God: The Failed Hypothesis. How Science Shows That God Does Not Exist

Many authors claim that modern science supports the proposition that God exists, but very few authors have directly challenged this assertion. Physicist Victor J. Stenger points out that if scientific arguments for the existence of God are included in intellectual, not to mention political discourse, then arguments against his existence should also be considered.

In God: The Failed Hypothesis, Stenger argues that science has advanced sufficiently to make a definitive statement on the existence — or nonexistence — of the traditional Judeo-Christian-Islamic God. He invites readers to put their minds and the scientific method to work to test this claim.

The author has a summary of arguments online.

Just read it.

Even though I agree with the conclusion his arguments really didn’t satisfy me. Too much left unsaid I think.

I have to agree, I’m not particularly impressed with any of the arguments I skimmed over.

What did he leave out exactly? A glaring endorsement of Objectivism?

What did he leave out exactly? A glaring endorsement of Objectivism?

No, for me it’s just that it seems a little too condense (or abridged) for a nutritional read. Good quality in bad quantity.

Though I do greatly like his thought experiment with God and boulder.

The god-boulder thing is very old–and he actually mentions it as a logical argument against God (correct) but then goes on to say he’s got all this scientific evidence against God. Unfortunately his scientific evidence turns out to be mostly assertions that other physicists have the evidence, without even a satisfactory popular explanation of what it actually is. The whole book is a series of handwaves even at the popularization of science level.

Here’s an illustration of the “balance” of evidence.

What did he leave out exactly?

To start with, you can’t have a scientific argument that god doesn’t exist, because it’s an empirically untestable claim. If somebody were to set for a specific scientific argument that god exists, then you could counter that argument on scientific grounds. But given what is asserted to be god’s nature, it would be impossible to verify or refute the claim that he exists, so the question is completely outside the domain of science. In fact, he doesn’t give scientific arguments, he gives quasi-philosophical arguments, following a traditional “sequence of sentences” approach to constructing arguments that is common in philosophy. Such arguments often crash because there is some arbitrarily injected assertion that is anywhere from questionable to flat out false. So his “An All-Virtuous Being Cannot Exist” argument has the stem “But virtue involves overcoming pains and danger”. Well, shucks, that’s just crapdoodle, and the rest of the argument hinges on that bunch of miserable nonsense. Then you move on to the next “argument” where he asserts “If any being is God, he must be a fitting object of worship”. I don’t know where that came from. Imagine that Eric Cartman is god. So you get to his next line, “No being could possibly be a fitting object of worship, since worship requires the abandonment of one’s role as an autonomous moral agent.” He sorta skipped the step where he showed that being a fitting object of worship means that you demand that all of your worshipers be autonomous in their moral judgments and not refer to any fact outside of the worshiper’s mind. [Consider what Objectivists “worship” – objective values. If god were an objective value that could be recognised by any rational being, recognizing that value would not be an abandonment of one’s moral autonomy. It would furthermore not diminish your objective value if you were to expect others to recognize your value].

Number 3: “The attributes of God are not consistent with the existence of evil.” Sez who? Number 4: “If a being is perfect, then whatever he creates must be perfect.” Sez who? (“If a being is a mammal, then whatever he creates must be a mammal”). The web page is sufficiently disappointing that Steve’s disrecommendation wasn’t necessary to persuade me to spend my money on a new thumb drive, instead.

Here’s an illustration of the “balance” of evidence.

Heh…I saw that this morning too. Very awesome, I love XKCD.

To start with, you can’t have a scientific argument that god doesn’t exist, because it’s an empirically untestable claim. If somebody were to set for a specific scientific argument that god exists, then you could counter that argument on scientific grounds. But given what is asserted to be god’s nature, it would be impossible to verify or refute the claim that he exists, so the question is completely outside the domain of science. In fact, he doesn’t give scientific arguments, he gives quasi-philosophical arguments, following a traditional “sequence of sentences” approach to constructing arguments that is common in philosophy. Such arguments often crash because there is some arbitrarily injected assertion that is anywhere from questionable to flat out false. So his “An All-Virtuous Being Cannot Exist” argument has the stem “But virtue involves overcoming pains and danger”. Well, shucks, that’s just crapdoodle, and the rest of the argument hinges on that bunch of miserable nonsense. Then you move on to the next “argument” where he asserts “If any being is God, he must be a fitting object of worship”. I don’t know where that came from. Imagine that Eric Cartman is god. So you get to his next line, “No being could possibly be a fitting object of worship, since worship requires the abandonment of one’s role as an autonomous moral agent.” He sorta skipped the step where he showed that being a fitting object of worship means that you demand that all of your worshipers be autonomous in their moral judgments and not refer to any fact outside of the worshiper’s mind. [Consider what Objectivists “worship” – objective values. If god were an objective value that could be recognised by any rational being, recognizing that value would not be an abandonment of one’s moral autonomy. It would furthermore not diminish your objective value if you were to expect others to recognize your value].

Number 3: “The attributes of God are not consistent with the existence of evil.” Sez who? Number 4: “If a being is perfect, then whatever he creates must be perfect.” Sez who? (“If a being is a mammal, then whatever he creates must be a mammal”). The web page is sufficiently disappointing that Steve’s disrecommendation wasn’t necessary to persuade me to spend my money on a new thumb drive, instead.

Oh okay, all that stuff makes sense. While we are on the subject you seem to have a lot of knowledge of, what are some God sources about scientific arguements and God, or arguements for atheism etc etc…?

I’ve read God Delusion, and I like the whole “Too improbable to care about” thing, but I still feel like there are better arguements out there.

In the case of a god who, it is claimed, is omnipotent (such as the Xian god) you actually run into a logical paradox you cannot resolve without ditching the “omnipotent” label.

“Can God create a rock so heavy God cannot lift it?”

Omniscience leads to being forced into predestination, which also flies in the face of omnipotence…

At least very powerful, but not infinitely powerful, gods like in ancient Greece do not have this problem. I find Zeus more plausible (but still arbitrary) than Yahweh.