While having a conversation about space and time with my 5 year old little boy, he made a statement I found myself unable to disagree with, but I believe rejects a premise of Objectivism (and possibly of Aristotle’s). My son has always been fascinated with oxymorons and likes to point them out whenever he notices one (He did this when I once told him that going to his room was his “only choice,” so he’d better do it. “That’s an oxymoron,” he said “choice means more than one”.)
So, this morning in our car ride to school, during a conversation about the infinite and finite nature of things, I made the statement to him that “Infinity suggests a potential but not an actual.” When I asked him if that made sense he said it did, then he said, “Actually, no.” He understands the word potential roughly as something that “could be” so he said something to the effect of, “[You said infinity can’t ever be real (actual), so then how can it be a potential?] That’s an oxymoron!”. Basically, a potential to be what?
My struggled response was that infinity is an “idea” (concept) and that can be imagined but cannot ever be real. He says, “Like God?” (lol… whole different subject). In any event, we ended the conversation with him hopping out of the car for school and saying essentially, “[if it can’t be then you can’t say it is a potential]”.
So I’m stuck trying to explain how infinity can never exist but can still be considered a “potential”. Any help would be appreciated on that.
Two references:
An arithmetical sequence extends into infinity, without implying that infinity actually exists; such extension means only that whatever number of units does exist, it is to be included in the same sequence.
-Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology, 22.
There is a use of [the concept] “infinity” which is valid, as Aristotle observed, and that is the mathematical use. It is valid only when used to indicate a potentiality, never an actuality. Take the number series as an example. You can say it is infinite in the sense that, no matter how many numbers you count, there is always another number. You can always keep on counting; there’s no end. In that sense it is infinite—as a potential. But notice that, actually, however many numbers you count, wherever you stop, you only reached that point, you only got so far . . . . That’s Aristotle’s point that the actual is always finite. Infinity exists only in the form of the ability of certain series to be extended indefinitely; but however much they are extended, in actual fact, wherever you stop it is finite.
-Leonard Peikoff, “The Philosophy of Objectivism” | lecture series (1976), Lecture 3.
What Rand wrote in ITOE is perfectly logical and correct. I don’t think it follows to call infinity a potential though.
_______
As a corollary issue, can someone help me out with a seeming contradiction in the Objectivist’s definition of the Universe, versus the dictionary definition?
Peikoff says (in The Philosophy of Objectivism lecture):
"
The universe is the total of that which exists—not merely the earth or the stars or the galaxies, but everything."
This allows it to logically follow that there is not (and can never be) *anything* outside the universe. True, if that is the definition.
:
universe
- the totality of
known or supposed
objects and phenomena throughout space; the cosmos; macrocosm.
universe
-
- the whole body of things and phenomena
observed or postulated
What the dictionary does (as Objectivism normally does) is leave out the arbitrary. The “unknown unknowns” are outside of, or not part of, the universe until the moment that they are postulated or known about (according to the dictionaries).
The issue with Peikoff’s definition that I’m wondering about is that he is setting up one of two possible contradictions:
a.) He is considering the arbitrary and all potentials inside his definition of universe so as to be able to say that “Everything which exists is finite, including the universe.”
~or~
b.) He is NOT considering the arbitrary, unknown, or yet-to-be-postulated as part of what would then be an “evolving” definition of an expanding, and then necessarily, potentially INFINITE universe. (Which also contradicts the statement that “Everything which exists is finite, including the universe.”)