no inclination to discuss them again. Of course if the other person was someone to whom I thought I owed some type of explanation – even if just because of a friendship, it would be different. So, I think an important piece of additional information would be: what is the relationship between the two people in your example, and – based on that relationship – should the person do something more than refuse to discuss it.
Essentially, saying “_ I won’t discuss this" is not the same as saying to oneself "I will refuse to think about this _”.
Well, the relationship is an old one, of friendship, and the conversation usually flows quite well, until certain topics are reached, where the above mentioned occurs.
The person usually has a good sense of life, but it appears in some areas, was cornered by early childhood’s experiences and societal constraints.
Without knowing the reasons for your friends evasion of the discussion, it is impossible to infer whether he is evading in fact, in his mind, or not. However, the fact that he is evading the discussion is clearly a red flag, as you noted. While it is possible that evasion of the discussion is based on good, rational, reason; and it is further possible that he has a good, rational reason for not telling you the reason he is evading the discussion; it is far more likely that he is evading the topics in fact, i.e., in his mind.
If he won’t discuss, and won’t tell you a good reason why not, then you are stuck.
Maybe try getting him out of his usual state of mind and try for more intimate discussion then.