In fact, now that I have a deeper understanding about Cato, I believe almost all the name calling between libertarians and objectivists is irrational. I have come to appreciate that all objectivists are libertarians, but not all libertarians are objectivists.
In fact, now that I have a deeper understanding about Cato, I believe almost all the name calling between libertarians and objectivists is irrational. I have come to appreciate that all objectivists are libertarians, but not all libertarians are objectivists.
Today David Weigel has rehashed the above at Slate, this time adding in material that takes ARI to task over foreign policy. The fact that he makes no acknowledgement of the diversity of opinion within “Objectivism” on this matter is something I find irritating.
Today David Weigel has rehashed the above at Slate, this time adding in material that takes ARI to task over foreign policy. The fact that he makes no acknowledgement of the diversity of opinion within “Objectivism” on this matter is something I find irritating.
Objectivism is the philosophy of Ayn Rand. How is there diversity of opinion within it? Are you suggesting she was schizophrenic?
Objectivism is the philosophy of Ayn Rand. How is there diversity of opinion within it? Are you suggesting she was schizophrenic?
Did you read the article? And did you notice that I used scare quotes?
The way this strikes in the real world—the way it separates objectivists from other libertarians—is in foreign policy. Since the war on terror broke out, Cato’s been a bunker for non-interventionists. Its foreign-policy shop is staffed with critics of the Iraq war.
Objectivists don’t see foreign policy that way. The Ayn Rand Institute, founded in 1985 by Rand’s intellectual/financial heir Leonard Peikoff, has spun off arguments for war rooted in a philosophy of self-preservation.
Weigel is equating Objectivism with ARI’s foreign policy. I’m saying I find that irritating. There are plenty of Objectivists who disagree with the ARI foreign policy. Are we on the same page now?
Did you read the article? And did you notice that I used scare quotes?
Weigel is equating Objectivism with ARI’s foreign policy. I’m saying I find that irritating. There are plenty of Objectivists who disagree with the ARI foreign policy. Are we on the same page now?
No. The opinions of Objectivists are only relevant to the extent they are the one position which is in accordance with Objectivism, and entirely irrelevant otherwise. And the way to determine that correct position has nothing to do with submitting it to a vote, or anything like that.
Objectivism does have a position on foreign policy, and that position isn’t open to contradictions. So there cannot be several valid yet contradictory positions on foreign policy, held by Objectivists. If you’re gonna address Objectivism as it relates to modern foreign policy, you have to pick one interpretation as the correct one first, and dismiss all the incorrect ones. It makes no difference whether Objectivists would agree with you, your starting point should always be Ayn Rand’s philosophy, not what her followers believe.
I don’t see anything wrong with David Weigel’s approach here. Not only has ARI been lead by Rand’s close friend and intellectual heir, but Ayn Rand herself was very clear on both the morality of a free nation sacrificing its own defense for the sake of protecting lives in an enemy country, and on the evil, savage nature of Islamist terror.
But maybe you do see something wrong with it. And you’re welcome to explain what is wrong with it. But so far, you haven’t. Bringing up the fact that he is ignoring the opinions of some Objectivists is not a valid point. Unless he has evidence that those opinons are correct, he should ignore them. He did in fact give clear indications that he believes ARI’s interpretation to be the correct one.
I don’t see anything wrong with David Weigel’s approach here. Not only has ARI been lead by Rand’s close friend and intellectual heir,
Lead indeed.
I’m not interested in starting a debate about foreign policy with you. This ground has been well tread, and frankly you’re not worth talking to. If you had ever acknowledged being wrong about the date rape imbroglio I might credit you with some intellectual honesty and feel it worth my time to provide links to prior discussions of the issue. As it is, I’ve long since written you off as a hopeless case, and your earlier post (#65) shows your intent here on this thread, however ineptly executed it was. Go waste someone else’s time.
I don’t see anything wrong with David Weigel’s approach here. Not only has ARI been lead by Rand’s close friend and intellectual heir, but Ayn Rand herself was very clear on both the morality of a free nation sacrificing its own defense for the sake of protecting lives in an enemy country, and on the evil, savage nature of Islamist terror.
Kind of besides the point, since there is no intellectual heir (I’ve never seen Rand mention anything of it), and there is nothing about ARI that inherently gives it any authority in determining how Objectivism ought to be applied. It’s wrong for anyone to reason that ARI is anything besides an institution that applies Objectivism. Just because ARI has an official position doesn’t mean that anyone who disagrees is being inconsistent or contradicting Objectivism. Better to make references to Ayn Rand than ARI. Although in this case ARI probably matters, since Allison is affiliated with them.
Kind of besides the point, since there is no intellectual heir (I’ve never seen Rand mention anything of it), and there is nothing about ARI that inherently gives it any authority in determining how Objectivism ought to be applied. It’s wrong for anyone to reason that ARI is anything besides an institution that applies Objectivism. Just because ARI has an official position doesn’t mean that anyone who disagrees is being inconsistent or contradicting Objectivism. Better to make references to Ayn Rand than ARI. Although in this case ARI probably matters, since Allison is affiliated with them.
That’s not what I said. Ninth Doctor is upset that Weigel isn’t treating Objectivism as a collection of all the voices of everyone who is claiming to be an Objectivist.
I pointed out that that’s not what Objectivism is. Whether ARIs position is the right one is debatable, but whether two contradicting positions should both be treated as “the Objectivist position” is not. It has to be one or the other.
