Hello,
Recently I have been discussing the topic of the Objectivist Metaphysics, and have found something that I need clarification with. I hope somebody can assist me.
on page 31 of OPAR, Mr. Peikoff states, " Is God infinite “infinite” does note mean large’ it means larger than any specific quantity, i.e., of no specific quantity. An infinite quantity would be a quantity without identity. But A is A. Every entity, accordingly, is finite; it is limited in the number of its qualities and in their extent; this applies to the universe as well"
However, both Peikoff and Rand acknowledge that existence must have always existed. They have stated that the axiom of existence exists, encompasses the concept: Existence always has been, is, and will be.
I don’t remember where this information is cited, but I am aware that the Objectivist definition of time is a measurement between two things. This solves the problem of time being infinite as there can be no infinity. Time is always a finite and specific quantity, regardless of how large the measurement of time is.
My problem then, is my ability to make sense of how the existence always has been and always will be, yet can not be infinite. I have a some ideas, but I am curious as to whether I am missing something.
Thank you for your help!
The Universe has a finite beginning in the past under any constant time-unit, as has been proven by physics (see Linde, Linde, and Mezhlumian, “From the Big Bang Theory to the Theory of a Stationary Universe”). Additionally, prominent singularity theorems assert that there existed a singularity point approaching infinite density and approaching zero size which gave birth to the universe as it is.
I always say that the more I see of the world, the more I like Ayn Rand. Rand, not familiar with this very technical theorem (as she wasn’t properly a physicist), asserted through philosophical consideration - and quite correctly so - that the Universe, while eternal, is finite in internal quality. Although she and Peikoff are quite correct in stating that existence qua existence has no relational quantity with time, and is thus eternal in the technical philosophical sense (i.e. literally outside of time), this doesn’t mean that internal actions cannot be considered via means of an analysis of the impossibility of an infinite set of causal history.
More modern and less fundamental thinking Christian theists from the Aristotelean school of thought - like my friend Dr. Bill Craig, whom I hold in the same “half respect” regard (although in a less important modern sense) as Ayn Rand held Aquinas - holds, as Rand does, that the set of causation is finite, and thus leads to God:
-
Everything that begins to exist has a cause;
-
The Universe began to exist;
-
Therefore, the Universe has a cause.
Now, as Dr. Peikoff has pointed out in a recent radio broadcast, there’s a problem with Premise 2. The Universe is the set of everything that exists. It is permanent. But Dr. Craig has faced this criticism before, but Craig clarifies, in a sense, that what he means here is that the Universe sprang from a First Cause, as the Big Bang Theory asserts.
Peikoff is absolutely right. And so is Craig. But, while Craig is additionally correct that this First Cause is internally and externally timeless (similar to Rand’s sense of “eternal”), he is wrong in asserting that the First Cause is a conscious Divine being willing the matter, energy, and motion of our Universe out of literally nothing through a (timelessly existing!?) “completely free” decision.
Craig is asserting that the Big Bang theory in physics mirrors the metaphysical necessity for a finite causal history and proves that, as Rand already anticipated in Galt’s speech (paraphrased): God created everything that exists from nothing by means of arbitrary whim. This doesn’t seem like an attractive option.
Unfortunately for Craig and completely in line with Rand - a strict author and philosopher not knowing of the deep physics itself - the Big Bang theory implies that the Singularity caused the Universe, since it actually existed and since it must, by philosophy AND by physics, contain all constituents of matter and energy (fermions and bosons, etc.) superimposed in a state with infinitesimal size (which is fine, because these fundamental building blocks themselves have infinitesimal size).
Applying any time unit to this process (i.e. any unit of relational motion ) yields that this cosmic singularity existed only at t=0, i.e. it did not exist necessarily for any duration of time. Therefore, it is argued by some people ascribing to the floating concept of some “absolute notion of time” that this singularity therefore couldn’t have technically existed. But not only does physics point to a relational need for time, philosophy does as well, since time is necessarily an epistemological assessment of a constant metaphysical relation (i.e. “second” epistemologically is related to the metaphysical motion of light over a set small displacement). In metaphysics, we do not have some “god clock” to relay the race; we only have causation and motion of the fundamental existents of reality. Period.
And what is happening at this supposedly “impossible” t=0? The Universe, by the necessary proof of mathematics in accordance to data that has been properly observed and interpreted in physics, existed “at this time” in a motionless, distanceless state. There was no “time” that the universe existed in this state, nor was there a “time before t=0” where this state didn’t exist, as lesser theists screaming that atheists believe that the Universe arose from nothing constantly blather. This is where Rand and Peikoff truly come in - not only is there no external referent, as they correctly state, but there is not an internal referent, either. At “t=0,” the cosmic singularity isn’t “there for a vanishing instant.” Since there is no motion, it simply _ is. _ It doesn’t “spring from the nothing before”; there is no “before” and there is no “nothing,” since existence exists and the fundamental constituents of reality are necessarily eternal philosophically and physically, as discussed above.
At the “t=0” Cosmic Singularity State, in short, the Universe simply was . Just as it simply _ is _ today. Only, no motion marked any internal time.
How could such a state cause the Universe to exist in its (internally and externally) timeless state? In that state, all fundamental components of matter existed in a hyper-superimposed state, with the spins of the fermions granting absolute “instability,” similar to an unstable atom today. So, although the Singularity existed in a timeless state, the instability of its components in internal relation necessarily entailed separation, meaning: motion, and therefore time and space, as a necessary result.
Do not confuse the Singularity with some sort of pellet existing in some infinite space hanging out for some past-infinite time before the Big Bang. There is no “space outside the Universe,” even in this superimposed state, since all components of existence existed within this state, providing no referent for “space” (imagining the Singularity from the outside with your mind does not count; the metaphysical existents making up your mind precedes such imaginary placement “outside” because all components of existence are “inside”). Likewise, it did not “hang around for a past-infinite amount of time,” since there is no motion internally and externally and therefore no time at all. The singularity birthed space and time from this state due to the identities of the constituents contained within. It is not only a sufficient cause of the Universe, but due to the equations of Special Relativity and especially the Second Law of Thermodynamics, coupled with the Law of Conservation of Matter, it is the necessary cause, one that - again by the Law of Conservation - could not itself have been farted out of nothing by some hypothetical, contradictory Triune God, or any being for that matter.