I see it as a way to reconcile religious terminology with concepts that actually exist. In a way it’s bringing their supernatural ideas back to the natural world. It helps me argue with theists better.
But what is the value of “reconciling religious terminology”. What is the value of calling reality, nature, existence with the term God.
I claim to be an objectivist but also a pantheist, I don’t see any difference in the view of reality. I don’t think they contradict each other so it should be alright (unless I’m mistaken, then I will be an objectivist only). As I said before, my pantheism acts merely as a reconciliation of terminology.
What i argue is that you are an atheist, who just for some reason calls existence, nature etc. God instead of calling them by their real names. And that makes absolutely no sense to me.
Pantheism still has the theism in it, and by theism we usually mean belief in a deity(or many), that posess supernatural powers, and are supreme beings. If you have some alternative explanation on the what the word theism means, please tell me.
I just cant understand the value of giving validity to the religious nuts to believe in a God, by yourself calling the universe God, even though you mean completely the opposite by this word.
Just like the belief in unicorns. We have
“unicornists” - those who believe in that unicorns, magical horselike creatures with horns on their forehead, exist
a-unicornists - those who do not believe in unicorns & those who affirm that unicorns do not exist
agnostics - those who do not “know” whether unicorns exist
In this case, what would the value be of calling yourself a
horse-unicornist - those who affirm that there are no horselike creatures with horns on their forehead, but that what they mean by the term unicorn is actually everything that encompasses a horses organs, blood circulation system, bones, hair etc. In other words, what they mean, is a horse, but they call them unicorns.
Why not call yourself an a-unicornist, and call horses horses?
You’re mistaken. Objectivism is only compatible with atheism.
Exactly, but i think he really is one…
The only explanation for why people call themselves pantheists, would be if they had been raised really religiously, and the idea of a God was so ingrained in their upbringing that they have found it necessary to redefine the word God, once they realized that their Christian/Muslim etc. beliefs were BS, because they are not capable for some reason to give up on the idea of God…
But still, what is the value of calling yourself a pantheist, if the only thing how it differs from atheism, is that it has different words for some things…
edit: slightly off-topic, but as i was browsing different articles on wikipedia i found this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antireligion scroll down to the “Notable antireligious people” part and you will find:
Ayn Rand, novelist and libertarian philosopher, critic of homosexuality, founder of the objectivist school of metaphysics, famous for writing Atlas Shrugged and The Virtue of Selfishness.
first of all, the libertarian part obviously struck my eye, but what is weird is that “critic of homosexuality” is listed in such a short summation of Ayn Rand. Sure, she was a critic, but that is not in any way a cornerstone of her philosophy, so why would someone add it in such a short summation…