If Ninth Doctor had said that ARI is wrong, and the correct Objectivist position is to be opposed to so called
interventionist wars, then at least he’d be trying to assert and defend his position. Instead, he wants it to be mentioned whenever Ayn Rand’s philosophy is mentioned, just because he says he’s an Objectivist.
It’s wrong for anyone to reason that ARI is anything besides an institution that applies Objectivism.
Read the article. That’s not his reasoning. He presents a substantive argument as to why ARIs position is the correct application of Objectivism. Nowhere does he suggest that whatever ARI says is automatically Objectivism.
Today David Weigel has rehashed the above at Slate, this time adding in material that takes ARI to task over foreign policy. The fact that he makes no acknowledgement of the diversity of opinion within “Objectivism” on this matter is something I find irritating.
And here’s another one, a bit longer, and not too much overlap, from the American Conservative. It’s funny to see a non-Objectivist saying such and such “should provoke an excommunication from ARI”. He’s suggesting that otherwise John Allison is practicing duplicity. I, for one, am inclined to take John Allison’s latest statement, the one to Cato staffers, at face value. And I expect his “excommunication” to come about as quickly as Alan Greenspan’s. Meaning, not quickly at all.
He links to my video, and I just checked the analytics on it. One interesting fact, this even surprises me, is the demographics of the viewership. 88% male, 12% female.
He links to my video, and I just checked the analytics on it. One interesting fact, this even surprises me, is the demographics of the viewership. 88% male, 12% female.
Why is that surprising? Women generally are not into such abstractions. Math, science, Objectivism, theology, 80:20 is about the typical male:female ratio.
Why is that surprising? Women generally are not into such abstractions. Math, science, Objectivism, theology, 80:20 is about the typical male:female ratio.
I would expect 60:40, or 70:30. 80:20 goes beyond my experience. 88:12, way beyond.
The Ayn Rand Institute (ARI) announced today that John Allison, a member of the Institute’s Board of Directors, has decided to resign from the Board, noting a desire to reduce his professional commitments and devote full energies to his new position as chief executive officer and President of the Cato Institute in Washington, D.C.
Hmmm. It might mean just what it says. This is also consistent with the theory that Peikoff’s influence over the ARI Board is strong, strong enough to be described as “conform or be cast out”. Whatever, I won’t be boycotting ARI or taking any other special action.
I look forward to Cato becoming equal to and surpassing ARI in its policy analysis and advocacy work.
FWIW, I’m disinclined to take ARI’s latest statement at face value. OTOH, I don’t believe this was an excommunication. A has not entirely been A when it comes to this topic, so I’ll just leave it at that.
I look forward to Cato becoming equal to and surpassing ARI in its policy analysis and advocacy work.
I can’t imagine by what measure you would conclude that it’s Cato that has catching up to do. You might disagree with them on policies, but they’re one of the top think tanks, ARI is not nearly as influential.
I can’t imagine by what measure you would conclude that it’s Cato that has catching up to do. You might disagree with them on policies, but they’re one of the top think tanks, ARI is not nearly as influential.
Yes, by the objective measures of amount of papers published or influence measured in citations Cato is already way ahead. I look forward to Cato being more consistent with Objectivism in its conclusions about issues of the day, and more productive than ARI at doing it.
I’d like to see the ARI become more consistent with Objectivism.
First you need to review the forum rules as insulting comments about ARI are not allowed.
Then, if you can manage to conduct yourself according to those rules, you’ll have to provide evidence for this extremely insulting comment. As far as I can tell ARI is perfectly consistent with Objectivism.
First you need to review the forum rules as insulting comments about ARI are not allowed.
I haven’t insulted the ARI.
Are you taking the position that every opinion issued by anyone at the ARI must, by definition, be consistent with Objectivism? In other words, are you saying that it is not possible for the people at ARI to err in their interpretations or attempted applications of Objectivism, and that to even suggest the possibility of their lack of infallibility is an extremely vicious insult?
Then, if you can manage to conduct yourself according to those rules, you’ll have to provide evidence for this extremely insulting comment. As far as I can tell ARI is perfectly consistent with Objectivism.
Let’s start with just one example to begin with. The ARI’s position on the “ground zero mosque” is that those who wished to build it are enemies who constitute an immediate threat to our metaphysical survival, and, therefore, that the solution to stopping the threat and saving ourselves from extermination is to oppose the construction of a single building in a symbolic location, while allowing the alleged enemies to continue to walk freely amongst us!
It’s not a rational or Objectivist position to take. It’s the advocacy of the violation of others’ property rights, as well a subversion of due process and of proof and of individual accountability. The ARI’s position is an example of treating people collectivistically and trying to establish guilt by association, and of thinking in non-essentials and non sequiturs.
Here’s a little detail I didn’t know till now. We all know David Kelley was excommunicated for speaking at Laissez Faire Books. I think there was more to it, but be that as it may. Turns out John Aglialoro was excommunicated for speaking at…wait for it…The Cato Institute. Does he expect John Allison to suffer the same fate?
TAC: So do you expect him to be excommunicated?
JA: I think there’s been a change of mentality. Yaron Brook is now executive director of ARI, and I think Leonard gave him the sanction to carry on. They’re now joining the ranks of society, philosophical society. The libertarian, the political; it’s not just up here [gestures with his hands]. [Working with libertarians] is no longer anathema.